2 ms·
> "People have been murdered over cartoons. End of moral analysis" I don't understand the significance of this. People have been killed for all sorts of silly
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
> "People have been murdered over cartoons. End of moral analysis"
I don't understand the significance of this. People have been killed for all sorts of silly reasons, religious differences provide lots of examples but there's plenty more outside that, wearing the wrong color or the wrong team's shirt in the wrong part of town, dating someone from a different social group, trying to vote, I could go on for a while.
So what's his point?
- chroma 10y agoHarris's point is that moral accountability lies solely with the murderers, not the cartoonists. The same goes for your examples. You don't blame the person trying to vote. Yes, there are practical expectations (this is why I use a pseudonym when criticizing certain ideas), but saying, "What did you expect?" is an indictment of the group doing the harm, not the provocateur.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoSo his point is that murder is bad? That seems a bit self-evident to me. Am I missing something? Why is he focussing on the cartoons?
- michaelbuddy 10y agoMaybe it's the fact that the quote is contextual, and you're not privy to the discussion around it. Basically there are people that say "Well they shouldn't have provoked it by drawing Muhammad, the cartoonists had it coming" Yes I've actually seen people write that too. Sam Harris is saying, that actually the cartoonists are blameless and there is no moral justification any one, muslim or not can use to blame the cartoonists for their own deaths.