4 ms·
I disagree with some points. The hate for "no middle management" is laughable HOWEVER the "too many cooks" situation can definitely happen The German managemen
by raverbashing 10y ago
I disagree with some points. The hate for "no middle management" is laughable HOWEVER the "too many cooks" situation can definitely happen
The German management style is built on many people agreeing at the same time and doing things as good as possible which is great when you're building a train network but not so much with software
- elcapitan 10y agoNot just management, but all parts of German society. It leads to a Merkel-ish leadership style with late, opportunistic decisions.
- hengheng 10y agoYou could also call it a Volkswagen approach towards innovation. Never first to market, never anything rushed out, and do not stray away from the beaten path until the new thing has been implemented perfectly.
- allendoerfer 10y agoBuying up every brand under the sun and cutting costs by putting the same window openers into their cars sounds reasonable to me. Tesla is innovative and all, so was Porsche. VW does not care and just buys you. I mean, they are running out of car companies to buy so they have to buy motorcycle manufacturers.
- elcapitan 10y agoThe original VW (the bug) was innovative, but then again, that was actually a Porsche (designed by Ferdinand Porsche) ;)
- theoh 10y agoI know I'm not supposed to mention The War, but according to John Boyd, there was a similar phenomenon in the German army which aided the success of Blitzkrieg tactics: 'According to General Gunther Blumentritt, such a scheme presupposes a common outlook based upon “a body of professional officers who have received exactly the same training during the long years of peace and with the same tactical education, the same way of thinking, identical speech, hence a body of officers to whom all tactical conceptions were fully clear.” Furthermore, a la General Blumentritt, it presupposes “an officers training institution which allows the subordinate a very great measure of freedom of action and freedom in the manner of executing orders and which primarily calls for independent daring, initiative and sense of responsibility.”'
- elcapitan 10y agoThat's actually an older (going back to 19th century) German army leadership style, called Auftragstaktik (mission style tactics, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mission-type_tactics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mission-type_tactics). It means that instead of giving concrete orders how to do something, the leader gives order to achieve a certain goal, and it is in the autonomy of the next level of leadership to decide about how to do it. This is directly related to Clausewitz' understanding of war as something that is very much up to chance and unpredictable outcomes, rather than something that can be planned completely beforehand.
- theoh 10y agoThat's interesting. Two quotes from the Wikipedia page that I think are relevant to this discussion of management styles: "[There is the following] implicit requirement imposed on superior commanders: * to give their subordinates no more orders than are essential (every order given is regarded as an additional constraint upon its recipient), and: * to be extremely rigorous, absolutely clear, and very succinct in the expression of their commands." "Few armies seem to have mastered the approach. The Wehrmacht are perhaps the premier example—a degree of competence achieved only after rigorous training under Hans von Seeckt between 1919 and 1935." So Boyd's observations about WWII are corroborated by that account.
- elcapitan 10y agoI guess the big mental requirement there is the ability (on all command levels) to understand strategy and translate it into tactics, and to change from one tactic to another in order to achieve the same strategic goal. This was what Helmuth von Moltke (Chief of Staff of the Prussian Military) coined as "No plan survives contact with the enemy" (paraphrased). The battle between top-down and bottom-up management styles is still pretty alive in most companies, I guess.