3 ms·
Tesla says that only the passenger side was opened at first, and the driver side was only opened from the outside. And yet the accident was on the right side of
by pwinnski 10y ago
Tesla says that only the passenger side was opened at first, and the driver side was only opened from the outside. And yet the accident was on the right side of the vehicle, so if either door would have had trouble opening, it would be that one. If Tesla's information is correct--and isn't a sensor malfunction or similar--then my hypothesis would that the driver was not even in the driver's seat. However, we're also told that steering and braking happened before the car came to a stop, so is the idea that the driver climbed over to exit the damaged passenger side rather than the untouched driver side? Possibly while running from the noise? Alternatively, the logs are incorrect.
Tesla also says that there was an "abrupt steering action" that preceded hitting the first post, and that the car was not auto-steering at all for the other 11 posts. There's some fuzziness in Tesla's description. The implication is that the driver hit the brakes immediately, but it's only an implication. No timestamps are provided, nor clarifying language beyond the broad implication.
I'm generally thinking Tesla's information is probably correct, BUT I'm really, really, really tired of hearing about how two seconds of no-hands is somehow unreasonable, when the car itself allows for much, much longer. If you want to say that someone has to keep a hand on the wheel, have it beep and prepare to disengage after two seconds of no-hands, not 15 minutes. If you allow for 15 minutes, don't be shocked when people use all 15 minutes.
- zeroxfe 10y agoIt was not two seconds, it was two minutes (in the response.) The car starts to alert you by beeping when it doesn't detect hands for a few minutes and displays a message on the dash to grab the wheel. It does this a few times (every ~10 seconds I think) after which if there are still no hands on the wheel, it starts to slow down and come to a complete stop. In this case, it looks like the driver disabled Autosteer by abruptly tugging on the steering wheel after two alerts.
- zaroth 10y agoAs road conditions became increasingly uncertain, the vehicle again alerted you to put your hands on the wheel. No steering torque was then detected until Autosteer was disabled with an abrupt steering action. Immediately following detection of the first impact, adaptive cruise control was also disabled, the vehicle began to slow, and you applied the brake pedal. It's actually not clear the order of events from Tesla's letter, but I read this to mean the abrupt steering action came after the first first impact.
- pwinnski 10y agoTwo replies, each of them assuming something completely different from Tesla's response. Tesla's communication is so poor, it's hard to see that as anything other than deliberate.