3 ms·
So what you're saying is, Windows should not strive to meet any sort of basic security capability? Because that's all UWP is: A more secure design. Win32 is on
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
So what you're saying is, Windows should not strive to meet any sort of basic security capability? Because that's all UWP is: A more secure design.
Win32 is only "less restrictive" than UWP in one particular way: It allows any application to mess with almost anything in your system without warning or user permission.
Anyone can download and run UWP without any hiccup. In actuality, Win32 does have hiccups: UAC elevation, SmartScreen filtering, etc.
Steam can sell UWP apps if they want. Epic Games can merge Microsoft's fork if they want. (Bear in mind, pull requests start as forks.)
Microsoft has the users, it needs the security so it doesn't lose those users. Tim Sweeney is paranoid in the wrong ways, he's suggesting that you have to leave a poorly secured operating system in order to protect user freedom. That's false.
- shmerl 10y ago> So what you're saying is, Windows should not strive to meet any sort of basic security capability? Because that's all UWP is: A more secure design. Its development is rather weird though. If I understood correctly, part of the build process is out of developers' hands, and is supposed to be performed by distributor which supports UWP (especially for different architectures). Is UWP backend toolchain and implementation even available for other distributors besides Windows Store? If yes, then it's not a distributor lock-in. But if no, then Tim Sweeney was perfectly right criticizing it.
- hirsin 10y agoI think you may be misinformed. You can build an app and install it using VS. You don't even need VS, apps are just exe's in zip files. Compile and lay it out right and you're done. The Store isn't required to do any of that, so I don't know what the "UWP backend" is. You might look at Hockey app (pre acquisition) for evidence of an app distributor that wasn't Microsoft.
- shmerl 10y agoHow does UWP achieve architecture agnostic releases then? They claimed it's part of the UWP design.
- iamcreasy 10y ago> So what you're saying is, Windows should not strive to meet any sort of basic security capability? It should, but at this cost. > Epic Games can merge Microsoft's fork if they want. (Bear in mind, pull requests start as forks.) Epic games won't. In fact, our conversation starts following the article interviewing Tim Sweeney. I highly doubt if MS will ever be able to convince Epic games to do that. Also in the future what's stopping MS from forcing developers to use Microsoft store, followed by restriction on the type of content, followed by...more restrictions. The trust issue is very big here. It's also true that MS have changed their attitude recently after Satya Nadella became the CEO, but when both Tim Sweeney and Gabe Newell is worried about something - I think the issue deserves more attention. > Tim Sweeney is paranoid in the wrong ways, he's suggesting that you have to leave a poorly secured operating system in order to protect user freedom. That's false. He is saying it will be wiser for the community at large to choose user freedom over poorly implemented security policies.
- shmerl 10y ago> He is saying it will be wiser for the community at large to choose user freedom over poorly implemented security policies. To be honest, he ignores the elephant in the room. Despite his criticism of MS, all his talks assume Windows and MS everywhere. To promote user freedom, he should do more for people to ditch MS for good and to switch to Linux for example. While UE is one of the best engines that support Linux today, it's done as an afterthought, more by contribution of UE community, not so much as a big focus by Epic. Using Windows and complaining that MS can mess things up at any time is somewhat incoherent. Because MS indeed can do it. Make something to reduce relying on MS, that's a fix for it.
- iamcreasy 10y ago> it's done as an afterthought, more by contribution of UE community, not so much as a big focus by Epic. I think that's wrong. Linux support was on the road map, but since the engine was open source, the community(done by one person if I remember correctly) beat them to it. And today Linux is a fully supported platform. > Using Windows and complaining that MS can mess things up at any time is somewhat incoherent. Very true. Our only hope is to talk about it, and hoping that MS would listen.