2 ms·
Gruber's right about there being two distinct sets of patents Theora has to worry about (basically big companies that are part of MPEG and random other companie
by ZeroGravitas 17y ago
Gruber's right about there being two distinct sets of patents Theora has to worry about (basically big companies that are part of MPEG and random other companies/trolls) but he's wrong about whether they are "likely" to infringe either set and wrong about basically everything else he says about patents in general e.g. misusing the term "submarine patents" even though he links to an accurate explanation on Wikipedia, and in their specific relation to Theora and H.264.
For example, why should Theora worry about H.264 patents? Theora is from the previous generation of codecs, which means it is both simpler and older, two very good things when it comes to patents. That's two very good reasons why Theora is less likely to be exposed to random non-MPEG patents than H.264.
If Theora infringes any MPEG patents then it's more likely patents from MPEG-1, 2 and 4 part 2 that they need to worry about. But these are well known and Theora has worked around them.
Thom (of OS News)'s arguments are, as you say, mostly rabble rousing, and probably wrong wherever he gets into specifics, but that doesn't magically make Gruber right.
But this does remind me of a million other tech battles where you have the choice of supporting the plucky underdog or rewarding the source of the actual problem (e.g. people building sites that work on IE6 only) and I think people getting angry, at least as a first step, is a potentially useful strategy.