4 ms·
Out of interest, what do you believe the opposing arguments to Wikileaks are?
by robin_reala 17y ago
Out of interest, what do you believe the opposing arguments to Wikileaks are?
- ErrantX 17y agoYou mean how can I support both sides? I fully support the need for whistleblowers like Wikileaks. But I am also fine with stuff being secret or not known. shrug the world just works like that. Wikileaks has the right to try and dig up secret stuff (though I dont fully agree with the way some of it is presented) and governments have the right to try and stop information escaping with reasonable measures. When got right there is a nice balance which should help in the effort to keep governments on the "straight and narrow".
- dsplittgerber 17y agoIf government in a democracy can only hold those powers the people have ceded, why are they allowed to withhold material information from the people? Sunshine is surely the best disinfectant.
- jonknee 17y agoIt would be dangerous for governments to have no secrets. I'm perfectly fine not knowing where our nuclear subs are or the specs of Air Force One. The issue is deciding what's classified and having whistleblowers are a good way to keep a balance (governments won't feel like they can get away with something just because it's classified) without risking tons of lives.
- invisible 17y agoI think it could be claimed that a PAST action often should not be classified unless it directly affects an ongoing directly related incident. If it needs to be classified, then maybe the US population as a whole would not have agreed with the action (and rightfully so). I think it does stoop to a low I feel we (as the US) should not venture down. Are individuals not able to make judgment calls based on evidence compiled?
- jonknee 17y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/30/us/politics/30secrets.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/30/us/politics/30secrets.html "President Obama declared on Tuesday that “no information may remain classified indefinitely” as part of a sweeping overhaul of the executive branch’s system for protecting classified national security information." It's getting closer to that goal.
- ubernostrum 17y agoI will respect you more if you'll start a perfectly transparent democracy which makes every piece of information public, and then see how well that works in a war.
- blasdel 17y agoForget war, what about painting the bikeshed?
- ErrantX 17y agoI'd happily discuss my thoughts r.e. this (I have a few) but HN is probably not the place for involved political discussion.
- usaar333 17y agoErrantX put it best. In general, their mission of exposing any leaked document can actually decrease freedom rather than increasing it. Examples: 1) If they ever leaked witness protection documents - the witnesses are now less free (more at risk). 2) Their actual leaking of the membership of the British National Party. You and I might disagree strongly with their platform, but, leaking that membership does harm discourse coming from a minority group (admittedly, an extreme one).
- lenley 17y agoI think the key as you said that some team at wikileaks ultimately controls the the editorial review of the information (intell) flow... Wikileaks makes editorial decisions, a lot of governments are going to be interested in the information that wikileaks receives but decides not to publish. Sorry, but that's what intel agencies world wide are going to do...accumulate information. In many ways wikileaks is simply a similar intel agency unless they begin to publish all the information they receive and become completely transparent. Of course, due to the nature of what wikileaks does, it seems that they can not afford to be transparent in their operations... somewhat ironic huh.. Wikileaks _needs_ secrecy in order to function.