13 ms·
Model X Crash – Open Letters Between Driver and Tesla
- mandeepj 10y agoIt is impressive of Tesla that they are doing this in-depth logging. I don't think none of the other non-electric vehicles log this much.
- dragontamer 10y agoImpressive? Or immoral? When I purchase a $100,000 vehicle, I want the vehicle to act under my control. Not under Tesla's control. The sensor data belongs to Tesla, not to the customer. And Tesla uses the sensor data to serve their Public-Relation benefits instead of helping the individual customer.
- Alupis 10y agoIs there any mechanism that will disable all this logging? > When I purchase a $100,000 vehicle, I want the vehicle to act under my control. Not under Tesla's control. I feel the same way, and kind of find it intrusive that Tesla can seemingly obtain this data at will without my explicit permission.
- guitarbill 10y agoI'd bet it's mentioned in the paperwork somewhere when you buy it. Alas I haven't had the good fortune of being able to go through the purchasing process, but give me $100,000 and I'll find out.
- Alupis 10y ago> I'd bet it's mentioned in the paperwork somewhere when you buy it. It probably is - but that doesn't make it feel better. I want to explicitly allow log collection upon request, or disable it completely. Where my car goes, how fast it was driving, which window I had open, whether or not I was listening to AM or FM radio - is frankly none of Tesla's business. As it is - these logs are seemingly only used to defend Tesla's PR - which as a simple customer, is not something I'm interested in.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoThey do ask for explicit permission.
- devindotcom 10y agoWell that raises the question, if you want a $100K vehicle that is under your control, why would you buy a Tesla, one of the draws for which is increasing automation? For that matter, many systems are out of your control even on more ordinary cars.
- mikeash 10y agoMy car is getting better all the time because of that sensor data they collect, and I knew what I was getting into when I bought it. It's not like they hide the fact that the car is constantly connected to the mothership.
- dragontamer 10y agoIt is immoral however if they cherry-pick sensor data and issue press reports that only favor Tesla consistently.
- mikeash 10y agoIf you say so. I merely object to the part where you say "instead of helping the individual customer." I'm an individual customer and I'm being helped a lot by it.
- lucaspiller 10y agoIn terms of how this may work, most cars have a CAN-bus (or a few) which is basically a stream of events which happen in a car. For example when you press the volume down button on the steering wheel it sends a message on the bus, then the radio receives it and turns the volume down. The same is true for most things in the car, so all Tesla needs to do is attach a device to the bus which logs everything. Other car companies could do the same relatively easy.
- zaroth 10y agoI editorialized the title a bit to remove the click bait. This line of Tesla's letter back to the driver caught my eye; The diagnostic data shows that the driver door was later opened from the outside... That is pretty impressive that diagnostics are not just logging that a door was open, but which handle was used to open it! I guess Tesla has had enough issues with their retracting outer handles to warrant some additional diagnostics in this area, but those logs sure do come in handy.
- bsdetector 10y agoIn this crash they give details like the door handle opening from the outside. In the Pennsylvania crash they say autopilot turned itself off 11 seconds before the crash. In the Florida case they say 'who knows?'. How many seconds did the guy in Florida not have his hands on the wheel? How many alarms were sounded? What did the radar detect? What did the sonar say? Nothing. If Tesla wants to be trusted they need to give out all the relevant information for all crashes, including timestamps, not pick and choose crafted statements that make their PR department happy.
- curiousgal 10y agoMaybe that particular data didn't get transmitted / got corrupted?
- bsdetector 10y agoWhy are we left to guess about what data exists?
- Alupis 10y agoWould they not have said something to that regards then? It does appear, so far, that these "log dumps" are being carefully sifted through and cherry picked for release.
- dragontamer 10y agoMaybe Tesla has ownership of this data and only publishes the data that helps their case.
- curiousgal 10y agoThe devil is in the details.
- mastermojo 10y agoWhen will people learn to stop lying about the behavior of a car that keeps logs of everything it does?
- canthonytucci 10y agoSo how does this work? Do we trust the car or the man? If the car does not detect any steering input, even though it has been given (due to bad software or hardware), or logs a warning being sounded, even though none manifested in the real world, what do we do? How do we know? Bugs are by definition human assertions of computer failure, the computers can't lie (yet), but they can be wrong. Are inward-facing dash-cams going to be required so that we have evidience of compliance with the terms of service of our vehicles? I think it is rather unlikely that a false steering input detection, a false warning log, and a false door-opening log all happpend at once...perhpas not in thic case, but subtle, cascading bugs can and do happen.
