3 ms·
There are several problems with sites like snopes and politifact. They are centralizing "truth", making themselves an authority, and creating a single point of
by colordrops 10y ago
There are several problems with sites like snopes and politifact. They are centralizing "truth", making themselves an authority, and creating a single point of failure. The information can be manipulated or misrepresented toward an agenda. Its even more powerful than mainstream media because people put more trust in these "truth" sites. Also, they make a judgement call with their meters and traffic light widgets as to the truth value of a claim. This is problematic because it makes judgement extrinsic, and creates a visual component that can be embedded out of context to drive people toward an opinion using only their emotions.
A better version of these sites would teach about how to source information and use critical thought, then list as many verified sources on a topic as possible without making a judgement themselves as to the truth of the matter.
- mod 10y agoI don't fully agree. They present contradictory or supporting evidence. I don't think that is presenting oneself as the authority. Merely the fact-checker. If you're saying they should present all the same evidence and NOT decide whether the claim is true or false--I think that's a pretty trivial point. When I read snopes, I look at their evidence, not their actual rating. I know they have a bias and I don't want to include it in my own decision.
- colordrops 10y ago> I look at their evidence, not their actual rating. Your behavior is not an indicator of behavior at large. The politifact truth-o-meter is regularly embedded on Reddit and other sites out of context by those with an agenda.
- mod 10y agoAny source of information can be used improperly. We still owe it to ourselves to present facts without bias.
- hatsunearu 10y agoEspecially since politifact itself has shown political bias.