6 ms·
I wonder why they don't fund proper studies. Maybe because the effect is too obvious to question? My oral hygienist can tell whether I floss regularly or not, s
by adrianN 10y ago
I wonder why they don't fund proper studies. Maybe because the effect is too obvious to question? My oral hygienist can tell whether I floss regularly or not, so there must be an observable difference in plaque buildup. Subjectively my gums also feel better and bleed less when I floss regularly.
- flukus 10y agoI've never flossed, I don't have gaps in my teeth to get the floss in. My first trip to the dentist in 25 years was a few weeks ago and my teeth were perfect except for a wisdom tooth and the damage it caused. So i'm kind of skeptical of the effect. Edit - I always wonder what kind of toothbrush other people use. I've always used electric ones so I wonder if that helps.
- tiddlydum 10y agoThis is anecdotal, but when I don't floss my teeth hurt.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoProbably poor technique. When the oral hygienist flosses my teeth it doesn't hurt at all but I can't replicate the pain free flossing at home.
- pizza234 10y agoAnecdote is not evidence. A few people are certainly "gifted" teeth-wise (I know another case), but not going to the dentist for 25 years would be disastrous if applied on large scale.
- flukus 10y ago>Anecdote is not evidence. Well that's the problem, we don't have better evidence.
- totalcrepe 10y ago> Well that's the problem, we don't have better evidence. We actually have had it for quite a while. The CAMBRA MOOC is put together by a dentist/statistician and lays out a point system based on correlation between patient behaviors/health and carries. It has been iteratively corrected based on effective and ineffective results when modifying behavior according to the system. Notably in that system, floss is not given a point. Whatever effect it may have is either too weak or better described by other factors flossing correlates with. When points like that come up, the teacher stresses that the system is only measuring odds of near term carries, so flossing may be effective for something else with regards to oral health or preventing one of the negative factors.
- osteele 10y agoA claim is that flossing reduces gingivitis. The CAMBRA MOOC measures carries.
- pizza234 10y agoThe sentence above was about considering the extreme case irrelevant. Focusing on flossing itself, as person who started doing it regularly only as adult, I think that researching on how frequently one should floss (or not) is in a way like researching how frequently one should change underwear. It may make sense theoretically, but ultimately all it requires is just to pay attention. I never noticed the bleeding and/or irritation of the gums (which dentists always mention) until I started flossing regularly. Now I do feel a difference (as a matter of fact, I floss irregularly, depending on how the gums feel). Of course, I'm pretty sure I could survive without flossing at all. This is in line with what dentists generally suggest. Given that flossing can be ultimately considered as simply extra cleaning, and that the presence (or not) of the effects can be easily observed, a couple of weeks of flossing should be enough for anybody to make a solid judgment more than any theory.
- mamadrood 10y agoI've never been to the dentist and i am perfectly fine. I'm getting tired of soup, though.
- hydroxonium 10y agolol
- cLeEOGPw 10y ago> I don't have gaps in my teeth to get the floss in. Same here. Never understood how people can physically floss. Maybe those with undeveloped teeth can do it, others, I don't see how it's even possible.
- fredsted 10y agoI use one of these: http://imgur.com/8A3dopG http://imgur.com/8A3dopG For some teeth, I have to force it a little, my teeth are pretty close too. Its so worth it though: much better breath, clean feel, minimized risk of cavities.
- flukus 10y agoI've tried them, but they refuse to go in too.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoI use these. I can bit down on it if I need extra force. http://www.apteekkituotteet.fi/WebRoot/Euran/Shops/Eura/506D/44FC/C30E/E6B0/D550/0A28/1050/7369/plackers_twin.jpg http://www.apteekkituotteet.fi/WebRoot/Euran/Shops/Eura/506D... Of course people's teeth are different. I know some prefer these, where you push it in from the side. http://www.tepe.com/uk/products/interdental-brushes/ http://www.tepe.com/uk/products/interdental-brushes/
- cLeEOGPw 10y agoThing is, teeth are so close to each other that literally nothing can get between them, not even food. I have however few teeth that get food in between, but these are the ones that already went bad and were fixed, and have gaps as a result of that.
- throwaway41597 10y agoI avoided purchasing one by forming a loop with the wire. I cut a 20cm (8in) piece, then I tie a triple knot (the simple over hand knot with both ends). The wire is very slippery so I move the first knot as close to the ends as possible, so as not to waste floss. Having a loop allows to have a firm hold on the floss and adjust tension. I use it with both hands though. And I waste very little floss because I can rotate the loop and use every inch of it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- imron 10y agoYou might find that if you go to the dentist for teeth cleaning and they clear away all the plaque buildup that you'll be able to get the floss in between your teeth. Like you, I have good teeth (never had a filling) and on average have visited the dentist about once every 10 years. Like you I also used to never be able to get floss in between my teeth, but after a dental checkup some years back the dentist cleared all the plaque buildup and from then on getting the floss between my teeth was no problem, and I've been flossing regularly since. Once the plaque builds up and hardens, it's very difficult to break it up with just floss and you'll have difficulty getting floss in. For what it's worth, my teeth definitely feel cleaner after flossing, and if I miss a couple of days they start to feel dirty.
