6 ms·
I live in the Outer Richmond district of San Francisco, which was built on sand dunes. Most houses in my neighborhood were built in the 1920s and 1930s, +/- a d
by wahern 10y ago
I live in the Outer Richmond district of San Francisco, which was built on sand dunes. Most houses in my neighborhood were built in the 1920s and 1930s, +/- a decade.
I was told by a contractor that it's extremely common for houses to have shifted considerably, sometimes by several feet. Mine certainly has, though not nearly that bad.
Most of the houses are built on concrete foundation walls that go about 3 feet into the sand. Despite being unreinforced and using water-permeable cement, they've seemed to hold up reasonably well. It's usually the whole house that shifts and racks. Yet looking from the street you wouldn't expect that because all the houses abut each other, with only a few inches or none of space in-between. (Perhaps this has mitigated the problem somewhat, though.)
Despite being built entirely on giant sand dunes, the Richmond district is only "moderately" prone to liquefaction. And there wasn't much notable damage during the 1989 earthquake, AFAIK. I think (though cannot confirm) that similar foundation techniques were used as far back as 1905 and earlier, in the Richmond, Sunset, and elsewhere, and judging by their survival and continued use of the foundation techniques I'm not particularly worried. (While widespread building in the western half of the city didn't begin in earnest until about 1910'ish, there are hundreds of buildings many decades older randomly distributed, especially closer to the beaches.)
The bigger problem is that almost all houses in the western half of the city were built with so-called soft stories as the first floor--basically a giant open space supported almost entirely by the external walls. Interestingly, AFAIK this design came before the widespread introduction of cars. These days nearly all houses use that space as a garage, but I believe they were built as unfinished first floors intended to be finished as desired--e.g. workshop, additional family rooms, in-law apartments, etc--while keeping the initial purchase price low.
- JosephHatfield 10y agoThe city is currently requiring many owners of soft story buildings in the Outer Richmond district to pay for seismic refitting.
- wahern 10y agoOnly those buildings with 5 or more units, which is only a tiny fraction of the structures. Ideally it should be every building, but it's ridiculously expensive to install moment frames, which is pretty much what every house needs given the typical layout of the houses. Each installation costs between $30k to $50k, and as well-off as you need to be to afford to purchase in San Francisco, that's still an expense few can justify even if they could afford it. We had structural plywood sheathing installed in our garage, and the typical job is around $10k. The pre-existing sheathing was installed by [presumably] a fly-by-night contractor shortly after the 1989 earthquake. Fortunately I noticed that it wasn't installed correctly and used the wrong materials, and so it was basically useless. But given that the garage door, garage side entrance, and entryway make up greater than 80% of the front wall of our first story, that we have a big window and door on the back wall, there's not much room for sheathing (properly installed or not) to control movement along that axis. The house is now very unlikely to collapse into the street, but we're still lucky to be sandwiched between two other houses. Fortunately, our neighbor on the corner had his foundation rebuilt and a third structural wall installed. I should probably be remunerating him somehow.
- omegaworks 10y ago...And allowing them to pass on 100% of the cost to their renters.
- vonmoltke 10y agoSo, you think landlords should operate at a loss for the benefit of their tenants?
- thebooktocome 10y agoOn the other hand, how fast does an empty unit depreciate in value?
- 205guy 10y agoSo you think that capital investments (in this case property) should have zero risk, in other words guaranteed returns?
- alasdair_ 10y agoObviously not. If the price is too high, people will not pay it.
- vonmoltke 10y agoI didn't say anything about zero risk. As the sibling comment indicates, if the cost is too high tenants will refuse to pay it by not renting the place. How long it takes the landlord to recoup the costs will depend on the local market for rentals.
- omegaworks 10y agoNot at all. I do, however, feel there should be some incentive for him to shop around for a good price.
- tomcam 10y agoWe call that "the profit motive"
- whyenot 10y agoI lived in SF's Inner Sunset for several years. When the old DeYoung museum was demolished and all the landscaping scraped away, the "soil" underneath was pure sand. I noticed the same thing at my home a few blocks away -- the city had to dig a trench in the street and after they got down a few feet, there was no soil, just beautiful beach sand. A little disconcerting with SF's earthquake history.
- theoh 10y agoAha! "In Paris, the famous phrase Sous les pavés, la plage! ("under the cobblestones, the beach") was used by the May 1968 protesters to mean that it was possible to escape from a regimented life." http://www.ruerude.com/2010/05/sous-les-pavés-la-plage.html http://www.ruerude.com/2010/05/sous-les-pavés-la-plage.html
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoHow do you plan plumbing and electricity for houses moving several feet?
- ptaipale 10y agoIf it's the earth below houses also moving, then the problems in plumbing and electricity do not appear at the house; they appear at the cross section of the moving and non-moving earth masses, and are typically the responsibility of utility provider.
- wahern 10y agoFor plumbing, I don't know. That's a good question I should ask a contractor the next time it comes up. But given how old these houses are perhaps the problems are sporadic. A broken pipe here or there gets fixed and people move on. And some kinds of movement might not matter, like if the back of the houses shifts down the front end might not move nearly as much. Also, AFAICT the plumbing comes up under the foundation walls, not through. Concrete slabs on the first floor aren't original (and you can still find the occasional house with a dirt floor at the first level), so maybe there are some degrees of freedom of movement that mitigate problems. For electricity the Richmond and Sunset districts and I believe the vast majority of the city uses overheard wires. So there's plenty of slack.
- batbomb 10y agoHi neighbor, I'm at 28th and Geary!