4 ms·
The university should have told him when he enrolled for the course that some classes might not be possible because of his age. "Summer field work" sounds like
by arethuza 17y ago
The university should have told him when he enrolled for the course that some classes might not be possible because of his age.
"Summer field work" sounds like it could have a marked degree of risk and/or physical effort required. If that is the case, then I can see that it might not be a good idea for a kid to do them (regardless of how bright or mature he is).
- joshfinnie 17y agoRight, but replace a 13 year old with a 20 year old in a wheel chair and you can see where this gets interesting. If it is a requirement for his degree, I am not sure physical fitness can be used as a determent. I have to say though, I just finished up a fields method class and they are not easy. And mine was just in the woods of Connecticut not in Africa.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- badgerbombs 17y agoIt's different. Just because a 13 year old succeeds academically does not mean he has the skills to handle himself outside of a protected environment. The world will not care what his IQ is and will not treat him as special. He's a liability in South Africa, full stop. It would take a lot of money and/or risk to send him, so I support their choice.
- roboneal 17y agoSo what assessment is made to ensure that any given 18,19,20+ year old " has the skills to handle himself outside of a protected environment"? That's right, none, but the arbitrary assumption that they are "old enough". It's just as arbitrary assuming THIS 13-year old is "not capable".
- allenp 17y agoThere is the difference in legal responsibility of the university. I think this is probably the biggest stumbling block here - even with parental consent there is risk to the school. Imagine facing the newspaper headline "UConn loses 13-year-old prodigy in South Africa" . . .
- roboneal 17y agoPer the article, his mother offered to chaperon him at her own expense...makes your point kind of moot.
- allenp 17y agoHow so? He is still participating within the school's program. Just because his mom signs the field trip slip (or tags along herself) doesn't absolve the school from any and all responsibility for his well being. What sort of insurance policy do you think a school needs to fly a 13 year old from Connecticut to South Africa for a week? How about a 13 year old prodigy? I'm all for Colin being able to have this experience - I absolutely would have been thrilled to participate in something like this at any age. I don't think the school has any obligation to allow him to participate in this activity however.
- roboneal 17y agoIf they allowed him to enroll in this field of study but are now limiting his access to the curriculum, they should have just refused his tuition. That's the legal obligation. Did you read the article? She offered to sign an explicit legal waiver and accompany him on the trip at her own expense? It appears they family is willing to go to extraordinary lengths to compromise. If the university would look to "solve" the problem vs. outright denial - the family would probably pay cost of any "additional insurance" rider.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe university should have told him when he enrolled for the course that some classes might not be possible because of his age. This may not be reported in the submitted article, but if I remember correctly, some press report or another states that the family asked about this issue before enrolling the boy in UConn. He is pursuing a college major that involves fieldwork, and my recollection is that he took initiative to make sure that he would be allowed to do fieldwork before deciding where to enroll for his college major program. From involvement in the nonprofit organizations that I lead, I have also become aware of federal statutory law on the subject, which generally bars age discrimination (against the old OR THE YOUNG) in educational programs funded by federal appropriations, which would definitely include UConn. It would be the university's burden of proof to show that there is some specific reason that the specific student is unable to participate in the fieldwork (not likely, in this case) rather than the university's prerogative to declare that students below some age are ipso facto ineligible for the program.