3 ms·
I'm interested but not particularly surprised to see everyone here against this move. These people are out on parole. That means that they could be in prison i
by mikeash 10y ago
I'm interested but not particularly surprised to see everyone here against this move.
These people are out on parole. That means that they could be in prison instead, but the authorities have decided to be nice and let them out early under supervision. They can be sent back to prison for simple things like associating with the wrong people, or failing to tell the government about their movements.
This restriction doesn't seem terribly useful to me, but nor does it seem particularly onerous.
- tn13 10y ago>These people are out on parole. That means that they could be in prison instead Will you be fine if people are allowed to beat up an inmate scheduled for death penalty ? How does it really matter if we break a few bones right before he is dead ? I think the logic is the whole "sex offender" registry is bullshit. Check what sort of things can get you on that list. So people on parole are not necessarily hardened horrible criminals we should despise. Even if they are bad people why should not be they allowed to play a game ? How on earth do we even enforce such restriction? Creating restrictions that can not be enforced reduces overall respect for law. Tomorrow the politician will say Itunes should not sell pop songs of teenage singers to such people are we supposed to comply ? I see this as sex war pretty much like drug war.
- mikeash 10y agoI don't see how beating up death row inmates is analogous. I don't support the death penalty at all, but even ignoring that I don't support physical violence against prisoners, no matter how guilty. I do, however, support punishing criminals. And since letting criminals out on parole is a nice thing we do for them, not a requirement, I think we should consider the fact that these people could easily still be in prison instead. If they hadn't been paroled then they wouldn't be able to play Pokemon Go either, and they'd have a bunch of other restrictions on their lives besides.
- morgante 10y agoI don't think it will have any impact either way. Any danger of sex offenders using Pokemon Go to lure children is vastly overstated, but I also agree that people out on parole can be subject to restrictions. It's mostly a waste of taxpayer time to be considering this. Most of the negativity is really about the attitude that Pokemon Go is somehow dangerous. I also find it a little troubling that Niantic is being compelled to review user data in a search for "criminals."
- mikeash 10y agoWhy is "criminals" in quotes there? These are people who have been convicted of crimes and are still serving their sentences.
- morgante 10y agoIt's in quotes because I suspect the threat of sex offenders actually playing Pokemon Go is minimal. There's no reason that the government should be able to force Niantic to search for arbitrary lists of users without a court order.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoHow onerous it may be is irrelevant. The government shouldn't do things that aren't useful. This is exactly as stupid as a law requiring paroled sex offenders to stand on their heads and whistle Yankee Doodle each morning.
- mikeash 10y agoGovernments so often do things that are destructive that I welcome it when they merely do something that wastes their time.
- aianus 10y agoThey also want to restrict Niantic from creating pokestops near sex offenders' homes which is ridiculous.
- lojack 10y ago> nor does it seem particularly onerous I disagree for reasons other than putting a burden on parolees. To me, this is effort wasted on our legal system in drafting, passing, arguing against, and ultimately maintaining when its no longer relevant. Additionally it places a burden on Niantic, and any company that builds similar products, to cross reference their customer list with the list of NY sex offenders (and potentially other similar lists of states that follow suit). In my opinion, any potential payoff from this is so small that it's almost certainly something we could do without.
- pgodzin 10y agoIt's also impossible to cross-reference since all you need to play is a Google account
- mikeash 10y agoSex offenders in New York are required to give the government information about all of their accounts online, so it would be easy to reference against that list. I'm sure it's easy to refrain from doing so and not get caught, but it's something.
- pgodzin 10y agoDidn't realize that was part of it. But yea, creating a dummy gmail address and only use it for Pokemon Go seems extremely easy to do and not get caught.
- jaynos 10y ago3000 sex offenders are on parole? I wonder how many of them are potential threats and how many are the "took a piss on a playground at midnight while drunk with no children in sight" variety.
- jMyles 10y ago> potential threats Well, since "sex crime" (to the extent that this is even a cognizable category at all) has such a low recidivism rate, it's reasonable to say that they're aren't much of a threat to begin with. More than 90% of the perpetrators of crimes against children, including sex crimes, are personally known to those children.