5 ms·
Would it be possible to do any real harm (to humans, pets, etc) by increasing this power setting or would this only cause interference with other electronics?
by koolba 10y ago
Would it be possible to do any real harm (to humans, pets, etc) by increasing this power setting or would this only cause interference with other electronics?
Also, which models is this for?
- callesgg 10y agoHarm to biological entity's no way. "causing interference" In theory, yes the possibility exists. In practice not likely. Other wifi ap's neer by might be drowned more than they would otherwise. You could call that interference.
- raarts 10y ago> In practice not likely. Depends. It apparently is real enough. Higher 5GHz WiFi band channels can interfere with airport radar. That's why the standard mandates a router to switch to another channel if it detects radar signals.[1] But of course using an illegal channel is simply illegal... [1] http://wifi-insider.com/wlan/dfs.htm http://wifi-insider.com/wlan/dfs.htm
- pdabbadabba 10y agoI cannot imagine why you're being down-voted. This isn't hypothetical; the FCC imposed these security restrictions after reports of actual interference to airport weather RADARs. https://www.fcc.gov/general/u-nii-and-tdwr-interference-enforcement https://www.fcc.gov/general/u-nii-and-tdwr-interference-enfo...
- wtallis 10y agoNote however that it appears that virtually all of those instances of interference were tracked down to Ubiquity point to point link devices. TP-Link's ordinary consumer access points and routers may have been out of compliance with the letter of the law, but they weren't causing actual harm to airport operations, let alone enough harm to justify banning OpenWRT.
- Sanddancer 10y agoOne individual home router operating illegally won't do much to increase the noise floor, but each router operating illegally adds that much more to the background noise and makes it that much more difficult for the weather radar to function properly. So yes, they were doing harm to airport operations. It's just like light pollution -- one light won't block out the stars, but a million will.
- wtallis 10y agoDo you have specific knowledge that diffuse ground-based access points impair the narrow beam TDWRs at issue, or are you just making a broad generalization? It's a decent analogy, but I can think of quite a few differences between a short range weather radar and a radiotelescope.
- Sanddancer 10y agoIt was one of the things discussed when making the decision to allow restricted use of the frequencies. Also, keep in mind that more than just airport weather radar use the frequency range in question. That frequency range is also used for satellite uplinks and downlinks. There was a lot of research put into the FCC's decision before it was enacted. https://www.ntia.doc.gov/files/ntia/publications/ntia_5_ghz_report_01-25-2013.pdf https://www.ntia.doc.gov/files/ntia/publications/ntia_5_ghz_... https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-14-30A1.pdf https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-14-30A1.pd...
- wtallis 10y agoThose are informative but rather long documents. Are there any specific portions you'd like to call my attention to? Because I'm seeing statements like "There have not been any cases of TDWR interference identified for other unlicensed device applications" (referring to things other than outdoor point to point links), and the sole satellite communications provider operating in the U-NII-1 band being concerned only with limiting the power radiated upwards from outdoor access points and unconcerned with indoor access points. For such a well-studied topic and with such strong regulation on the table, there really ought to be something relevant and approaching a smoking gun to point to.
- swiley 10y agoThe rules for using DFS 5ghz channels are so harsh that the networks built with them are almost uselessly unreliable. You're /far/ better off just not using channels requiring DFS. Especially if it means you can actually own the equipment you paid for.
- yuhong 10y agoWhich also reminds me of LTE-U vs WiFi. I wonder if the fundamental problems are similar.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y ago> "causing interference" In theory, yes the possibility exists. In practice not likely. uh... every time i've seen anyone increase their router's power usage, it was done directly to cause interference so as to MITM everyone else into ignoring the lower powered signals. you're all idiots.
- jimrandomh 10y agoInterference with other electronics, especially other wifi networks. Unused radio spectrum in an area is a limited resource, and if you transmit at a higher power level, you're getting longer range but you're also consuming that resource in a larger radius.
- Sanddancer 10y agoYes. The FCC allowed operation outside the normal Part 15 unlicensed band range in exchange for the makers of wifi devices promising not to intrude on certain areas within that range of frequencies. By increasing the power setting, you're disrupting navigation services, weather services, aviation services and maritime services. Some of these services are very sensitive to interference, and by setting up your devices to use those frequencies, your little router is essentially screaming into their ear, blocking people from getting information that may be essential for their safety. If you want more bandwidth, pester vendors into hurrying up with 802.11ad devices, don't go tromping on the neighbors' rf lawns.
- nisa 10y agothe big topic is weather radar on 5ghz channels at least in europe. The wifi router has to detect that and stop transmitting[1]. Besides that I don't think you can do soo much harm... on the models with pluggable antennas you pump of the power to 500mW and add some additional power through an antenna but in practice that buys you little or even does worse to your wifi... however DD-WRT allegedly got some knobs to do this and lot's of people did (higher is better!11!!) and this caused some fallout that the seemed to put the FCC into the need to intervene. Most wifi routers you can buy max out at 100mW some do 500mW you can multiply that if you add custom antennas but then the energy is directional. There is no harm to humans to animals, maybe eventually if you sleep and live directly (<100cm) next to the antenna 24/7 but even then your smartphone likely uses more power speak to the cell tower. 1: http://wifi-insider.com/wlan/dfs.htm http://wifi-insider.com/wlan/dfs.htm
- webtechgal 10y ago> some do 500mW you can multiply that if you add custom antennas... I am somewhat confused here. How can an antenna (a passive device) multiply (or amplify) the power? Yes, it can effectively increase the range by allowing the signal to propagate farther, but actually multiply the power? I don't think so, unless it also includes a signal amp/booster.
- nisa 10y agoyou are correct. sorry. here is a link that explains it well: http://www.tp-link.us/FAQ-3.html http://www.tp-link.us/FAQ-3.html I was refering to the ERP - in the article: > Even the law states [wrongly] that the "Effective Radiated Power (ERP) will not exceed..." and this is based on the input into the antenna multiplied by the antenna gain. So you are correct! Thanks for pointing that out!
- dogma1138 10y agoRF is a bit more complicated than that, you have also a specific gain on an antenna. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antenna_gain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antenna_gain The gain on the antenna doesn't create "energy" but it tells you how efficient an antenna is and what its RF characteristics would be, in general a high gain antenna is a directional one it would send a more focused transmission and would attenuate better to a receiving transmission from a certain direction only, a low gain antenna would have a more uniform RF profile (doughnut/spherical). High gain antennas are usually used for point to point applications so MW transmitters, P2P Wifi Links, TV/Satellite etc. while low gain antennas are used in devices where the transmission can come from any direction like for example GPS receivers, cell phones and handheld radios. For Wifi for most applications you would want a low gain antenna on your routers/AP's as they would give you uniform coverage, people often buy high gain antennas without understanding what it means, it's great if you want to line of sight 2 AP's across long distances but unless you also want to line of sight your XBOX it wouldn't have any positive impact on your wifi reception at home.