6 ms·
There are limits to 2FA
- subway 10y agoPlease don't conflate Apple's "Can you read a message we sent you?" verification with well designed 2FA.
- stephengillie 10y agoThe limits described in this article are where all components are part of the same system - the 2FA device (iPhone) can be disabled from the same system (iCloud) that is protected by the 2FA device. Thus compromises had to be built into the system to allow device recovery, since that is also part of the same system. Were iCloud 2FA provided by an Android device (or PC or Blackberry or RSA keychain), this problem could be easily obviated.
- JBiserkov 10y agoGitHub/Google/Microsoft/Blizzard/Heroku have "recovery" or "backup" codes which you are supposed to keep in a safe place (perhaps even a physical safe) and can be used when the phone is not available(lost, locked, erased, whatever). They are one-time only (that's why you get 10), but are not time sensitive (like those generated by app/token) so they are longer.
- iokanuon 10y agoGoogle also tells you to add a second, "backup" number for two factor auth, or even more of them. It can be a landline, or a trusted person phone.
- atemerev 10y agoPhone or SMS based 2FA is inherently insecure. Can be intercepted at carrier level (and it is quite cheap to do it — some political targets in Russia and Turkey were attacked this way).
- lorenzhs 10y agoYeah but that's a different threat model than the one discussed. It will prevent 99% of attacks but someone always comes in yelling "BUT IT'S NOT PERFECT". As they say, perfect is the enemy of good.
- atemerev 10y agoThe solution which is considered to be "almost perfect" and relied upon as that, but failing unexpectedly is arguably worse than imperfect solution with known imperfections.
- rhizome 10y agoThe solution which is considered to be "almost perfect" and relied upon as that, but failing unexpectedly What other failure mode is there? A solution that's considered to be actually perfect? Regardless, you have to account for Godel.
- atemerev 10y agoBlack swans arise because when people design things that work 99.99% of the time, they tend to relax and rely on the system more than they should, and when this 0.001% event happens, they are completely unprepared. The correct mode of operation is to always be prepared, without relying on the "perfect" system too much. If system is actually good, "chaos monkeys" may be employed to keep everybody prepared.
- prodigal_erik 10y agoWhy would 99% of adversaries fail to choose the attack that's known to work?
- lorenzhs 10y agoNot everyone is a nation state or has SS7 access. Intercepting SMS isn't as easy as you make it out to be.
- yeukhon 10y agoAs I said above, the problem with MFA is now you have one static code for every MFA account, so we are re-introducing the problem public key infrastructure would solve, which I consider is a pretty valid limitation of MFA.
- eximius 10y agoIt sounds like his complaint is that Apple doesn't use 2FA when you acknowledge your 2FA device is unavailable (I had trouble following the article). This is admittedly bad. All they need is an offline code or something like Google's recovery codes. It's actually somewhat disappointing that so few sites have something like that.
- dendory 10y agoIt's a bit of a catch 22, if you lose your iPhone then you need some way to locate it / erase it without having your iPhone. I don't think it's a big deal, you should have backups anyways. One thing they could do is, if you have more than 1 device on your account, then force you to use another device for 2fa.
- derefr 10y agoIt occurs to me that the "use another device" verification process built into iCloud Keychain would work well for this. You could make the entire thing cryptographic, actually: just store each device's "erase code" in the Keychain, such that you have to auth yourself on one of the devices that has the unlocked keychain in order to (automatically) grab the erase code and send it to the associated device.
- ams6110 10y agoYou're still screwed if you lose both devices (e.g. a burglary where both your phone and laptop are taken).
- atemerev 10y agoI once left my bag with both inside. It surfaced in city's lost and found two months after, thankfully. But if I had 2FA enabled, it would have been mighty inconvenient.
- Symbiote 10y agoI keep some Google and Github account recovery codes on a slip of paper with my passport, some more in my wallet, and all in an encrypted file on a server with SSH access. Hopefully that's enough that I'm not too inconvenienced, should my phone be stolen.
- atemerev 10y agoHow often do you travel?