- MarcusP 10y agoI had the issue that I couldn't floss due to lack of gaps too, I even have a wire behind my bottom teeth keeping them together after having braces when I was younger. This meant I had to visit the dentist if I wanted to clean between my teeth and even after that, normal floss just didn't fit. But now I have discovered floss tape; it's just what it sounds like, a thin strip of tape that you can slide between your teeth to floss. Now I can actually floss and it makes a big difference to how clean my teeth look and feel. I'm in the UK and the product I use is Oral-B Satin Tape - worth trying or finding an equivalent if you have teeth very close together.
- imron 10y agoSnap! Oral-B Satin Tape for the win.
- throwaway41597 10y agoIf it works for you, then no need to change it. For me, it depends on which tooth I'm flossing. Some are easier than others. Some are so tight that floss won't come out, it feels like I'm pulling a tooth out. For this reason, I don't floss often and not every tooth. I use toothpicks though.
- epalmer 10y agoMy gaps are small. My dentist says my teeth are tight. I have found that using Glide is the best floss. Even with that I have at times cut right through the floss with a particular pair of teeth. You might want to try Glide. I floss daily and sometimes twice a day. I keep floss at my desk at work and some mouthwash to kill some of germs that get stirred up. It is easy to fit that in when thinking through a problem. I also take vitamin C twice a day. My dentists always comment on the good health of my gums and say "you take vitamin c don't you?" At 62 I want to maintain my gum and teeth health.
- amalag 10y agoI have to use a plastic floss needle sometimes, you thread the needle with floss in order to get floss between teeth when there is some food stuck in there. Amazing that people are wondering what the "scientific" value in getting food particles out of your mouth.
- huherto 10y agoI have tight straight teeth on one side and I wicked with little gaps on the other side. There is a big difference when I floss. On one side is usually clean, on the other is not. It requires a lot more maintenance.
- specialist 10y agoCongratulations. You won the genetic lottery. I did well, for a while, too. Then I had a lot of chemo. First year post, I had 14 cavities requiring fillings. Now I have 3 crowns. Floss your teeth, preferably with a water pick. Older you will thank younger you.
- jbpetersen 10y agoNow I'm wondering whether brushing with added attention towards gums would provide an equivalent result.
- cel1ne 10y agoFrom personal experience I can say: It helps, but it doesn't give you equivalent results.
- dualogy 10y ago> bleed less when I floss regularly Sheesh, shouldn't they ideally never-bleed? Just what is it you're ingesting (or not ingesting)?
- mrweasel 10y agoFor years my oral hygienist kept telling me to a get an electric toothbrush. When I finally got one, I didn't tell her, but I never hear the "get an electric tooth brush" again. It was the same with flossing. When I started flossing I didn't say anything, and she hasn't commented that I need to floss since.
- dazc 10y agoAlso worth noting that if you floss properly (maybe also use interdental sticks) the descaling routine becomes a lot more comfortable. For this reason alone it's worth doing.
- rangibaby 10y agoFlossing was a painful, bloody mess for me the first week or so I did it. Then it felt great, then I ran out of the floss sticks (like a disposable razor, but with floss instead of a blade) and haven't done it since. Such is life.
- merpnderp 10y agoI found this to be the same with a water pick. At first my gums bled and hurt, but after a few weeks I could turn the power to max and it feels like an awesome massage on my gums. I used to get some food stuck between my teeth, but now almost never do which I presume is due to much healthier gums.
- nextos 10y agoThere's a ton of evidence in the literature supporting that gum disease and cavities are, obviously, a bacterial issue. Flossing is an obvious way to disrupt pathogenic bacterial colonies by abrasion. I think irrigation is much better, as it reaches deep pockets below gums. But it doesn't replace flossing entirely. Those two, coupled with regular brushing of teeth, gum and tongue, plus oral probiotics should keep issues at bay. In particular, my experience with probiotics is that tartar calculus fell apart within a few months. I have never had a cavity. Sadly most dentists don't place too much emphasis on these as it goes against their business model: drill, fill and bill.
- pw 10y agoI wondered that too. But I also worry whether the immediate-term indices of dental health that hygienists are taught to look for correspond to long-term dental health endpoints.
