4 ms·
Radio propagation is quite a bit like magic, and if you're an engineer making a microwave, you probably really don't care that much about the theoretical underp
by colechristensen 10y ago
Radio propagation is quite a bit like magic, and if you're an engineer making a microwave, you probably really don't care that much about the theoretical underpinnings. The thought process goes something like this:
I have a loud radio source I want to keep contained in a box. I want people to be able to see into that box while it's on. I know that radio waves are blocked as long as the holes are smaller than some multiple or fraction of the wavelength of the radio source.
So what do I do? I think about what's easy and cheap to manufacture while being reliable. I try out a few things and measure the radio leakage. I pick the best solution out of the few I tried.
None of that really has anything to do with the subtleties of theory, the practice is you want something good at shielding that's good for the guys building it.
- monochromatic 10y agoThat's probably a pretty good guess for what happened early on when designing microwave doors. And 99% of what's happened since is "the existing design is effective and cheap, so I'm not gonna try to fix what ain't broken."
- DINKDINK 10y agoYour post is a great description of the phenomenon that Tableb describes in his book Antifragility, as "Lecturing Birds how to fly" [1] Essentially the argument is: we learn by doing and formalize that knowledge in research. Birds don't need to be lectured on fluid mechanics(drag,lift,etc) to understand how to fly. [1]http://www.yourparttimehrmanager.com/lecturing-birds-to-fly-overreliance-on-formal-education/ http://www.yourparttimehrmanager.com/lecturing-birds-to-fly-...
- kleer001 10y agoAnd it seems to me a trivial step to then say that formalized knowledge churned through the science leads us to things that are impossible for birds.
- jacquesm 10y agoThe counterpoint to that is people that have read a book on what a certain organism is supposed to do / usually does and then extrapolate that to all organisms of that variety in all situations. They usually forget that said organism hasn't read that book and will do whatever it damn well pleases given the physical constraints it finds itself under.