3 ms·
The issue where people can be convicted for these crimes for public urination and similar is extremely important, but also completely separate. People like that
by mikeash 10y ago
The issue where people can be convicted for these crimes for public urination and similar is extremely important, but also completely separate. People like that shouldn't be on parole in the first place. Considering that they're probably being jailed, complaining about a Pokemon Go restriction because some of the targeted people may have committed a minor crime doesn't make any sense to me.
It's like saying that we shouldn't restrict prisoners' phone calls, because that's unfair to the wrongly convicted. It's technically true, but being wrongly convicted in the first place is far more important.
- Retric 10y agoParole is actually a safety valve in such cases, you might serve a few days in prison and then have X months / years of monitoring. Prison is a rather separate situation, but they still let most prisoners read for example.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> People like that shouldn't be on parole in the first place. But they are, so we have to consider them when writing new laws that will impact them. I agree that them being jailed/on parole at all is the greater injustice here, but that doesn't mean we can just wave this off.
- Retric 10y agoJust to add, the innocent people in prison is an important factor. For example it's a bad idea to simply execute people on death row right now. We have already released 20 people on death row we realized where innocent, how many more are wrongfully convicted?
- mikeash 10y agoThat's because execution is irreversible. Are there any examples of taking innocence into account when it comes to reversible punishments?
- Retric 10y ago> execution is irreversible So is prison. Lock someone up for 20 years and they never get that time back. Parole is actually used as reversible punishment in the other direction. Stay clean and your free to go, do even minor things and your instantly in prison. First offence leniency has a similar rational.
- mikeash 10y agoI tend to agree with you, but that's not how the system works. Whether or not prison is actually reversible, it's treated as though it were, by releasing and possibly compensating innocents.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> That's because execution is irreversible. Not only irreversible, but not even partially compensable. Prison is arguably irreversible (you can't rewind and make it so people didn't spend time in prison), but you can at least let people out without finishing the complete sentence when you discover a problem with it, and you can give them some form of compensation. You can't stop someone from being dead after executing them, or compensate them (even imperfectly) for it.