4 ms·
>Can you honestly say info browsing overall is better than it was 10-20 years ago? Yes, just block ads.
by pixl97 10y ago
>Can you honestly say info browsing overall is better than it was 10-20 years ago?
Yes, just block ads.
- MichaelGG 10y agoI'm talking with an ad blocker. I can only imagine how bad it is without one. Twitter is still sluggish as hell, especially how it's basically one big table of text+images.
- Touche 10y agoYou should compare 1999 Yahoo Mail to Gmail or Fastmail of today. I don't think you'd prefer the former.
- MichaelGG 10y agoAnd that's mainly due to what, though? AJAX? (Ignoring other enhancements.) And I'm excepting out a lot of "apps", because the browser has gotten more powerful, sure (and software dev has progressed). But mostly content sites that aren't heavy on any real interaction, iow, sites I "surf". Things just feel ... sluggish at a UI level (not the old sluggish of watching progressive JPEGs slowly refine).
- kasabali 10y ago>> Can you honestly say info browsing (not apps like GDocs) overall is better than it was 10-20 years ago? > You should compare 1999 Yahoo Mail to Gmail or Fastmail of today. I don't think your examples relevant because they are well in the realm of "apps" and not "info browsing" OP talks about.
- dredmorbius 10y agoActually, that's not enough. The expectation and dynamics of ad-driven publishing have created a huge proliferation of sites that have no reason to exist. Taboola, NewsMax, Outbrain, and a slew of others, pimping nothing but crap. It's anti-information. You're dumber for having read or even seen it. I've been keeping up a 60k+ element blocklist (sorted for dupes, and treating entire domains via DNSMasq), which helps some. But even that just chips away gently. I've got another tab open with a Guardian article, "How Technology Disrupted the Truth". It dives deep into a space I've been pointing at for a while -- that advertising isn't merely bad for having created bad UI/UX and malware distribution networks, but it's actively screwing with media's primary role of communicating true facts. https://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/jul/12/how-technology-disrupted-the-truth https://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/jul/12/how-technology... Until and unless authors and publishers take the heat for dumping crap on people -- I'm increasingly a fan of the block -- that's not going to turn around. (And yes, figuring out how to finance quality information also matters -- admitting it's a public good, and should probably be financed like one, would be a good first step.) Ad blocking is necessary, but insufficient.
- pferde 10y agoIt could be argued that media's primary role is not to communicate true facts, but rather to communicate information their owner wants communicated. Regardless of whether the media is a news outlet or, I don't know, your own mouth.
- dredmorbius 10y agoI'll invoke another HN post -- Donella Meadows speaking of systems highlighted the importance of accurate feedback. You can go further and note that all models are wrong, but some are useful. And note research which suggests that perceptual systems evolve to fitness rather than accuracy, a crucial distinction. But the perception still needs to provide useful predictive or explanatory power over the range of experienced conditions. And if yo're deliberately violating that condition, you're going to end up with some less than beneficial behaviors. Contemporary politics in various parts of the world, and interactions with media, demonstrates this well.