3 ms·
They said that the radar and camera detected the trailer but that it looked like an overhead sign and so was ignored. The sonar sensors play no role in preventi
by mikeash 10y ago
They said that the radar and camera detected the trailer but that it looked like an overhead sign and so was ignored. The sonar sensors play no role in preventing forward collisions, as they only have a range of about 16 feet. They are used to aid parking and to avoid side collisions from cars in adjacent lanes.
Since the system didn't detect any danger, I think it's safe to assume that no alarms sounded. Hands on the wheel isn't relevant, since the problem wasn't one to be solved with steering.
Aside from timestamps (which don't seem particularly useful here), this seems to include just about everything interesting.
- etendue 10y ago> They said that the radar and camera detected the trailer but that it looked like an overhead sign and so was ignored. Has Tesla or NTSB actually said that? From ref. 1, published today, my emphasis: Tesla *is considering* whether the radar and camera input for the vehicle’s automatic emergency braking system failed to detect the truck trailer or the automatic braking system’s radar may have detected the trailer but discounted this input… [1] http://finance.yahoo.com/news/tesla-mulling-two-theories-explain-191406596.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/tesla-mulling-two-theories-exp...
- mikeash 10y agoLooking into it, Elon Musk said that the radar ignores overhead signs, but he didn't actually say that was what happened in this case: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/748625979271045121?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/748625979271045121?ref_s... I don't think it matters much. The main thing is that the system didn't detect the trailer. Exactly why it failed to detect the trailer is interesting, but doesn't change anything about fault or responsibility. And if Tesla is still considering the possibility, then apparently it's hard enough to figure out that just releasing logs wouldn't help us.
- etendue 10y ago> The main thing is that the system didn't detect the trailer. Has that information been made public? Unless it has, that statement would also appear to be speculative at this point. > Exactly why it failed to detect the trailer is interesting, but doesn't change anything about fault or responsibility. I would say that it is far too early to make that declaration, given that the investigation is ongoing.
- mikeash 10y agoFrom Tesla's original post about the crash: "Neither Autopilot nor the driver noticed the white side of the tractor trailer against a brightly lit sky" - https://www.tesla.com/blog/tragic-loss https://www.tesla.com/blog/tragic-loss I have trouble imagining the underlying reasons for this being particularly interesting. I guess if the lighting was so bad that even the driver couldn't see the trailer then that would excuse him from fault, but I don't see how it changes Tesla's role in it.
- etendue 10y agoShort of an unholy ritual involving the supernatural, Tesla PR or Musk can only guess as to what the driver noticed in this case, and neither can accurately speak to what the either the driver or car did or did not do until the investigation is completed. I think there's a lot to be concerned about wrt. AutoPilot and I plan on thoroughly reading the completed investigation reports.
- madmax96 10y agoBut Autopilot users are supposed to be watching the road. Assuming this is the case, if the user had seen the vehicle he ought to have applied the breaks.
- etendue 10y agoAs a famous engineer said, "and if my grandmother had wheels, she'd be a wagon." Something to consider is that a "good" risk analysis takes into account the foreseeable use and misuse of a product based on the information available. Given that it is no secret that AutoPilot users have used the system contrary to directions, it is reasonable to demand that the risk analysis be updated to account for this reality (assuming it did not account for this) as part of the continuous PLM process.