- Alupis 10y ago> So how does this work? Do we trust the car or the man? Well, until there is a free tool to dump the logs from all of the Tesla cars, and Tesla the company starts releasing the raw data for the public to verify, the more appropriate question is: Do we trust the man or the company? Telsa has a _lot_ to lose, so the temptation to cherry pick data points that tell their desired narrative is fairly strong.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoI'd say trust the car... It would be easy to correlate one sensor failure and one part of the crash (detected hands on the wheels, kept it going int autopilot - because the sensor failure would lead to the crash) But to say that sensors failed, then warning sounds failed, then failsafes failed, becomes rather unbelievable. Also the high drama content of the customer's letter (there is no 50 foot drop off, i just checked on streetview for that entire section of route 2). There is a railroad, then a river, but not a steep drop. Even then, railroads pretty much stop cars dead trying to cross them (dont ask how i know, lets just say a 1986 ford tempo can go from about 45mph to a dead stop real fast)
- smallnamespace 10y agoIf the car's sensors were faulty, then the logs would be in error too. It's wouldn't be possible to say for sure whether the driver or the log is correct unless the sensors are physically recovered and tests.
- guitarbill 10y agoNot necessarily - sensors are usually picked to be independent of each other. So e.g. if the camera was malfunctioning, the output of the accelerometers and door sensors could (probably) still be trusted. Impossible to say without the raw data though.
- trhway 10y ago>As road conditions became increasingly uncertain, the vehicle again alerted you to put your hands on the wheel. why not publish the video from the car's Autopilot for say last 30 seconds? Looking at the photos, the road seems straight and with proper lane markings well visible. Though, given that it was 2AM, may be Autopilot has issues at low-light - if say they use narrow lenses (for cost as well as depth of field reasons) then it would mean more sensitive sensor (more noise) or longer exposure (less FPS) and relationship of colors of objects are different when illuminated by headlights instead of Sun - all this making it harder to discern the objects. Yet it all would be just a technical reasons that should have been solved before product release.
- thaeli 10y agoEven if that info is saved locally, video is certainly not uploaded to Tesla's servers over the air.
- mikeash 10y agoThere's no facility to record the video in the car either. The video is processed directly in the camera module, and only a high-level summary is sent out from there. There's no connection with the bandwidth needed for video, and not enough storage in the camera module to save it there.
- trhway 10y ago>There's no facility to record the video in the car either. that is really hard to believe. Given how useful dash cams are in cases of accidents, etc.. >and not enough storage in the camera module to save it there. and how all these dash cams do it? Storing 8hrs or more. If Tesla didn't put an SD card there, it sounds really not smart. To "mikeash" below: thanks for the link. It does seems like a small camera (thus one can expect low light issues). So Tesla uses 3rd party system - no miracles here, i hoped that they developed their own and thus hoped that they would improve it fast. That using of the 3rd party system explains while there are a lot of things missing that one would naturally expect in the sensing system of an "autopilot" functionality. It is also explains why they are so defensive instead of just going ahead and fixing issues.
- tmd83 10y agoThe Tesla response talks about Autosteer is that different from Autopilot or has there been a name change. If I'm reading this correct all the crashes against the post are supposedly with the drivers hand on the wheel? If thats the case then maybe the owner wasn't aware of the logging when he tried those claim. I also depend on application log being correct but errors in logging is a scary thought in the sense that how hard it would be prove (or near impossible) that what you are saying the truth. And even beyond weird bug what happens when malicious actors change computer record and takes away all our proof of innocence (aka The Net). I wonder if there is really solid protection against such act possible. I want things more accessible but can you truly make accessible + safe work together (not necessarily now but long in the future). I do sure hope so.
- mikeash 10y agoAutopilot is an umbrella term that includes autosteer, traffic-aware cruise control, "summon" (moving the car forward or backward with the key fob), and automatic parking. Depending on who you ask, it may also include safety features such as automatic emergency braking and side collision avoidance.
- dwg 10y agoI believe Autopilot is the umbrella term for features including Autosteer, Autopark, Auto lane change, etc.
- freerobby 10y agoIt wouldn't stop deceit if done at the engineering level, but one thing Tesla could do to gain trust in its logs is to let its drivers digitally sign a version of them. That way, if it ever lands in court (or some other form of arbitration), both sides could verify that Tesla's version and the driver's version match up -- that neither side has tampered with anything. (I don't believe Tesla has ever tampered with or lied about what the logs say; this would merely address folks who have such doubts).
- lucaspiller 10y agoMaybe cars should be fitted with a third party black box, which can have logs streamed from the car and also record voice and alerts in the cabin.
- gordon_freeman 10y agoI think Tesla should be forced to hand over all the log-data rather than pick-and-choose kind of log-data in order to not taking responsibility of an accident.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoWhy? Does Dodge, ford, chevy, mercedes, etc... have any obligation to step into every crash and turn over all kinds of data? Tesla looks into more crashes than they should, and in turn are being treated more in the wrong for simply looking into it... they do better than any other car company, yet are basically punished for it by groups of people for simply looking into wrecks to see IF there is something there they could do better...
