3 ms·
> Ultimately, there is a line which the US currently hasn't crossed If US government is killing civilians in various countries and is orchestrating arrests of
by rdtsc 17y ago
> Ultimately, there is a line which the US currently hasn't crossed
If US government is killing civilians in various countries and is orchestrating arrests of minors, morally it is not really rising above China by much. Yeah, it is not sending 'guidelines' to the media, because there are other methods of influencing what gets published and what doesn't -- namely intimidation of journalists and sources, appeals to the owners of media corporations and so on.
> Additionally what scares them is the handing out of classified material;
Well what kind of classified material? Yes, if these are nuclear launch codes, or frequency hopping codes of military radios, they would have a valid reason to detect the source of the leak. I think most of us and most US citizens would agree with the government doing that. But these are videos of slaughtering of civilians. At this point, the CIA should be appologizing and not running around arresting and following people. There are now showing their true face (well to the rest of us who didn't know it yet).
> Whatever your feeling on whether it should be classified or not they have an obligation to reasonably mitigate information they consider secret.
That is what I have a problem with -- "an obligation". Obligation to who? Government? Why should we have an obligation to them that trumps our moral sense of right and wrong? Luckily there is someone there, who is an actual human being, with a moral sense, that knows that killing innocent people is wrong no matter how many classification layers get slapped on top of it. That is why these leaks happened. Someone put their job, freedom (and life?) at risk because they felt that the "obligation to hide murder under the carpet" is wrong.
- ErrantX 17y ago> Well what kind of classified material? Any classified material. I don't think they should be discriminative based on some ill specified metric; if they feel the material should be classified then they should attempt to keep it so. If Wikileaks feels it should be public then they should attempt to make it so. Therein we have the makings of balance. > Obligation to who? Government? Why should we have an obligation to them that trumps our moral sense of right and wrong? We certainly don't have an obligation, that's silly. They have an obligation to stand by the laws they impose. Otherwise whats the point :)
- arohner 17y agoAnd They have an obligation to do what's in the best interest of the citizens of this country. Classification is useful only so far as it improves our well-being. Nuclear launch codes and radio frequencies fall under this. Keeping something classified because it embarrasses a gov't official or maybe costs him a job is not.
- GHFigs 17y agoReality is not so clear cut. There is a huge span of information which is useful to potential enemies without directly being a risk to people's lives. For instance, in the Army counterintelligence report that Wikileaks recently published one of the classified items (much of the content of the report was actually unclassified information) lists certain countries that were believed to have the capacity to hack Wikileaks. Now, if you were (say) North Korea, then your presence or absence on that list tells you something about what the US knew about your cyberwarfare capabilities. If you were the US, leaking this information undermines your desire to not reveal all you know, and might even reveal something about your own intelligence capability. I've intentionally chosen a fairly benign example because my point is not that this information is so valuable, but that classification of information does not simply break down into "nukes" and "embarrassing".
- Silhouette 17y ago> But these are videos of slaughtering of civilians. Unless I've missed something, the evidence Wikileaks claim to have hasn't been released yet (that's the 5 April date they keep mentioning). And yet, they describe it as a "massacre" and you echo this by using the word "slaughtering". I have little sympathy for governments who try to do dubious things claiming national security/terrorist threat/whatever as justification without presenting any real evidence. I have equally little sympathy for Wikileaks, trying to drum up publicity at a time when it is desperately short of money, doing the same thing with just as little evidence shown. If it's that important, why are they waiting to reveal it, and practically daring the security services to stop them?
- makmanalp 17y ago> Well what kind of classified material? Yes, if these are nuclear launch codes, or frequency hopping codes of military radios, they would have a valid reason to detect the source of the leak. I think most of us and most US citizens would agree with the government doing that. I think the point is that they don't know what information is being stolen and how deeply they have been penetrated, and this scares them. What is released to the public is not as relevant as what information wikileaks actually has. Why should they trust wikileaks not to sell that information to other nations? Their reaction is understandable. On the other hand, as always, I'm curious what wikileaks has in store for us.
- rdtsc 17y ago> Why should they trust wikileaks not to sell that information to other nations? I think in this case they realized the leak is probably from an insider. So the issue for them is not being able to trust their own people. Unfortunately whistle-blower laws and protections don't work for classified material. Whoever leaked this was either an agent working for another country or someone who had a strong moral sense of right and wrong. They most definitely put their job and freedom on the line. I would guess that they were morally motivated. Government agents and even CIA operatives and analysts are still human beings and (luckily) some of them hold basic human rights and moral values above agency's classification levels. > ... how deeply they have been penetrated, and this scares them. That is an interesting phrase because it assumes someone from outside penetrated them. I would guess it is just one of their employees. They don't necessarily plan on quitting or getting exposed, but rather they want to keep working but they are seeing this exposure as helping shed light and getting the record straight. With ultimate good results for US and the CIA. > Their reaction is understandable. Yes it is -- from their point of view. But I look at understanding their position as one would understand the position of a serial killer. There is some internal logic of course. But it is rather insane and wrong to the rest of the world. Given that US taxpayers are funding both the alleged killings of civilians and the cover-up, they should probably become aware of what's happening. One way to stay away from such controversies is to simply not commit things that would bring them about. So we'll supposedly see soon enough what this is all about. If it is just baseless hype from wikileaks, then they will lose all their credibility and will become as believable as a tabloid magazine.