5 ms·
The return of the Luddite president
- kristopolous 10y agoOk, yes. Politicians live under a rock on a different planet. We all know this. :-( It's definitely not an age thing though ... I see plenty of people in their golden years on smartphones and have quite a few facebook friends north of 80 who post frequently and clearly understand the basic tenants of the things.
- ageek123 10y agoI don't care whether the President uses email or knows how to tweet. I care about whether their policies are pro-tech or anti-tech, and right now the two parties are in a race to the bottom to be as anti-tech as possible.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mbesto 10y agoI think the point is that it would be a fairly logical to conclude that if he "doesn't believe in email", he's going to have a very hard time understanding the implications of net neutrality, IP rights, and more.
- jackpirate 10y agoWhen cs giants like Donald Knuth also "don't believe in email" I find this line of reasoning specious.
- emdd 10y agoThat's a fair argument. However, the reason behind Knuth's conclusions are inevitably different than Trump's. So, I think it shouldn't be compared.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- davmre 10y agoIt's not clear that Knuth would be a particularly knowledgeable leader on these issues either, whatever his other strengths.
- mikeash 10y agoI think it would be reasonable to conclude that "don't believe in email because I can't be bothered to do computer stuff" is different from "don't believe in email because I understand all relevant technology from top to bottom and have made an informed choice."
- perhonen 10y agoHis position (which is explained on his webpage: http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~uno/email.html http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~uno/email.html) is a little more nuanced. Relevant section: > Email is a wonderful thing for people whose role in life is to be on top of things. But not for me; my role is to be on the bottom of things. What I do takes long hours of studying and uninterruptible concentration. I think he would agree that a President's role is to be 'on top of things'.
- 1anh2kqowg 10y agoThis doesn't seem remotely true, if you compare the regulations tech has been subject to with those applied to other industries (or tech in Europe). Can you give some examples of anti-tech activities you are referring to, in case I am missing something?
- jstalin 10y agoIf I were a candidate for president, I wouldn't use email either. It's a political and security risk.
- remarkEon 10y agoIt appears the argument being made here in the article is not that Clinton and Trump are tech averse because of political and security risks, but that they are themselves technologically inept.
- sheraz 10y agoThe article title seems a bit unfair, especially given how well trump has played in social media and the ever changing "news feed." Just because people are printing news articles does not make them a Luddite. I imagine many broadcasters still work this way. Lastly, it is not trumps or hillarys personal responsibility to understand email, networks, or even the governance of it all. It is their duty to fill their cabinet with the right people who can translate translate all the complexity into actionable choices and provide guidance. Same with CEOs
- jonknee 10y ago> The article title seems a bit unfair, especially given how well trump has played in social media and the ever changing "news feed." It accurately describes someone who has never had a computer on their desk and interacts mostly through paper (he's well known for hand written notes). He sometimes tweets by himself, but that's about it and I am sure his advisors wished he didn't ever tweet on his own. TV seems to be where he focuses, both watching it and trying to be on it.
- danso 10y agoTo be fair, the problem goes beyond just wanting to print a web article: > Clinton, now 68, also emailed a department staffer to ask what time the CBS drama “The Good Wife” aired and later to request a paper copy of a website news item. “Pls print for me and deliver to me,” Clinton wrote in the winter of 2013, attaching a web address. “This links to the front page of the Washington Post,” the employee responded. “Is there a particular article that you are looking for?” Assuming Secretary Clinton wasn't trying to solely keep her email private, the kind of unfamilarity she has with the very fundamentals of information technology is the kind of unfamiliarity that leads to flawed usage of technology, such as her now-controversial email server. When you need so many middlemen to get you information that you could far more asily access and explore yourself, you increase the chance of incompetency and inefficency hindering the information flow.
- sheraz 10y agoDisagree here. This is what the right hand man/woman is for. My guess is that there is a real cultural problem not only in the Democratic Party but also with hillarys organization(s). Dissent and speaking truth to power is squelched which creates hubris and bad decisions. Certainly there were people who told Hillary it was a bad idea to put an email server in a basement. Were they heard? Did they even speak up?
- mtviewdave 10y agoThe tech-aloofness of the two nominees marks a sharp break from President Barack Obama, who fought to keep a mobile phone when he entered the White House... It was Clinton's desire to do the same thing that led to her setting up her own email server and the resulting scandal. Clinton also balked at agency guidance that she use a government-issued personal computer in her Foggy Bottom office Obama wanted to use a mobile device instead of a desktop computer for email, and that proves that's he's tech-savvy, but Clinton desire for the same thing means she's a luddite?
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoI interpret this more as - government IT is in terrible shape, and I can't blame somebody who does not wish to be saddled with the pain of it. The argument that an ostensibly political appointee must be held to the same IT-savviness standards as , say, an enlisted (wo)man are specious. While it would be a good thing if it were true, we all know too many people in positions of power who have simply not had the time to be competent in it. It's a variation on the generally advancing Russian Doll thinking that is sweeping tech.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"The argument that an ostensibly political appointee must be held to the same IT-savviness standards as , say, an enlisted (wo)man are specious." Wait: you are seriously arguing that the Secretary of State of the United States is in a less-sensitive position than an enlisted member of the armed forces? Seriously?
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoI am saying that detailed crypto and IT knowledge is not a prerequisite for being appointed to a cabinet position. Ever do any work for lawyers? It's like that. They have admins that run the firms; the lawyers are the inventory.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago
- blatherard 10y agoThe title of this article has little to do with the content. Luddism isn't ignorance of technology, it is fear of and hostility toward it. This is just an article about how Clinton and Trump don't use technology as much or in the same way as your average post-Boomer office worker, but says nothing about hostility toward it.