3 ms·
I've negotiated hundreds or maybe thousands of salaries. The goal should be to find a salary that is appropriate for the employees skills and experience level.
by andrewstuart 10y ago
I've negotiated hundreds or maybe thousands of salaries.
The goal should be to find a salary that is appropriate for the employees skills and experience level. Neither too high nor too low.
You do not want anyone to "win" the negotiation.
The idea is to find a salary that will ensure that the employee feels that they are being appropriately paid during their employment, and will not be browsing jobs because they feel they are under market rate. You want to employer to feel that they have someone who is being paid at a level that reflects the employees skills and experience and is broadly consistent with other employees at a similar level.
Negotiating isn't a battle. It's a process of trying to find if there is common ground.
If the employee and the employer do not find satisfactory common ground then the negotiation should end gracefully - both parties move on.
It's important to work out at the very beginning of the employment process if jobseeker and employee are in the same ballpark on salary - it's silly and wasteful of everyones resources to get to the end of a process only to find out the parties expectations do not synch.
- poikniok 10y agoThat seems a bit reductionist to me. Basically I think there are a lot of spots where a software developer provides say 500k a year of value to the company, and the company is looking to hire a person for about 150k a year in total comp. But if they hire somebody for 200k a year, it is not as if they are going to get rid of the person, it is still +EV for the company. And while the company might not be quite as delighted with the latter's value proposition, the employee is far better off negotiating aggressively and trying to "win". And as to why the company would not just try and wait and find a person for 150k, it is generally because good software developers are hard to find, and it is easier and lower risk to "overpay" a bit rather than lose out on a good hire.
- dustingetz 10y agoBig companies with margins like that fire for underperformance, so your ev analysis is missing some inputs I think
- poikniok 10y agoSure reality is often very complicated. However there is one thing in my experience that I want to contribute, which to me was non-obvious when I realized it. Which is that in large companies often times once you are hired your manager effectively cares very little about what you are paid. Their expectations are more or less the same whether you are paid 150k or 200k. Because often HR is in charge of negotiations, and then the manager just comments on performance, and not performance relative to pay. And also in my experience extra pay can improve performance. In my current job I negotiated my pay 65k higher than the initial offer, and thus did not feel bad at all about paying for a 4k apartment which is a 10 minute walk from work. As a result of my commute being negligible I perform much better at work and am far more rested than some of my colleagues who commute to save money. And my manager does not care why my performance is good, all he knows is that it is, and that is reflected in my evaluations.
- pm90 10y agoThis is so true. And I don't see a solution for it unless there is a closer collaboration between HR and the manager. This is often very hard, since the 2 are usually in different orgs with different goals and priorities. Ultimately, it basically means that it is in the employees interest to negotiate very high at the beginning... since there are very few forces that will increase their salary once they do join a company.
- thefastlane 10y ago"Negotiating isn't a battle" of course it is. you make this sound like there is no asymmetry, that it boils down to two equal parties sitting down to chat over tea. that's not the case. this is a completely asymmetrical process, where the firm really has most of the power. they are essentially uneffected, no matter the outcome of the negotation. "it's silly and wasteful of everyones resources to get to the end of a process only to find out the parties expectations do not synch" again, you are implicitly promulgating the fiction that this amounts to two equal parties trying to find a meeting point. it just isn't. i see how tech companies go about recruiting. it's an assembly line. their recruiting process is a well-oiled machine, an assembly line -- and i'm the widget on their conveyer belt. if i attempt to get a salary that i think i deserve, and fail, they won't lose any sleep. their well-oiled machine will continue to hum. software engineers are a commodity to the firms we interview at. you patronize us by suggesting otherwise.
