6 ms·
That argument would be more convincing if the original poster were not comparing SF to Sweden -- the country that essentially solved those problems in 1950-1980
by pavlov 10y ago
That argument would be more convincing if the original poster were not comparing SF to Sweden -- the country that essentially solved those problems in 1950-1980 by having the most liberal and progressive government in the world.
- objectivistbrit 10y agoThose policies were both very expensive and caused a slowdown in economic growth. Sweden has rolled many of them back recently. https://mises.org/library/how-modern-sweden-profits-success-its-free-market-history https://mises.org/library/how-modern-sweden-profits-success-...
- pavlov 10y agoHow is that theoretical slowdown apparent in today's Stockholm? The city is a buzzing growth center, as wealthy on the surface as San Francisco, but without any of the obvious problems with "homelessness, the mentally ill, the dirtiness & shabbiness of the city" (which the grandparent poster wanted to blame on liberal government). You make it sound like Sweden in the '80s was a pseudo-Cuba. That was never the case.
- aminok 10y agoA slowdown is a remark on a change in trajectory, not a change in absolute position.
- Kurtz79 10y agoWeird that a right-wing liberatarian organization is criticizing liberal social policies... "The Mises Institute, founded in 1982, teaches the scholarship of Austrian economics, freedom, and peace... Accordingly, we seek a profound and radical shift in the intellectual climate: away from statism and toward a private property order."
- aminok 10y agoSo if one concluded, based on an impartial examination of economic facts, that free market economics is indeed the best way to foster economic development and standard of living gains, how should one promote such views without become an advocate of free market economics (and thus become discredited in your eyes)?
- Kurtz79 10y ago"based on an impartial examination of economic facts". That's a bold assumption to make. Facts are objective by definition, but their interpretation it's often not. The moment you state your objective if promote free market economics it's clear that you will give an interpretation of facts that goes towards validating that view. You can promote your views this way, but cannot expect people not to take a critical view of them. Just read anyhting from Paul Krugman on the NYT, and you will see equally partial interpretations of facts that come to very different conclusions.
- aminok 10y agoSo promoting any economic view discredits someone? Or just those you personally disagree with?
- Kurtz79 10y agoNo, have you read my post ? No problem in promoting your views, just not expect people to take them at face value, or as an "impartial examination of facts", when they are not.
- aminok 10y ago>just not expect people to take them at face value, Of course not. But no one asked you to take the views of the Mises Institute at face value. It appeared to me that you were implying they were biased, meaning not credible, based on the fact that they have endorsed free market economics since the 1950s. Which is an assumption that a group that regularly endorses a particular school of economic thought is biased toward that school of thought for reasons other than sound and impartial economic analysis. If I was misreading what you were implying, then I of course take my previous comments back.
- jazzyk 10y agoTrue, Sweden is clean and has no homelessness issues. But it is now quite segregated (not unlike France with its banlieus) full of not-homeless, but, unfortunately, un-assimilated population. A blog written by an American living in Sweden (check out the other posts on the blog as well): https://swedenreport.org/2015/05/18/police-yes-there-are-no-go-zones-in-sweden/ https://swedenreport.org/2015/05/18/police-yes-there-are-no-...
- pavlov 10y agoI'm not sure if "segregated" is the right word. The economic gap between Stockholm downtown and a suburb is smaller than, say, the gap between Washington D.C. and a small town in West Virginia. Does that mean the United States is hopelessly economically segregated, with permanently unassimilated redneck populations that refuse to join the urban mainstream? If that's an unfair interpretation, why make the same kind of rhetorical leaps about European cities?
- jazzyk 10y agoThe US is segregated with ghettos in NY, Chicago, Detroit, etc. But I was making a point about Sweden. If you checked the blog I referred to, entitled "Police: Yes, there ARE No-Go Zones in Sweden" you would learn that there are essentially lawless areas where the police concedes that they have indeed lost control. So "segregated" is the right word.
