2 ms·
For health care as a "customer", I think I like it. I'd rather have some assembly-line style automatons applying empirically validated flow-chart medicine than
by _delirium 17y ago
For health care as a "customer", I think I like it. I'd rather have some assembly-line style automatons applying empirically validated flow-chart medicine than old-style generalist doctors going off their gut instinct. Sure, sometimes you really need some critical thinking, but 95%+ of medicine is routine, and more liable to be screwed-up than helped by someone going off-script.
Going even further, I'd be happy to see computers do more routine medical work. It's been 35 years since the system MYCIN beat most physicians in its (admittedly narrow) area of competence, and yet we still have huge amounts of automatable stuff being done by fallible humans attempting to recall something out of a med-school textbook.
- ippisl 17y agoI think technology is taking diagnosis from doctors , but not in the way thought by MYCIN ( diagnose using a list of symptoms). A better way to diagnose is using improved molecular tests, and new imaging methods. those have a few benefits: 1. Higher accuracy. 2. Sometimes you can diagnose in a very early stage of the disease , with no apparent symptoms(i.e. screening) 3. You can diagnose by the cause , not by the symptoms. when you have the exact cause you can give much better treatment. Molecular methods probably have easier acceptance by doctors vs expert systems , probably because they don't seem as a direct competition.