5 ms·
I hope it's not an EEE move[1]? MS aren't new to such things. I.e. make Unreal Engine work with certain things only on UWP platforms, putting everything else at
by shmerl 10y ago
I hope it's not an EEE move[1]? MS aren't new to such things. I.e. make Unreal Engine work with certain things only on UWP platforms, putting everything else at a disadvantage. I don't have much trust in good intentions of MS when gaming and 3D graphics are concerned, given how they are dead bent on lock-in with DX12, while the industry is collaborating on Vulkan.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend_and_extinguish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend_and_extinguish
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoEvery single Microsoft-related news item does not require mention of a 20-year-old business strategy from before the Internet era.
- shmerl 10y agoPossibly they don't mean anything evil here, but as I said, MS aren't free of lock-in nastiness yet. Otherwise they would have joined the Vulkan working group already. They simply didn't earn trust in that area.
- toss1941 10y agoWhat could Microsoft gain by helping make Vulkan better? I can see them wanting to support it on Windows but Nvidia and AMD will do that for them so what can MS possibly gain?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 10y ago> What could Microsoft gain by helping make Vulkan better? Developers' efficiency. But MS understanding of "gain" is a crooked one. They want to prevent developers from releasing anything for the competition, so they use tools to make it harder (lock-in tactic). Or if they can't prevent it, they want to tax it (i.e. to make it more expensive). It is clearly crooked. And I don't mean just to make Vulkan better. I mean MS starting supporting it instead of DX12. Same AMD can produce Vulkan support for them for Xbox quite easily.
- cocotino 10y agoMS supporting Vulkan instead of DX would be shooting at their own feet. Makes 0 sense to them.
- shmerl 10y ago> MS supporting Vulkan instead of DX would be shooting at their own feet. Makes 0 sense to them. Same as supporting standard HTML instead of ActiveX and Silverlight? If not using lock-in is shooting in one's own feet, you have some strange notion of what's normal.
- toss1941 10y agoI don't see the parallel there. HTML was always a secular technology, unlike DirectX which was created and developed by Microsoft for Microsoft.
- shmerl 10y agoI guess you don't remember browser wars. Until MS started supporting standard HTML, they were pushing all kind of junk like ActiveX and Silverlight, in attempt to monopolize the Web with lock-in. Only when browsers competition intensified, they reluctantly started supporting standards (even WebGL). Some still suffer from that lock-in though, such as South Korea who are stuck with very bad decision of requiring ActiveX for bank transactions. Exactly same thing here. They used DX to lock 3D graphics into their platforms.
- toss1941 10y agoMicrosoft deservedly lost because they failed to innovate. But that isn't the case with graphics, where they have been at the forefront of innovation for well over a decade now. OpenGL has historically lagged behind DirectX in terms of features, ease of use and performance. Only in the last couple years has anyone (Mantle, Vulkan) actually begun to threaten Microsoft's dominance and if DirectX is inferior it should lose, but to equate that with how the HTML wars went is glossing over a lot of detail.
- floopidydoopidy 10y agoIf it quacks like a duck.
- stryan 10y agoActually, this may be a valid concern. It does look like Microsoft is trying harder and harder to lock down PC gaming. See Gabe's [0] and Tim Sweeney's [1] complaints. [0]:http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2012/07/steams-newell-windows-8-catastrophe-driving-valve-to-embrace-linux/ http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2012/07/steams-newell-windows-... [1]:http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2016/03/tim-sweeney-to-microsoft-universal-windows-platform-can-should-must-and-will-die/ http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2016/03/tim-sweeney-to-microso...
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoNewell's comments are from 2012. Sweeney's comments have been pretty much directly invalidated by Microsoft's actions. Note that this year Microsoft made a point to address Sweeney's comments by demonstrating Steamworks in a UWP app, and the Windows 10 update releasing today makes it easier to install UWP apps without the Windows Store. They've repetitively reiterated that UWP apps can be sold through third party stores, the difference is primarily a technical one: That UWP apps are sandboxed (like Android and iOS apps) and therefore less able to act maliciously. To date, Microsoft has done... nothing I'm aware of... to lock down PC gaming. FUD articles are abound though.
- shmerl 10y ago> To date, Microsoft has done... nothing I'm aware of... to lock down PC gaming. DX12 is a form of lock-in.
- kayoone 10y agoUnless you are writing your own, all the major game engines support multiple graphics apis anyway.
- shmerl 10y agoIt doesn't contradict what I said above. Supporting multiple APIs is a burden, whether it falls on those who write their own engines, or those who write those engines for others to use. You can view it as a tax which increases costs and reduces efficiency. The point of lock-in is exactly such tax, which will deter some from using anything else, or at the very least make it more expensive for those who will use something else. This tax is passed to the end user either way, in the form of slower progress, higher prices, unavailability on other platforms and so on.
- ungzd 10y agoIt would be EEE if they, for example, ported DirectX to Linux. But here they're just ported other product to run on their "a-la Android for desktop" system. Possibly evil but not exactly EEE.
- oldmanjay 10y agoWhat is the possible evil?
- Sylos 10y agoThey can definitely also EEE with this. Take a game engine, create a fork for your platform, wait until your platform and fork has a significant market share, and then start introducing features to your fork, which are not directly available on the main-branch. I can't seem to find anything on how UE4 is licensed, but even if Microsoft is forced to release all of their source code, if their fork is different enough from the main-branch, it might be extremely hard to backport all of these features into the main-branch.
- shmerl 10y ago> They can definitely also EEE with this. Take a game engine, create a fork for your platform, wait until your platform and fork has a significant market share, and then start introducing features to your fork, which are not directly available on the main-branch. Exactly. Or if it's not even a fork anymore (let's say it was merged upstream), make those features platform dependent / unportable even in the main codebase. It will still be EEE.
- Ezhik 10y agoI seriously doubt the UE license will allow this. The source code may be available but it's not "free software".
- detaro 10y agoAnd everybody using the fork still has to pay Epic according to the UE4 license, it doesn't matter for Epic which version they use: they get their 5% profit share either way. If Microsoft were to discourage Win32 apps Epic would have to adapt UE4, but the MS fork can't really make that harder.