- pavlov 10y agoYou linked to a blog post with a large illustration depicting a "typical leftist Internet troll". I've spent over 30 years of my life in Nordic countries. These stories of embedded lawless mini-Afghanistans ruled by local Sharia tyrants don't reflect any reality I've ever seen.
- jazzyk 10y agoNo one is claiming that they are "lawless mini-Afghanistans" in Sweden, as you stated. (from the article I linked to: "To the best of my knowledge, there are no Shariah patrols in Sweden.") But there is enough evidence to state that there is segregation. "Segregation (noun): the action or state of setting someone or something apart from other people or things or being set apart."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mikaeluman 10y agoSick and tired of non-swedes thinking socialists ever did anything for this country. Nothing was "solved" by politics in those years. Quite the opposite, our lean and mean economy faltered until the socialists became fiscally conservative in the 90s. The sheer arrogance of Swedes dissing US is also annoying. Go to our new ghettos and inspect the great equity the progressives have established lately.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- EdSharkey 10y agoFiscally conservative ... socialism?? Huh. Now that would be something I'd like to see tried here in the United States! Waste is treated like an benign abstraction here: an assumed given of "bureaucratic overhead" that nothing can be done about except occasionally talk and handwave over. I'd guess you'd need to have a culture that encourages whistleblowing, snitches, and oversight to make fiscally conservative socialism work. Such a culture doesn't exist here in the US.
- ersii 10y agoUm, hm? I don't know how you get to "Fiscally conservative socialism". The previous comment said that the socialists (ie. Social Democrats, Left Party - previously known as The Communist Party) became somewhat fiscally conservative. There is a huge difference in how you would read that. The interpretation that you should go for is "The socialist being less socialist for the time being". In other words, they toned it down briefly. They're certainly at it again now. That said, there is plenty of waste and bureaucratic excess/largess in Sweden - and it's very hand-wavy and nothing can apparently be done to reduce it when you start talking about it. The last part of your comment I did not quite understand. What do you mean by having a culture that "encourages whistle blowing, snitches and oversight"? You mean that in order to have some kind of socialism to be fiscally conservative - you'd need whistle blowers that would rat out largess and snitch on people who waste State resources? If that is what you mean, we have some of that (whistle blowers) - but we also have way more waste than what covers whatever gets surfaced. They're also few and far between..
- mikaeluman 10y agoSick and tired of non-swedes thinking socialists ever did anything for this country. Nothing was "solved" by politics in those years. Quite the opposite, our lean and mean economy faltered until the socialists became fiscally conservative in the 90s. The sheer arrogance of Swedes dissing US is also annoying. Go to our new ghettos and inspect the great equity the progressives have established lately.
- powertower 10y ago> That argument would be more convincing if the original poster were not comparing SF to Sweden -- the country that essentially solved those problems in 1950-1980 by having the most liberal and progressive government in the world. You will find that this type of governance only works in homogeneous societies - where the people can agree and identify with one another (and also have qualities such as good work ethic, social responsibility, love for their country or place, etc). Once you bring in variously diverse groups into the picture, half of which are only seeking benefits, those same polices tend to produce the opposite effects.
- chongli 10y agoSweden solved those problems by keeping those people out of the country, relegated to the south of Europe. That is the difference between Sweden and SF. SF allows unrestricted migration from the rest of the continent, Sweden does not.
- uola 10y agoSweden received many immigrants from Greece, Turkey, Italy and Yugoslavia during the 60s.
- chongli 10y agoYes, and Canada received many refugees from Syria. That's a far cry from allowing unrestricted migration which is what SF does. There are no border patrols outside the city. You do not need a passport to get in. Other cities literally pack up their homeless and give them free bus tickets to SF! Sweden, on the other hand, forces people to learn the language before they can even get a job. Those who won't or cannot do that end up in Germany instead.
- uola 10y agoSweden has a higher percentage of English speakers than Canada. Germany not so much.