4 ms·
>> Instead the post attacks a straw man argument about "General intelligence", something that no AI researcher is claiming. Several of the Deep Learning people
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
>> Instead the post attacks a straw man argument about "General intelligence", something that no AI researcher is claiming.
Several of the Deep Learning people are on record making silly claims about the future of AI. I'll dig you up the links if you insist [1] but frex, Juergen Schmidhuber has made noises to the effect that deep nets have shown intuition and things like that. Jeoff Hinton has said similar things.
The reason for that is that the original AI project started out to create strong AI in the first place, so if you could not show that your theory has some sort of chance to lead to strong AI people would scoff at it. There's still a bit of that in academia and in industry and parts of the press have not yet gotten the memo that things have changed now, so you'll still hear lots of people making these claims, or having such claims drawn out of them in interviews.
But that's besides the point- which is that a lot of the very clearly stated goals of the industry require the development of systems with human-like intelligence. For instance, natural language processing. We have made some advances in recent years (for instance in things like part of speech tagging or even machine translation to an extent) but the parts of language that we really take for granted as humans, conveying meaning and being aware of some sort of context, those are completely outside our grasp for the time being.
So when Google pretends it can just throw a ton of processing power at, say, machine translation between any two languages any time, and get it to work well, you know that's just its marketing people knowing they can claim anything they like and only their engineering team will be in a position to know how far it is from the truth.
_______
[1] please don't, I need to stop procrastinating.
- cLeEOGPw 10y ago> Juergen Schmidhuber has made noises to the effect that deep nets have shown intuition and things like that. The only thing wrong in this sentence is your sarcastic tone. Neural nets, deep or not, rely on intuition to produce output, so it is completely true that deep nets show intuition. What is intuition? It's a feeling that something is of a certain way that is not obvious or immediately obvious/self evident. And translated to ML terms, it is some amount of certainty about something. Intuition is an intrinsic feature of any ML algorithm.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> What is intuition? It's a feeling Do you see the problem with this line of thought? You're now arguing that machine learning algorithms have feelings. Well, I got feelings too and your assumption I'm being sarcastic makes me really, really sad T_T
- cLeEOGPw 10y agoYou are mixing feelings with emotions. Sadness is a feeling, but more specifically an emotion. A generic feeling is just amount of fitness to the pattern. The better the network is fit to recognize specific pattern (machine or human alike), it can be said the better "feeling" of the pattern it has. By the way, emotions won't be that difficult to implement once the feeling part will work.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> A generic feeling is just amount of fitness to the pattern. This is nonsense and the rest of your comment is nonsense on stilts.
- cLeEOGPw 10y agoLooks like someone's amount of fitness to the pattern got hurt.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoOn a more serious note (and therefore a different comment) you're not even, like, factually correct. What you call "certainty", more commonly known as confidence, which you seem to think is a component of all machine learning algorithms [1], is actually a characteristic of probabilistic classifiers and makes sense primarily in a Bayesian belief network context in any case. If you train an SVM for instance, you would normally not learn much about its degree of confidence to its results (unless you explicitly output probabilities). Also like I say it's called confidence not "certainty" and it absolutely refers to the degree of confidence of an observer of a given phenomenon, and not some mental state of a system that computes the probabilities by which that observer sets his or her degree of confidence. Not to mention that in any other context, such terms as "belief", "confidence", and so on are only used metaphorically and - assuming a modicum of reason - only sparingly. [1] You say that in the context of machine learning intuition is "some amount of certainty" and so "an intrinsic feature of any ML algorithm". Correct me if I misunderstood that.