- INTPenis 10y agoThe effect is very obvious. I'm not ashasmed to say that since the age of 18 - your last year of free dental care in Sweden - to the age of 31, I didn't go to the dentist at all. I brushed mostly regularly the second half of this period, I never flossed. I'm a computer geek, I can get caught up in code for days without brushing my teeth but try to do it regularly. The result was 13 years of plaque and two visits to a dentist to clean it all out. Dental plaque is a coating over your tooth and your gums will grow over this coating. So I think it's pretty obvious that dental plaque can cause cavities between your gums and your teeth, infections in your gums and all this will in turn lead to periodontitis. And also you have saliva glands at the bottom of your mouth that bring with them additional minerals and stuff that get stuck to your teeth, forming plaque. So the front bottom teeth are even more important to floss. Now I floss regularly and I'm proud to have actually made it one of my daily habits.
- pc86 10y ago> I brushed mostly regularly the second half of this period I'm terrified to ask what you did the first half of that period.
- whack 10y agoExcept that studies have now shown that the effect is not obvious at all. "Since doctors began saying that a string-based tooth scrapping was good for oral health, a handful of studies have been conducted. However, they all fall far short of what’s needed to make a convincing argument. A 2011 review of a dozen randomized controlled studies concluded that, “Overall there is weak, very unreliable evidence which suggests that flossing plus toothbrushing may be associated with a small reduction in plaque at 1 or 3 months.” The US Agriculture and Health and Human Services departments quietly removed the flossing recommendation from the latest version of dietary guidelines. ---------- If anyone thinks that this is because the study's parameters are too narrow to show an effect, that is not the case. Other studies have successfully shown the benefits of flossing... if the dentist is the one performing it. But they haven't been able to show similar results when regular people do the flossing. "Maybe the evidence that flossing reduces tooth decay or gum disease does not hold up because we are all such poor flossers. Superflossers, like the zealous hygienist at your dentist’s office, aim to “hug the neck of the tooth” and get below the gum line, Dr. Hujoel said. But we common folk, staring woefully at our bathroom mirrors, tend to lightly give it the once-over. A review of six trials found that when professionals flossed the teeth of children on school days for almost two years, they saw a 40 percent reduction in the risk of cavities. So maybe perfect flossing is effective. But scientists would be hard put to find anyone to test that theory." ----------- Honestly, I'm not surprised at all. Years ago, my dentist strongly urged me to get my asymptomatic wisdom teeth removed. I then went home and did my own research on this subject. And what I found was the complete opposite of my dentist's recommendation. But a new study of more than 6,000 patients in Greece found that only 2.7 percent of the teeth had a cyst or tumor. An older study, often cited by critics of routine extraction, found that only 12 percent of 1,756 middle-aged people who had not had impacted wisdom teeth removed experienced a complication. Numerous comprehensive reviews of research, conducted by independent bodies not affiliated with oral surgeons, have concluded that there was no evidence to support routine prophylactic extraction of impacted but healthy wisdom teeth. Britain’s National Health Service stopped paying for the procedure if there was no good reason for it after an analysis by its Center for Reviews and Dissemination at the University of York concluded in 1998 that there was no solid scientific evidence to support it. Also that year, the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh said that for patients who do not have a condition related to third molars or whose teeth would probably grow in successfully, removal is “not advisable.” In 2005, a review by the respected Cochrane Collaboration said the number of extractions could be reduced by 60 percent if they were done only when patients were in pain or developed a condition related to wisdom teeth. The group also said there is “reliable evidence” that suggests that removing wisdom teeth does not prevent or reduce crowding of front teeth. In 2008, the American Public Health Association dismissed arguments typically made for removing wisdom teeth: that adjacent teeth might be damaged, or that the teeth may harbor bacteria that cause periodontal disease. The association approved a policy saying these concerns do not justify the risks of surgery, which include possible nerve damage, complications from anesthesia. loss of the sense of taste and, very rarely, death. “The few studies of long-term retention of impacted teeth have shown little risk of harm,” the association concluded. ------------- I've since brought this up with a few other friends who are dentists as well. They always start off by haranguing me for doing my own research, instead of following my dentist's recommendation. Then once I show them all the above evidence, which they have never seen before, they change their minds and accept that I'm probably right. With a track record like that, I wouldn't be surprised at all if flossing turns out to be yet another sacred cow that's virtually pointless in reality. I do have to say kudos to the dental field though. At least they are making efforts to validate their recommendations, using empirical studies. I wonder how many of the recommendations given by programmers/teachers/fitness-trainers etc are similarly flawed. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/03/health/flossing-teeth-cavities.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/03/health/flossing-teeth-cavi... http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/06/health/06consumer.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/06/health/06consumer.html
- bbayles 10y agoI've tested a few times - if I floss the day before and day of I don't get the "floss more!" lecture.
- JoshGlazebrook 10y agoIt really depends. If the plaque is left too long it will harden and turn into tartar (calculus), which can't be easily removed with just floss.