3 ms·
> I think the best thing about FreeBSD is the incredibly high quality of its users; I suspect survivor bias in action here. At least I would consider a possibi
by smsm42 10y ago
> I think the best thing about FreeBSD is the incredibly high quality of its users;
I suspect survivor bias in action here. At least I would consider a possibility that these users are so well-educated about their system because they have no choice. And that's not always what one wants. I don't really want to be extremely well-educated about the details of my car. I just want to operate a couple of buttons, levers and other gadgets and get quickly and safely from point A to point B. I couldn't care less how the car does it, for all I care it could have magical pixies inside.
Now, I'm not saying BSD users doing it wrong. On the contrary, if it works for them that's great, and becoming the master of your tools is both personally rewarding and enriching. But - if you're preaching to outside audience, one has to mention that "BSD users are very knowledgeable about the details of their system" might also mean "you can't use this system unless you become an expert in it, if you're just interested in being a casual consumer you're in trouble".
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI suspect self-selection: Right now, Linux is the most popular Unix. If you're going to another system, there's probably a reason, either technical or ideological. But to know enough to know why you might want to move already requires a lot of technical knowlege. And the will to actually do it, stick it out, and learn the different ways the system works requires a certain willingness to learn (although the excellent docs DO help). It's not so much that you can't use the system if you're a casual consumer, it's that if you're a casual consumer, you won't bother. Also, it's not a bias: We're trying to root-cause why the freeBSD community is so knowledgable. if it's because only the most knowlegable are capable of using it, that isn't a bias, it's just a result. /nitpick
- smsm42 10y agoIt's bias in a meaning that the cause is not BSD making their users somehow knowledgeable, but only users having enough motivation and knowledge to become power-users continue to use BSD. So if you approach it as a new user evaluating whether to use BSD, saying "BSD users are very knowledgeable" may mislead you as to the reason why.
- toomanythings4 10y agoLinux is not Unix. Never has been and moving further away from it. (Ignoring the very recent version in January which got certified somehow)
- toomanythings4 10y agoFreeBSD is a professional operating system for professionals. It bothers me none if a 15-year old redditor can't handle getting his games to work on it.
- astrange 10y agoIt's difficult to use FreeBSD without becoming a 90s-style expert sysadmin, and the handbook doesn't really help even if it's possible to do better. Setting up a server should be as secure and fast as possible with no work, you should get backups, and you shouldn't need a C compiler installed, let alone /usr/src. But the docs still act like you need to be checking out the whole OS and recompiling it for every machine, and then recompile again for jails. And once you get traffic to your web server there's a few pages of sysctl numbers to increase because it won't autotune anything. On the power user topics, is there a way to get a changelog of port/pkg updates or OS beta releases? It's hard to know when you should bother testing something.
- tete 10y agoI actually would be scared of anyone being a sysadmin (or devop for that matter) and not know their system very well. Also I actually think it's a community thing. What is way stronger in the BSD community is people not being missionaries and wanting to aggregate users as much as you see it in the Linux or MacOS world (not saying that's bad!!!). If you join the BSD community and are like "Why would I use BSD" people will often will be like "Why bother, unless you wanna learn something new? If you don't have a reason for using it, we won't convince you". This is pretty unique to the BSD community. That also means that you are expected to not as dumb questions. I was active in both BSD and Linux communities, and even in the more "know your stuff" communities (Arch and Linux for example) asking dumb questions wasn't frowned upon. Yeah, you may call this elitism. Maybe it is. I don't think so, because there is no "I am too good for answering this" and in general less politics, but then it of course you can't completely deny it, if you are supposed to adhere to the typical "How to ask good questions" guide. And really, it's not that one is better. It certainly isn't. It's a different approach. It more likes me think of how I once watched the Standford Programming Introduction Class and the guy talked about how there is different courses and some are more about being nice and holding your hand at all time and the the other is more pushing. It's a culture thing and just like companies are successful with different cultures you can't say one is better for everyone. Also it depends on what you count your success on. And that can be so many things, having something stable, having great bleeding edge, having a large community, a smart community, having a few big success stories or having everyone use it. One can maybe compare it to a business plan or describing target audiences. Nobody will say that the target audience is wrong. (even though that's more the case when your goal is to make money)