- slg 10y agoThe headline is a little misleading. The "limits" aren't with 2FA. The problem is there are holes in Apple's feature set where 2FA isn't enabled. This is an Apple problem and not necessarily a 2FA problem. As others have said, there are ways around this lost device problem like the one time use codes that Google and other companies provide.
- atemerev 10y agoCan also be lost. I am losing things constantly (laptops, phones, documents — damn you, ADD), and I wouldn't want to be locked out from my digital life just because I lost another piece of paper or device. In compensation, my symbolic memory is excellent — never had a problem with memorizing long passwords.
- sbarre 10y agoThen you should be able to memorize one of your backup codes, and you'll be fine.. I don't know if Apple does this, but Google's 2FA (and others) gives you static (printable - or memorizable!) backup codes in case you lose your device.
- homero 10y agoA bag of codes hidden in the pantry can't easily get lost
- atemerev 10y agoI lived in 6 different countries and changed 60 rented apartments (not to mention countless hotels). Challenge accepted.
- rabboRubble 10y agoApple has two types of what might be called 2FA, two-factor and two step authentication. If memory serves, two step has a back up code that needs to be maintained by the end user. If the user misplaces this code, the account is unrecoverable. Two factor does not have this back up code feature. When I went to the genius bar to ask about this, they said that an affected user would need to contact Apple and they would interrogate the user to confirm identity. This seemed a bit strange to me but whatever. Now with two factor I thought a code could be generated from any previously authenticated device that is El Capitan / IOS 9.3. These devices can generate codes while offline and unconnected. To generate an offline code from a Macbook, turn off WIFI then open Settings > iCloud > Account Details > Get Verification Code. To generate an offline code from an iPhone/iPad, put in airplane mode, > Settings > iCloud > tap your picture / name / Apple account icon-y think at the top > Get verification code. So when I read this article, I'm thinking to myself that myabe I know a trick that the author did not. Am I missing something?
- darkhorn 10y ago2FA? Several years ago I have enabled 2FA on Facebook. One day they they stopped sending SMS and thus I wasn't able to log in to Facebook for arounnd half month. Fuck 2FA on Facebook!
- matco11 10y agoWhy not simply disabling "back to my iPhone"? I question its value against theft - thieves these days know about taking your device offline. Sure, it is useful if you forget your phone somewhere, but how often does that happen? It seems the intrinsic risk of attack you expose yourself to by having "back to my iPhone" enabled is greater than the risk of forgetting your iPhone somewhere...
- 0x0 10y agoFind my iphone also has the benefit that if you erase and lock your lost iphone, then (in theory) the device becomes useless as it will refuse to reactivate, even with a factory reset. (aka "Activation Lock"). The idea is to make stealing these types of devices much less attractive (by killing off any resale value)
- mohsinr 10y agoI use 2FA and love it, however one issue I faced that I wanted to highlight for anyone having missing sms issues... in our country we can keep the number but change phone company, called porting number to other carrier... it works great however international sms which is mostly the case with 2FA messages, never work after number porting. Do not know it is just issue with our country porting config or universal problem. So anyone having issue of no sms received...may look into it if number ported...
- metafunctor 10y agoIt's possible to receive SMS sent to your number without your knowledge. The GSM network cannot be trusted, so SMS is not a very good 2FA method.
- ktta 10y agoYou never mention the name of your country though :)
- mohsinr 10y agoPakistan :)
- ereli1 10y agowhen an attacker is trying to access my Find My iPhone feature, I expect Apple to offer a different version of the their 2fa - either by user pre-authed device along with a special secret (those offline password print outs) or another form (landlines, biometrics, knowledge based, etc.). remote wiping someone's one can a very serious threat if they don't offer something that handles both the usability requirements and the security of the service.
- pi-err 10y agoWhat's the goal of a "Find my iPhone" attack? Ransomware? Also puzzled that the attacker manages to guess the victim's password (described as complex). In my experience, 3 incorrect login attempts on iCloud block the site for a while. Is there more to this story?