5 ms·
It need not be a major telco though. This awesome dumb pipe could and should come from municipal internet services. Chatanooga, TN was able to provide affordabl
by bogomipz 10y ago
It need not be a major telco though. This awesome dumb pipe could and should come from municipal internet services. Chatanooga, TN was able to provide affordable gigabit internet to it citizens and make a small profit. In Los Angeles the Department of Water and Power has an extensive network - LADWP Fiber and L.A has floated the idea. The reason it doesn't succeed? Because AT&T and Verizon will sue and and get an injunction against it because they would be put at an unfair disadvantage they say. It's criminal but it's true:
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/03/tennessee-kills-muni-broadband-expansion-bill-after-att-opposition/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/03/tennessee-kills-m...
https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-releases-order-preempting-tn-nc-municipal-broadband-restrictions https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-releases-order-preempting-t...
Those duopolies business models are contingent upon have access to public right-aways. The resources are owned by the general public/tax payers in the municipalities the operate in. There is technical reason we can't have near universal and affordable dumb pipes, just political.
I personally see this as going to be a success for either Verizon or its share holders, quite the opposite. It will be paid for by end users in the form of increased fees.
- rayiner 10y agoChatanooga makes a small operating profit, but not enough to pay the interest on the bonds used to build the network: http://www.nyls.edu/advanced-communications-law-and-policy-institute/wp-content/uploads/sites/169/2013/08/ACLP-Chattanooga-Case-Study-updated-October-2015.pdf http://www.nyls.edu/advanced-communications-law-and-policy-i.... The system is only possible because the EPB is using its electricity monopoly to subsidize internet.
- bogomipz 10y ago"Notwithstanding questions about its accounting practices and the extent to which the utility might be leveraging its monopoly electric service to support its telecom division, EPB continues to report relatively strong financial health of its fiber system. In 2014, the GON increased its revenues from $80.7 million to $99.9 million.53 Revenue from Internet access sales in particular saw a net increase of about $17 million,54 much of which was due to residential customer growth.55 Overall, residential services accounted for two-thirds of EPB Fiber’s revenues in 2014.56 Expenses and transfers to the city of Chattanooga totaled $84.7 million.57" This sounds OK to me, what am I missing? Why is it important that their electricity monopoly subsidized anything? How is that any different than any other new enterprise that has gotten funding from a VC? You don't hear anybody criticize that some star up is only possible because they got money from an investor. How is the source of funding relevant?
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not sustainable. They're making less than 4% return on a network they issued 4.5% bonds to build. Ratepayers who have no choice of electric company are subsidizing the internet service.
- eru 10y agoWhy couldn't they raise prices by a bit?
- rayiner 10y agoPresumably, they set prices to maximize revenue--raising prices would decrease revenue by losing subscribers.
- crzwdjk 10y agoNot necessarily. It's entirely plausble that they set the price lower in order to boost the number of subscribers and thus their political constituency.
- eru 10y agoDisregarding what amazon_not said about the facts on the ground, your objection is an interesting one in theory. I think in such a situation I would perhaps try to play on people's pride and make an emotional appeal. And/or sell equity to customers. Some are happy to hold part of an enterprise they believe in, and will accept submarket returns. Come to think of it, a cooperative wouldn't be too different.
- amazon_not 10y agoNo need. EPB fiber is already squarely in the black.
- bogomipz 10y agoIt is sustainable, they just need to boost their numbers and market penetration like every other venture that regularly gets discussed on HN whether it be a music streaming service or ride sharing app etc: "Recent reports estimate that those numbers have risen to over 65,000 residential customers and about 5,500 commercial customers so far in 2015.48 This represents about a 45 percent share of the local residential market for broadband, video, and telephone service. 49 Despite being available to all potential customers, only about eight percent – or fewer than 5,500 – of residential customers that purchase Internet access subscribe to its signature gigabit service.5" This venture is only 5 years old(2011) and the bond has a maturity length of 25 years! Lastly only 162 million out of the bond issue was used to build out the fiber network, the rest was used to build a smart grid.
- amazon_not 10y agoThe above is incorrect. EPB Fiber is profitable, is servicing it's debt in full and is not subsidized by electric ratepayers. Not only are electric rate payers not subsidizing the fiber network, the fiber network is subsidizing the electric side! The EPB fiber made $15M profit (FY14) is after debt service. EPB paid $19M in debt service (FY14). Source: https://static.epb.com/annual-reports/2015/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/2015-financial-report.pdf https://static.epb.com/annual-reports/2015/wp-content/upload...
- rayiner 10y agoRead page 14 of the article you linked in light of page 3 of the article I linked. The vast majority of the debt used to build the fiber system is ascribed to EBP, not the fiber division. So it doesn't appear in EBP fiber's profit calculation. Your link shows less than $1 million of debt service on a network that cost $400m. Interest rates are low, but they're not that low!
- amazon_not 10y ago> Your link shows less than $1 million of debt service on a network that cost $400m. Interest rates are low, but they're not that low! I can't tell if you are joking or merely being frivolous, but of course municipal bond interest rates aren't that low. The base fallacy in your comment is that you are comparing the interest payment to the total network build cost and not the outstanding debt. These two are obviously not the same thing and only outstanding debt affects the size of the interest payment. > Read page 14 of the article you linked in light of page 3 of the article I linked. The vast majority of the debt used to build the fiber system is ascribed to EBP, not the fiber division. So it doesn't appear in EBP fiber's profit calculation You are correct in noting that the majority of the debt is ascribed to EBP and not directly to EBP fiber. This does not, however, mean that EPB fiber gets a free ride or receives a subsidy from the electric side. Quite the opposite in fact! As clearly noted also in the research paper you linked to, it is the electric side that receives a subsidy from the fiber side. So not only is the fiber side pulling its weight, it's also creating and sharing the wealth! Normally how this is done in cases like these, is that the department that carries the debt gets an internal transfer from the department utilizing and profiting from the asset that was constructed with the debt financing. In other words, EPB fiber would pay EPB for the use of the fiber network and EPB would use the payment to service the debt. Referring to the EPB financial report, EPB fiber certainly has the money to do so. In addition to their FY15 $17M profit, they have booked a $15M Provision of Depreciation. This $15M is a non-cash expense, so they are basically just sitting on $15M in cash on top of their profit. I'd expect this would be used for the internal transfer to EPB to service the debt. Now for arguments sake, let's assume that EPB fiber was just sitting on that $15M in cash and not sharing with EPB, content in just collecting a mountain of cash. Even so, with EPB fiber making a profit of $17M FY15, that profit is more than enough to cover the debt service in full on EPB fiber's part of the debt (originally $162M). In fact that $17M is almost enough to cover the debt service in full for the whole of EPB, electric utility and all. So, while you may reasonably and justifiably criticize Chattanooga's fiber project for a lot of things, being unprofitable and subsidized is not one of those things.