4 ms·
> The missile was launched by two separate keys (also kept in the safe), turned simultaneously and held for five seconds by the commander and deputy. Located on
by lisper 10y ago
> The missile was launched by two separate keys (also kept in the safe), turned simultaneously and held for five seconds by the commander and deputy. Located on separate consoles, there is no way they could be operated by one person. It would have been impossible to start World War Three by accident.
Seems to me the separate-console defense could have been easily defeated with a simple mechanical contrivance. How hard could it be to make a gadget that lets you turn a key from a distance?
- netcraft 10y agoBut that wouldn't have been accidental. They weren't necessarily trying to prevent attackers from being able to launch - more that someone couldn't put the wrong key in the wrong hole accidentally.
- lisper 10y agoRead the quoted passage again. "Located on separate consoles, there is no way they could be operated by one person." This was supposed to keep one rogue individual from initiating a launch.
- mikeash 10y agoThere's been a constant tension between the desire to control nuclear weapons and the desire to ensure nuclear weapons can be used in a war. These two goals are fundamentally in conflict to an extent. For a long time, the military was more worried about being unable to use a nuclear weapon due to a breakdown in the control system than they were worried about rogue officers using a weapon without permission. Permissive Action Links (devices in bombs which require an authentication code for the bomb to work) were resisted by the military, fearing that the codes might not be available when needed in wartime. That finally got forced on the Air Force and Army, but the Navy to this day doesn't have PALs on their weapons, because they see the risk of communications problems as being too high. For another example, the codes for the Minuteman ICBMs were set to 00000000. They remained like this until 1977. It's quite possible that this hardware was designed under a requirement that it would need two people to launch, but that it was deliberately engineered to make that requirement easy to bypass in case a single person needed to launch in wartime.
- chiph 10y agoNo, the concern was that a deranged officer might launch on their own, without correct authorization and checks from another person. This resulted in the two-man rule. When I did maintenance on our comm systems in certain areas of the base, there was always someone else with me. Entering alone meant that you would get shot (signs were up saying lethal force was authorized, and they meant it). What's more, our workcenter was divided into teams and members of each team would not be allowed to maintain equipment from the other, to prevent a single person from making unauthorized modifications to both. Two-man was taken quite seriously.
- Someone 10y agoThat depends on distance, relative orientation, obstructions between the keys, force required, etc, but chances are it would be easier to take the consoles apart and connect them by wire to a switch that makes two contacts. It probably would also be easier to smuggle such an electromechanical contraption in than smuggling in a five meter pole would be. Regardless of the method used, I think that would satisfy the goal of making it impossible to start World War Three by accident. It also would be very hard to do it intentionally, but by a single person, as the guards outside the main room wouldn't let a single person stay in the main room, and wouldn't let anybody carry in weird stuff.