4 ms·
What they're missing is that higher wages depend on some barrier to entry (there are many kinds) that protects the people who have jobs at the expense of anyone
by skybrian 10y ago
What they're missing is that higher wages depend on some barrier to entry (there are many kinds) that protects the people who have jobs at the expense of anyone who is looking for a job.
As someone who works for a company with high hiring standards and correspondingly high pay, I have mixed feelings about this. It seems like there should be some jobs that are easy to get without much training, and taxi driver is a good candidate for this. If we build fences around every kind of job, life gets even harder for the unemployed.
So I'm not automatically on the side of workers with more "skin in the game." I'd need a stronger argument about why we should support them rather than part-time drivers.
- jessaustin 10y agoI don't disagree, but why would Uber have lower fences than Swift? At least some of the part-timers must be surge-seeking: do their higher pay requirements reflect that they have higher skills than the 13-hour-day drivers?
- skybrian 10y agoIf you have some other obligations so you can't work full time, that already rules out most jobs, so it could be a barrier to entry all by itself. I don't know how many people that is. It would be interesting to find out.
- jessaustin 10y agoThat is an interesting question, but does Jacobin expect Swift to exclude part-timers? That would be a tricky philosophical position...
- bobcostas55 10y ago>that protects the people who have jobs at the expense of anyone who is looking for a job. And also at the expense of the customers.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWorkers making a living wage is more important than customers receiving a service at little cost.
- ma2rten 10y agoI think the most valid complain about Uber as an employer is that it is advertised as well a paying job but that there are hidden costs that most drivers won't consider. It's similar to how programmers often look at consulting rates, but don't factor in non-billable hours.
- paulddraper 10y agoDoes Uber have substantially more hidden costs than, say, a pizza delivery driver.
- thrill 10y agoNobody looks twice at the car the pizza is delivered in. Pick up a few riders in a car that smells like pizza, and you'll no longer be an Uber driver.
- paulddraper 10y agoSo keeping a clean car is one of the hidden expenses?
- niuzeta 10y agoI'd say keeping a care desirable to warrant a 5-star rating is, or any upkeep cost you would have to pay that Uber does not subsidize. I'm not a driver so I can't comment on specifics, but I doubt Uber pays for fuel, unless you're a full-time driver.
- jdminhbg 10y agoAgree to an extent, although I'd add that it's also similar in that people looking in from the outside frequently neglect to factor in the flexibility premium -- programmers who do consulting work frequently do so because they either enjoy or need to be able to set the amount of hours they work and when. Similarly, lots of Uber drivers seem to do it because they can just sorta fit in hours whenever they feel like it, without having to follow a manager's schedule.
- davidf18 10y agoThese "barriers to entry" is called "economic rent". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent Economic rents are harmful to the economy and keep new labor entrants out as you have pointed out making it harder for young people or others to get a job. A way to complete with Uber and existing taxi services is to provide greener vehicles such as electric or hybrid (the new yellow taxi medallion cabs in NYC are all hybrid). Just as people are willing to pay more for organic food they probably be willing to pay for cleaner vehicles.
- ianai 10y agoWhile they're harmful to the economy, the economy really seems to favor them.
- davidf18 10y agoIt is because special interests have a greater influence in lobbying for their good than the diffuse interests of the general population.
- ianai 10y agoThat's certainly part of it. But the economy rewards and enforces concentrations of power as a naturally emergent property. If you're Verizon you don't have to worry about too much about market entrance. If you create a highly demanded, new good or service then you'll quickly create all sorts of things empowering assets: market share, name recognition, and other 'incumbent powers'.
- valhalla 10y agoI disagree completely. Uber's inception/success was partly because of existing taxi services' "barriers to entry". Medallions were worth about $1 million each when Uber started in NYC (http://bloom.bg/2aCEeQA http://bloom.bg/2aCEeQA). That's a textbook case of an economic rent. Taxi service was often discriminatory in NYC and other cities: taxi drivers often refuse to pick up black passengers assuming they won't pay once they reach their destination and I've had gay friends openly complain about how SF cab drivers used to throw them out on Pride or after a PDA with their significant other. This was the status quo for decades because of the barriers to entry of municipal taxi services' monopoly. They never had to anything about it since their was no competition and if you didn't like it, you probably shouldn't take a cab. Besides Uber's barriers to entry are it's scale (low prices and reliable service) and brand than de facto monopoly status (which I assume is what you're talking about since you mostly talk about competition beside summing up your link). The fact that a co-op could potentially "disrupt Uber" is evidence of that.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoWhy should low-paid car drivers be the ones sharing their hours/pay with the othwerwise unemployed, while highly-paid professionals don't? This is exactly the argument for minimum wage: by raising prices and limiting # of employed (which could mean more people at fewer hours for the same total pay, OR fewer people at more hours for the same total pay), there is more funding for the overall labor pool, instead of more worker-hours sharing a smaller pie of funding.
- icebraining 10y agoWhy should low-paid car drivers be the ones sharing their hours/pay with the othwerwise unemployed, while highly-paid professionals don't? That's only a relevant question if the policy being proposed is actually likely to achieve a transfer from highly-paid professionals to the unemployed. Which is certainly not obvious, let alone consensual.