3 ms·
> so even if it takes a longer time for life to evolve in that environment, it's still, on balance, more likely that life evolves around low mass stars in the n
by antisthenes 10y ago
> so even if it takes a longer time for life to evolve in that environment, it's still, on balance, more likely that life evolves around low mass stars in the near future ("near" still being tens to hundreds of billions of years). So we would expect that the typical life form will evolve around a low mass star, far in the future.
I find that premise to be false, given our (limited) knowledge about exoplanets already. The limited Goldilocks zone for low mass stars usually results in planets being tidally locked, leaving life to develop in narrow bands or in the hostile zones with direct sunlight or lack thereof.
Not all exoplanets around faint stars may be tidally locked, but with increasing distance it also pushes them out to the limits, where there may not be enough energy for life to develop (at near freezing ocean temperatures)
With more information we may find that perhaps there's also an optimal star brightness, which provides just enough energy at just the right distance for life to develop, disqualifying most dwarf stars.
In either case, whatever you believe, given our extremely limited information, any papers produced can be labeled as speculative, especially when we're talking about something where N = 1.
- antognini 10y agoMaybe. Many hot Jupiters are probably tidally locked, but it's not clear to me whether rocky planets will be tidally locked. Though given that they're considering timescales of 100s of Gyr maybe they will end up tidally locked by that point. At any rate, I don't think our understanding of tides is good enough to claim that they will or won't be tidally locked one way or another. But needless to say, the authors didn't consider details like this in their paper.
- Retric 10y agoMoons are one way around this.
- WildUtah 10y agoI use a moon on my home planet to keep tides interesting and find it lends a pleasing glow to the night sky. Thumbs up.