3 ms·
I want to feel bad. I really do. I have a lot of journalist friends and they have made cogent and reasonable arguments about how this will set a precedent tha
by jedberg 10y ago
I want to feel bad. I really do. I have a lot of journalist friends and they have made cogent and reasonable arguments about how this will set a precedent that will quell their speech. Even if they are reporting something that isn't libelous, they will always fear in the back of their mind that a wealthy person who doesn't like them will bring a case against them that will bankrupt them, even if what they wrote was legit, just through having to defend themselves.
On the other hand, I don't like Denton or Gawker because they have no ethics. I was personally harmed by them when they decided to make their hobby doxxing controversial reddit users, and I know someone whose life was completely destroyed by Gawker but didn't have the money to sue.
I'm also not a fan of the fact that a lot of their early content was literally them reposting reddit content without permission.
So if this were anyone else with any other media organization, I would totally be on their side and agree that this is a travesty of justice that Theil was able to fund this lawsuit.
But for Denton and Gawker? Good, they deserve to go down in flames.
Edit: I would like to add that some of those journalist friends work for Gawker Media, are upstanding, ethical, and wonderful people, and will most likely loose their jobs, and I feel terrible for them. It's just a few bad eggs at Gawker that ruined it for everyone, but it came from the top (Denton).
- whatok 10y ago> Even if they are reporting something that isn't libelous, they will always fear in the back of their mind that a wealthy person who doesn't like them will bring a case against them that will bankrupt them, even if what they wrote was legit, just through having to defend themselves. So I keep reading this argument but am having a hard time accepting it because it's acting like Thiel is somehow the first person to think of something like this. If you think this will become widespread as a result of Thiel's actions, why is it not widespread already? You could make the argument that media outlets (or really anyone) were just never made aware of who was actually financing lawsuits but I'm more than certain that if it was widespread that someone would have looked into it by now.
- zck 10y ago> So if this were anyone else with any other media organization, I would totally be on their side and agree that this is a travesty of justice that Theil was able to fund this lawsuit. There are two different things here, and I'm not sure I understand all the issues. 1. The personal vendetta. I understand this. (At least, probably) 2. The posting -- without permission -- of a sex tape made without Hogan's knowledge and in a private location. This seems morally indefensible to me. This is where I get a bit lost as to people defending Gawker. Shouldn't posting such a video be illegal?
- jedberg 10y ago> The posting -- without permission -- of a sex tape made without Hogan's knowledge and in a private location. This seems morally indefensible to me. This is where I get a bit lost as to people defending Gawker. Shouldn't posting such a video be illegal? Yes, probably. The issue stems from the fact that someone else paid for the lawsuit, which is a moral gray area, and in fact was illegal for a long time, even before the US existed (in British common law): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Champerty_and_maintenance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Champerty_and_maintenance
- LA_Banker 10y ago>and in fact was illegal for a long time Yeah, no. NYTimes v. Sullivan determined that public figures sacrifice a good deal of their privacy when they when they enter the public sphere. For instance, the same such video of, say, a governor would certainly be newsworthy. Where it's unclear is to what degree is Hogan a public figure and whether the actual publishing of it, as opposed to just reporting on it, is constitutes newsworthiness. In terms of lawsuit financing, it's perfectly legal. There's an entire industry devoted to third-party lawsuit financing – otherwise, poor victims of car attacks (or other consequences which injured their ability to work and earn) wouldn't be able to pursue personal injury claims. Without it, only those with means could pursue legal recourse.
- jedberg 10y agoI was saying that funding other people's lawsuits was illegal for a long time.
- beschizza 10y ago" I was personally harmed by them when they decided to make their hobby doxxing controversial reddit users" That would be violentacrez, right? http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/10/what-was-reddit-troll-violentacrez-thinking/263648/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/10/what-w...
- jedberg 10y agoNo, it was other people who I had to help after they were doxxed, but he was also seriously harmed by Gawker.
- LA_Banker 10y agoThere's a certain, perverse form of cognitive dissonance in thinking what Gawker did to Hogan was wrong, but ViolentAcrez and his posting of creepshots of underage girls was somehow unimpeachable free speech – and therefore his freedom to continue doing such ought to be protected. Do not the girls and women whose privacy he was invading not deserve the same right to privacy?
- jedberg 10y agoI never said what VA was doing was right or wrong, not did I say what they did to Hogan was right or wrong. I just said I don't feel bad because they were unethical in their journalism and caused real harm to people because of it (real people besides VA).
- LA_Banker 10y agoYou defend VA downthread while only decrying Gawker as being unethical. One takes photos of girls without their consent/knowledge while the other blurs the line of good journalistic taste. Yet it's only the latter that's unethical? It's not difficult to impute which you approve of.
- jedberg 10y agoI never defended VA, and never have. I think both were unethical and wrong.
- dang 10y ago> It's not difficult to impute which you approve of. That's crossing into personal attack, or at least sidling up to it. Please don't sidle that way here. In nuanced discussion, which is what we're hoping for on HN, there's plenty of ground between criticizing not-X and defending X.
- abz126 10y agoAnd when someone said "Oh, boo hoo, poor violentacrez." you didn't respect that they don't feel bad for him. You have a very clear case of hypocrisy here.