4 ms·
Social security numbers are in the uncanny valley between something private enough to be plausibly used as a shared secret and public enough to be exploited wid
by stickfigure 10y ago
Social security numbers are in the uncanny valley between something private enough to be plausibly used as a shared secret and public enough to be exploited widely. There is really only one effective solution to this: Make all SSNs public and therefore useless as a secret key. All the services that are currently (ab)using this number will find alternatives.
- tedunangst 10y agoSSN is only one example. All your medical records, your entire genome can be represented as a number. Does that suddenly make it acceptable to publish?
- lisper 10y agoAny information can be rendered as a number. The whole idea that there's something special about numbers that makes them different from other kinds of information (i.e. it's OK to publish this "because it's just a number") missed the point rather badly.
- gioele 10y ago> Make all SSNs public and therefore useless as a secret key. An exhaustive list of all US SSNs will be mishandled, intercepted and posted online. It is only a matter of when, rather than if. (For precedents of whole-country database dumps, see the Turkish, Philippines and Qatar cases.)
- umanwizard 10y agoHow do you make the leap from "something has happened in three countries" to "it will inevitably happen everywhere" ?
- Qantourisc 10y ago(chance greater then 0) * (a lot of time)
- jacobush 10y agoRight. Reminds me of how to destroy the earth. Just wait until its atoms decay.
- umanwizard 10y agoThis is wrong for a lot of reasons. The most obvious one is that it assumes the United States social security number system (and the United States itself) will exist for infinite time.
- RexM 10y agoIsn't the point that it is public? > Make all SSNs public
- gioele 10y agoMy (excessively hermetic) message was meant to mean: "All the SSNs will one day be public. Even if the legislator does not make them public, they will leak one day anyway."