4 ms·
I picked David because his achievements seemed more concrete. The "marketing" and "sustainability" stuff sounded like fluff to me. I didn't read much more of
by melling 17y ago
I picked David because his achievements seemed more concrete. The "marketing" and "sustainability" stuff sounded like fluff to me. I didn't read much more of the article after I found out he chose the other guy.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoIt's not just that he picked the other guy, he expects everyone to agree with him, and yet like you I chose the "wrong" guy. Explaining the "amazing" reason that everyone picks his choice seems much less impressive at that point, particularly as it mostly seems like an ad for a book. Does anyone actually talk like this (from the comments): It’s interesting that you mention science fairs. I actually have a chapter in my new book where I take the awe-inspiring resumes of two Intel winners, then break down, step by step, the reality of their achievement
- nostrademons 17y agoI suspect that Hacker News has a bit of selection bias, in that most of the people here are driven, success-oriented individuals who'd like to believe that hard work makes a difference. We've already read all the articles about how success comes from diligence and practice, and that feats that seem superhuman are just the result of focused effort over time. In my personal experience, the majority of people do not think like this. When I was going through grade school, my parents/teachers/etc. often did use words like "awe-inspiring achievements", even for fairly mundane things like getting perfect scores on standardized tests. I got into Amherst through a process very much like the article describes (I had terrible grades but had worked at an all-teenage dot-com startup and aced my standardized tests). In the "brag session" where the director of admissions lists all the awe-inspiring resumes of the incoming freshman class, she said "And one of the students passed 8 AP tests without taking a single AP class", and a murmur of appreciation passed along the crowd. Really, it's not that hard, you read a book and then you pay $75 for a test - but most of them don't know that. I think it's great that there's more understanding going around of what achievement actually stems from. But that understanding certainly isn't universal, and in the meantime, you can hack people's perceptions of you by playing to the blind spots in their own knowledge. "Everything is impossible until I know how to do it, and then it's trivial."
- jacobolus 17y ago> passed 8 AP tests without taking a single AP class Passing AP tests is impressive? Whoa.
- nostrademons 17y agoThat was my thought too, but a surprisingly large number of people were impressed. Which was the article's point. There's no accounting for taste, I guess. (Well, actually there is an accounting for taste, and that's what the article was about. People can be irrational and yet have perfectly rational explanations for their irrationality.)
- kiba 17y agoI also choose David over Steve. Maybe it's because I have a disdain for politics. The ability to cause havocs in UN meetings would more impressed me. Competing with the United States Post Office and then crushing them is also an incredibly impressive to me. What I would search for, as a college admission office is people who is likely to defy authorities and be massively right. If I can get that guy into college, then that's the greatest achievement I could hope for, because this guy will have massive positive impact in this world. I don't need Obamas people, but I would like more Talebs people in my school.
- jacobolus 17y agoYou know a lot of high school students with “massively right” unique insights into the world that no one has thought of before? Enough to make up a freshman class at a mid-sized school?
- kiba 17y agoYou know a lot of high school students with “massively right” unique insights into the world that no one has thought of before? Enough to make up a freshman class at a mid-sized school? Just one guy/gal in his lifetime is what a college admission officer would hope for in his entire career. That's all he need to cause a revolution in a field. The problem is of course, how to find the genuine article in a pool full of candidates sprouting impressive grades and other distracting signals which are probably incidental or have nothing to do with massively right insights generators. My guesses and your guesses is probably as good as the college admission officers. The chance of scoring a direct hit because the officer was able to correctly reasoned that this guy is what he's looking for is probably incredibly low.
- mwerty 17y agoI have a hypothesis that one way to drastically reduce the amount of volunteering going on is to not consider it in college/MBA admissions. Every one of my friends who has volunteered has coincidentally highlighted that experience in some admissions essay two years later.
- lotharbot 17y agoThe article makes the mistake of confusing "surprising" for "impressive". Steve's accomplishments are surprising. I wouldn't have the slightest idea how he went about them; I'd have to ask to get the full story. (The article names this the "failed simulation effect".) I totally agree with you that it sounds like fluff, but it's unusual fluff. David's accomplishments are unsurprising. I know exactly how one gets to be the captain of a varsity sports team while keeping up an interesting hobby outside of school. Impressive, concrete, but doesn't provoke any further questioning from me. I wouldn't pick either of them just from a few sentences. I'd want to see the full essays.
- shadowsun7 17y agoThe article makes the mistake of confusing "surprising" for "impressive". Good point there. After reading your comment I reread the article, and it does seem more reasonable to replace all mentions of "impressive" with "surprising". That being said, to an academic reviewer, surprising may very well equal impressive, especially when the transcript is read along with a thousand others ...
- jamesbritt 17y agoSame here. David seemed remarkable self-assured; who takes calligraphy all through high school? It's sure not a peer-pressure thing. Meanwhile Steve may have some lofty motivations for his career path, but it says nothing about how well he actually does these things. FTA: "He’s not brilliant. super passionate, or ultra-hard working — instead, he accomplished something that’s hard to explain. " And that impresses people?
- wakeupthedawn 17y agoAs someone who actually goes to top school, I cannot even fathom how someone would think that being captain of a track team and learning calligraphy would be more impressive than lobby U.N. delegates. Track captains are a dime a dozen and there is nothing "impressive" about signing up for calligraphy class. Maybe those were the easy classes at his school - I don't know. But there's nothing inherently impressive about taking calligraphy. I don't even know why you would put that on your resume unless you were going to write an essay about it. Working with the UN as a high schooler is something that grabs the attention of an admissions officer. I'm sure his essay about the experience sealed the deal.
- r00k 17y agoI think your reply would have been a lot more persuasive without "As someone who actually goes to a top school..." It sounds like bragging. And worse: it doesn't do anything for your argument. (And for the record, I agree with you.)
- jacobolus 17y agoIt gives him somewhat more direct insight, having experience with what such students are like. He clearly meant it in that light. What would he possibly get from bragging? (People who go to top schools are a dime a dozen, after all. ;-)
- petercooper 17y agothere is nothing "impressive" about signing up for calligraphy class. Maybe those were the easy classes at his school - I don't know. But there's nothing inherently impressive about taking calligraphy. I don't even know why you would put that on your resume unless you were going to write an essay about it. Steve Jobs seems to think it was a big deal: http://www.google.com/search?q=steve+jobs+calligraphy http://www.google.com/search?q=steve+jobs+calligraphy
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sharms 17y ago
- JangoSteve 17y agoI chose Steve because he spent his time doing something that affects people other than himself. Most people I know have some aversion to changing the status quo. David has impressive accomplishments are of no importance to anyone but himself, so the state of things before and after David's accomplishments are more or less the same. In other words, I'm impressed with Steve, not because I'm comparing the amount of work and effort they each put forth, but because Steve chooses to spend his time and efforts changing things.