- soneca 10y agoI agree with you. "You want to employer to feel that they have someone who is being paid at a level that reflects the employees skills and experience and is broadly consistent with other employees at a similar level." No, you don't want the employer feels there is equality in salaries. If the employer cared about that it wouldn't have hired on a high salary in the first place. And any "feeling" by the employer is literally irrelevant, as by their own standards, the moment they accept to hire you at a higher salary. Now, it is different regarding colleagues. But your argument that it is in the employee best interest to not push for a higher salary, is nonsense. BTW, I am not a developer or engineer, I am a marketing person and no one in my line of work would ever consider this. This sounds a lot like companies that hire tech people trying to rationalize why developers should not earn that much with anything that is not just economical market balance.
- clarkmoody 10y ago> "I've negotiated hundreds or maybe thousands of salaries." How many job offers have you accepted or rejected? Perhaps the GP has more experience (and a more even keel) than you? > the firm really has most of the power The firm cannot compel you to accept an offer and work for them. > if i attempt to get a salary that i think i deserve, and fail, they won't lose any sleep. their well-oiled machine will continue to hum. Perhaps you should reconsider what you think you deserve, or move on to another city or sector that will value your skills more highly than the "tech company assembly line."
- pm90 10y agoI agree with your assertion that the salary ballpark should be worked out at the beginning of the process. However, my experience has generally been this: 1) 3rd party recruiters (i.e. staffing professionals who work for another company) are often upfront about this since they are given a salary range for the position that they need to fill 2) Internal recruiters are notoriously bad for being vague about the salary ranges. In the latter case, the standard response I get at the beginning is something like "we are prepared to pay an appropriate amount of compensation based on your skill level". But then when the negotiation actually starts, they balk at the range that I ask for.
- jonnathanson 10y agoIt's generally a good idea to do some research ahead of time on the compensation range that the company offers for the position you're seeking (and not just salary, but total comp package, including benefits). You won't get this out of an internal recruiter, no matter how hard you try, unless he or she willingly volunteers it. Instead, go to sites like Glassdoor, or consult with friends at the company or at similar companies. You want to reduce the information asymmetry as much as possible before starting the interview process. And there are resources and tools available to you to do so. If you're hearing all the time that your ask is way out of step with the range for the role, then it probably is. Companies don't have blank checkbooks available for roles; they operate on ranges or "bands" that they try to keep consistent across job titles and responsibility sets. If Company X has a range of $125k-$175k base salary for a job I'm seeking, and I ask for $250k, that isn't going to fly, no matter how much I impressed them in the interview. It will strike them as out of synch with the level and title and requirements of the job I am interviewing for. They will either counter within their range and say it's the best they can do, or they'll tell me I'm being unrealistic, and that perhaps my expectations for the role are mismatched with theirs. Often the latter. And if it's a wild mismatch -- say, they have the aforementioned range, and I ask for $350k -- then the mismatch is as much my fault as it is theirs. I didn't do my homework.
- azanar 10y agoI completely agree with you! It boggles my mind how much people will tend to treat negotiations, amongst so many other things, as zero-sum games. If that were true, anyone who claims this should please explain to all the people who entered into negotiated agreements and found mutual benefit how they are actually being screwed by the counterparty. For those who believe negotiation is zero-sum, I will say to you: if you notice agreements around you tend to turn sour because a party in it feels like they got screwed, take note of the common element. This includes salary and employment negotiation. Unless you are in a one company town, or otherwise have skills and talents that are transferable to nowhere than your present employer, you most likely have alternatives to explore. Even if this is the case, there are alternatives, although they will not be anywhere near as easy to achieve. Even then, it is not every employer that will decide the best way to profits is to screw their employees, and hope they feel hopeless. This is but one way to affect the bottom-line, and often not a very effective one. People will be more productive when they don't feel like they are being shafted. Not just in salary, but in: career development; personal sanity; and, if they care and have an interest in such a thing, in the net outcome of the organization. So, I absolutely agree with you. Do not stand for people who feel like they need to "win" because you'll invariably screw them back. They may ultimately add up to a great big loss for everyone involved.