5 ms·
I would add to the list many US "cities". If we define a city as a community large enough to meat the general needs of its inhabitants (health, commerce, work/
by sandworm101 10y ago
I would add to the list many US "cities". If we define a city as a community large enough to meat the general needs of its inhabitants (health, commerce, work/home etc) then lots of places in the US qualify as closed cities. Most of the large military bases a de facto cities, and they are closed.
Louisiana State prison (aka Angola) is a closed city imho. It has a golf course, farms, an air strip and cemetery.
My point is that wikipedia gives the impression that such cities are the mark of oppressive or secretive regimes, listing only a handful of formerly-closed cities in the US. And those were all relate in some way to the Manhattan project. But there are plenty of other closed cities in the US of today ... so um well ... read into that what you will.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoSurely Louisiana State prison is part of a locally oppressive regime even if the wider society outside is not.
- varjag 10y agoPeople living in closed cities were citizens not penalized in rights. Not so with prisons and labor camps.
- VLM 10y agoPrisons have guards and administrators and support staff who are free to enjoy the private golf courses and libraries and parks and stores. Likewise an army base with a basic training or advanced training school battalion isn't very free for new recruits but the cadre and soldiers unrelated to the basic training battalion may very well outnumber the recruits and live in a reasonably nice private closed city.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Prisons have guards and administrators and support staff who are free to enjoy the private golf courses and libraries and parks and stores. But don't generally live in the prison. The residents of the prison are not free citizens. > Likewise an army base with a basic training or advanced training school battalion isn't very free for new recruits but the cadre and soldiers unrelated to the basic training battalion may very well outnumber the recruits and live in a reasonably nice private closed city. US military bases are probably better examples or approximations of the idea of a closed city than US prisons.
- hueving 10y agoA closed city is not a prison keeping people in. It keeps people out. It's easy to get to the Louisiana State prison, just commit a crime appropriate to the security level of the prison and make going to that prison part of your plea bargain.
- sandworm101 10y agoBy wikipedia's def, a closed city is one where anyone entering has to provide identification and a reason for them to be there. You don't get into a large prison without a reason. You don't enter an army base without good reason.
- hueving 10y agoBy that definition every country with visa requirements is a closed city.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> If we define a city as a community large enough to me[e]t the general needs of its inhabitants (health, commerce, work/home etc) I can't tell what you're trying to say. Cities are never able to meet the needs of their inhabitants; they need to import food. In that sense, this would be an extremely odd way to define "cities". But you mention "commerce" -- if you assume that purchasing imported necessities counts as "meeting the needs of the inhabitants", I would think that everywhere on earth is "large enough" to do so. Also, without any uncomfortable analysis into what should and shouldn't count, a single peasant household definitely is large enough to meet the needs of its inhabitants in the same sense, whatever that is, that any urban area can. (Even peasant households -- and villages -- ordinarily purchase iron and salt rather than producing them.) Peasants, though, are generally considered the opposite of cities.