- pwinnski 10y agoDodge, Ford, Chevy, Mercedes, etc do not collect nor publicly release data at all, while Tesla does. Because Tesla collects and publicly releases data at their own choosing, they have an obvious motivation to release only data that supports limited liability against them. They might not be doing that, but until and unless they make all data available every time they make any data available, it's a matter of faith.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoYeah... then what? Police say "oh, you were doing 75mph in a 50? ticket!"... insurance rate hike, etc... how much liability would they be picking up if they exposed all of that, and how quickly would people be throwing a fit about privacy? I know multiple people (in multiple states) who have been ticketed based on their youtube videos... im sure police would try to use the logs just the same...
- pwinnski 10y agoLet's recap this thread: 1. gordon_freeman suggests that Tesla should be forced to disclose what they have, rather than pick and choose what to share. 2. You said that (a) other companies don't do that, and suggested (b) Tesla is being treated unfairly as a result of doing more than any of those companies. 3. I highlighted that, as I believe gordon_freeman was saying, the difference is that Tesla is already collecting that information and using it very selectively, putting them in a class of one. If they were to keep all of the data to themselves, that would be fine, or if they were to release it all, that would be fine, but as it is, nobody really has any reason to believe them. And now here we are. I'm not sure why you're jumping to liability questions about logs of speeding and bringing up privacy (amusing, that one, when it comes to Tesla's public descriptions of events in their cars). I think the point is clear. Tesla, either provide evidence for your claims, or stop making claims. Simple.
- tylercubell 10y ago> No steering torque was then detected until Autosteer was disabled with an abrupt steering action. Immediately following detection of the first impact... Well, which way did the driver steer? Away from the barrier to avoid more damage, like he claims, or into it causing the accident in the first place? This statement is ambiguous and I get the feeling from reading the whole PR response that Tesla is either omitting or cherry-picking information to obfuscate the truth.
- madmax96 10y agoThis is __very__ ambiguous: Mr. Pang states that: > the car suddenly veered right And later that he: > managed to step on the break, turn the car left and > stopped the car So, that's __two__ steering motions (one to veer right and another to turn left and stop.) Tesla only says: > No steering torque was then detected until Autosteer > was disabled with an abrupt steering action. > Immediately following detection of the first impact, > adaptive cruise control was also disabled, the > vehicle began to slow, and you applied the brake > pedal. That's one steering motion -- no indication of direction or magnitude. Also, Tesla's language deliberately avoids ordering the events. Since the "steering action" appears first in the paragraph, it seems as though this happened before the impact. That information is not actually encoded in the article, but a reader would naturally assume this is the case (I know I did). Short of a publicly released log file or an investigation by a third-party, I don't think we'll ever know the truth of what happened.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoIm proud of HN... not one joke about the driver being asian yet...
- pwinnski 10y agoTesla says that only the passenger side was opened at first, and the driver side was only opened from the outside. And yet the accident was on the right side of the vehicle, so if either door would have had trouble opening, it would be that one. If Tesla's information is correct--and isn't a sensor malfunction or similar--then my hypothesis would that the driver was not even in the driver's seat. However, we're also told that steering and braking happened before the car came to a stop, so is the idea that the driver climbed over to exit the damaged passenger side rather than the untouched driver side? Possibly while running from the noise? Alternatively, the logs are incorrect. Tesla also says that there was an "abrupt steering action" that preceded hitting the first post, and that the car was not auto-steering at all for the other 11 posts. There's some fuzziness in Tesla's description. The implication is that the driver hit the brakes immediately, but it's only an implication. No timestamps are provided, nor clarifying language beyond the broad implication. I'm generally thinking Tesla's information is probably correct, BUT I'm really, really, really tired of hearing about how two seconds of no-hands is somehow unreasonable, when the car itself allows for much, much longer. If you want to say that someone has to keep a hand on the wheel, have it beep and prepare to disengage after two seconds of no-hands, not 15 minutes. If you allow for 15 minutes, don't be shocked when people use all 15 minutes.
- zeroxfe 10y agoIt was not two seconds, it was two minutes (in the response.) The car starts to alert you by beeping when it doesn't detect hands for a few minutes and displays a message on the dash to grab the wheel. It does this a few times (every ~10 seconds I think) after which if there are still no hands on the wheel, it starts to slow down and come to a complete stop. In this case, it looks like the driver disabled Autosteer by abruptly tugging on the steering wheel after two alerts.
- zaroth 10y agoAs road conditions became increasingly uncertain, the vehicle again alerted you to put your hands on the wheel. No steering torque was then detected until Autosteer was disabled with an abrupt steering action. Immediately following detection of the first impact, adaptive cruise control was also disabled, the vehicle began to slow, and you applied the brake pedal. It's actually not clear the order of events from Tesla's letter, but I read this to mean the abrupt steering action came after the first first impact.