3 ms·
"Hester Harriet Marsden-Smedley" Wow. Just wow. And apparently it isn't never lupus. Gladwell has a knack for making me want to know more about his topics. Not
by mcguire 10y ago
"Hester Harriet Marsden-Smedley" Wow. Just wow. And apparently it isn't never lupus.
Gladwell has a knack for making me want to know more about his topics. Not by reading Gladwell, of course; that would be pointless.
He makes the assertion in this article that intelligence services in general, and British intelligence in the early decades of the cold war specifically, are useless. Based on a few examples, he thinks that having MI5 and 6 riddled with spies had no consequences---either the intelligence wasn't believed or it was, it was acted on, and people died, but that didn't change the outcome. Further, he says the later, paranoid period was bad, although other than a couple quotes from politicians, he gives no evidence.
And yet, the period between 1945 and 1965 was the high point of the Soviet Union. Taking over neighbors. Stealing secrets. Influence. Striking terror in the hearts of free world politicos. And then, after the golden age of Philby, not so much, realistically.
- atemerev 10y agoBack in Russia, we considered our golden age to be 1966 to 1982. Soviet spy stories of this time are no less dramatic.
- eps 10y agoThat's a very debatable assertion, comrade. If true, the 70s-80s period would've not commonly referred to as The Stagnation Period. Plenty of spy activity, granted, but calling it a golden era is an overstatement.
- ktRolster 10y agoLack of purges, lack of famine, lack of war, maybe could find something better than a Khrushchyovka.......the struggle continued, but there was less struggling.
- sverige 10y agoI have followed these stories for a few decades. Gladwell makes an unusual argument, to be sure, but I think his point about selecting false positives and false negatives is pretty good. James "Jesus" Angleton undoubtedly wreaked havoc on the CIA in the '60s with his obsessions about moles, for example. Whenever I dig deep into the spy world from my armchair, though, I always come to the conclusion that my father was right when he said that it's not healthy to keep secrets.