4 ms·
> The largest tax break relates to health care: it makes the premiums paid by companies that offer health insurance exempt from payroll taxes. We really shoul
by koolba 10y ago
> The largest tax break relates to health care: it makes the premiums paid by companies that offer health insurance exempt from payroll taxes.
We really should start with that one. If anything, replace it with an individual deduction. It'll be a double-whammy. Get rid of this bullshit subsidy for large corporations and at the same time level the playing field for small businesses and individuals trying to get coverage.
- nickff 10y agoThe health insurance exemption only helps the healthcare industry; without this exemption, people would rather be paid cash than get expensive extra healthcare benefits. People would probably rather buy their own health insurance than have an employer choose it, and most employers would rather offload the trouble of managing health insurance (as many have healthcare departments, which is not their core competency). Unfortunately the Affordable Care Act (A.K.A. ACA, Obamacare) cemented employer-purchased healthcare into place with the employer mandate.
- lotsofpulp 10y agoI think it's also possible that a large employer being able to offer health insurance much more cheaply per employee than a small employer can gives the large employer that much more advantage over the small one for no reason.
- nickff 10y agoThat is a very good point, and I have never looked at it that way. Unfortunately, this is exactly what we should expect, as governments usually consult large organizations for feedback, and small (or as-yet unformed) organizations are put at a great disadvantage.
- venomsnake 10y agoAnd it is a way to a job serfdom - the cost of unemployment is greater. And - is anything worth risking my family health plans for? Employer provided insurance should stop existing.
- stanleydrew 10y agoThe ACA was directionally correct in terms of the individual mandate though, and hard enough to pass as it was. I would expect with a Hillary presidency we'll see more progress made towards separating employment and healthcare.
- koolba 10y ago> The ACA was directionally correct in terms of the individual mandate though, and hard enough to pass as it was. The ACA was a cop out. If you're not going to go to either single payer or at least include a public option (i.e. buy into the equivalent of public Medicare) then it's all a way to force people to send money to insurance companies. The Dems had a supermajority in the senate but either didn't have the balls to do the right thing, or, more likely, just wanted to suck up to their corporate interests. > I would expect with a Hillary presidency we'll see more progress made towards separating employment and healthcare. Ha! I'm sure she'll be just as tough on Wall street too.
- lotsofpulp 10y agoIt really shows how corrupt the system is. If you buy insurance yourself on the exchange, then you pay with post tax dollars. If you happen to work for a large company whose population is obviously more desirable to insure, then you get a huge discount on health insurance. If you're a small employer employing people on the lower end of the economic scale, then you pay through the roof if you want to buy a group health plan because your population is probably not too desirable, and if you try to reimburse your employees for their own individually purchased health insurance (because you don't have time to deal with all the stupid health insurance laws like COBRA and stuff), then you also pay with post tax dollars. Using the tax code as a political bargaining chip is a time honored tradition that, unfortunately, isn't going away soon.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> If you buy insurance yourself on the exchange, then you pay with post tax dollars. It's deductible at tax time, though.
- ams6110 10y agoCan you pay the premium out of an HSA? That's pre-tax.
- ceejayoz 10y agoTo my knowledge you can only do that if it's COBRA or a few other fairly unusual situations.
- chiph 10y agoMy reading of IRS publication 502 is that you can pay COBRA premiums, medicare, and premiums if you are on unemployment, but not otherwise.
- koolba 10y agoNo an HSA is for out of pocket expenses. Monthly premiums cannot be paid from it.
- 10y ago
- fweespeech 10y ago> We really should start with that one. If anything, replace it with an individual deduction. It'll be a double-whammy. Get rid of this bullshit subsidy for large corporations and at the same time level the playing field for small businesses and individuals trying to get coverage. We really should just drop both and replace it with an increase in the standard deduction for individuals.
- maxerickson 10y agoGiven that deductions come out of top bracket income, it might be more fair to adjust the brackets and reduce the standard deduction. Of course it all depends on what the hell fair means. The people with income in higher brackets are still paying more taxes after deductions.
- fweespeech 10y agoI'd say the poorer you are, the more you need the tax deductions honestly.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIt really does not matter if they're tax exempt at payroll disbursement time or as a deduction on filings. The trouble with employer-based health care is much more about the fact that employers get a volume discount that individuals or small businesses do not. Even then when Ive worked W2 contract, I've had health care offered by the contracting company for reasonable amounts.