8 ms·
The end of sprawl
- Houshalter 10y agoI think sprawl will increase when self driving cars become a thing. Long commutes will be a lot more tolerable, parking a non issue, and the cost of owning a car could be reduced with self driving taxis or busses.
- angersock 10y agoLong commutes always suck, and having something else drive for you won't make that change. Parking as a non-issue is an argument for denser and tighter organization of cities instead of sprawl. Self-driving taxis and buses are another reason to prefer living in the city, least of all because they are cheaper in a denser area.
- nine_k 10y agoA long commute in a self-driving car, even more than in a comfortable train, can be a part of your work day, or even your leisure. Commute while driving is manual labor, preventing any meaningful concentration, be it watching a movie or writing code.
- sotojuan 10y agoI wonder how long it'll take for people to be comfortable enough with self driving cars that they stop paying attention to the road.
- icebraining 10y agoNo time at all: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXls4cdEv7c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXls4cdEv7c
- nine_k 10y agoI think that the whole point of a self-driving car is that the passenger can pay no attention to the road. Else it's not self-driving.
- angersock 10y agoIt is a sad state of affairs when labor is convinced that spending more of their time in a little box (regardless of pilot) in order to show up to work is somehow any sort of leisure at all. Why is all this tech being used to solve the goal of self-driving cars, and yet remote work is still somehow in the realm of fantasy to most people?
- Noos 10y agobecause only a tiny amount of the workforce does the kind of hands-off knowledge work than can be done remotely, and without the need for significant employee control.
- nine_k 10y agoWorking remotely can be great; I worked this way for several years. But not all jobs are like programmer's. Think of e.g. medical personnel, overworked as they usually are, being able to sleep for an extra hour while being taken to / from a hospital. Think of a teacher who could spend an hour of commute preparing to the lessons instead of holding the steering wheel. Think of a plumber who can settle some business affairs while on the road, and spend an extra hour with his kids instead.
- gcr 10y agoIt's far easier to get work done or to read some nice books when you're not also swerving to avoid oncoming traffic. Caltrain and Amtrak provide A+ reading experience. Even MTA or PATH are bearable. I rate them a B- if your book is one-handed.
- hiphipjorge 10y agoI don't think the move from the suburbs to the city is a technology issue. There are certainly trade-offs to both of them. The reason a lot of people (especially young people) have been flocking to walkable cities has a lot more to do with self-identity and lifestyle choices than with just merely commuting time. No self-driving card will change that. Keep in mind that the opposite is also true. Self-driving cars make city-living (where owning a car is unaffordable and unpractical) much easier, since it increases the access to cars.
- LA_Banker 10y ago>The reason a lot of people (especially young people) have been flocking to walkable cities has a lot more to do with self-identity and lifestyle choices than with just merely commuting time. These are drivers to be sure, but the biggest is the network effects of being in a denser metro. The more people there are in a given area, the more human resources: job options, entertainment options, dating options, knowledge-sharing (the form that can only be done via meeting people in person), collaboration, and other forms are human and knowledge-derived capital. It's easier to form a rock band or hire for a startup idea in NYC than it is Duluth, Minnesota where there are fewer musicians and programmers. This is why rural areas, unless undergoing some sort of unique boom (e.g. the Bakken Formation or Athabascan Oil Sands) or hosting a college/university, sustain much older average populations. Unless one's career allows them to live/work remotely, it's often necessary to move to the city to pursue most career options. Aside from the self-identity and lifestyle points you mention.
- nimos 10y ago>The reason a lot of people (especially young people) have been flocking to walkable cities has a lot more to do with self-identity and lifestyle choices than with just merely commuting time. No self-driving card will change that. For me personally having a self driving car would make suburban living much more attractive. For a lot of people having a yard/garage/space to tinker is a really big selling point. There is a big difference between having to spend an hour driving yourself and having an hour of freeish time to read/watch netflix/do work. I think the other big factor is being able to go out for drinks. Living in the suburbs today means either insane cab bills, having to organize a dd or driving drunk.
- iiiggglll 10y agoLong commutes? Once vehicles are self-driving, there will be whole swaths of the population who will simply live in their cars and not have another home. Imagine reddit's "vandwellers" times ten. Then there will be political fights over city congestion taxes and other ways of extracting money from people who do that. Interesting times...
- andy_boot 10y agoI don't think it will happen that way. It's as easy to live in a regular van as a self driving van. Sure some people do it but not many. I imagine that far less people will own cars and instead there will be a fleet of self driving taxis. But I'm not sure, interesting times - like you said.
- sotojuan 10y agoUnless the self driving cars can make an hour commute be half an hour or less, they'll still suck. All you gain is the ability to read, eat, play games, or even sleep during the commute and no one will be comfortable doing that for a few years.
- ocb 10y agoAdditionally, plenty of people already commute long distances in relative comfort without having to drive themselves--it still sucks.
- Houshalter 10y agoI've gotten more than one response saying that, but I don't understand it. I would find it very enjoyable to read, play games, or sleep during a commute. There's not that much I can't do in a car, that I can do on my couch. Much more enjoyable than spending hours focusing on the road. If you move further out of the city, you have much cheaper rent and taxes. Saving that much money would make it totally worth it to spend a few hours in a car everyday.
- alkonaut 10y agoRelaxing during a commute seems only marginally better than driving. What makes a difference is if you can work during the commute, so an entire 8h workday will be 2h commute and 6h work. In large metropolitan areas most people will end up spending what they can afford on housing, the choice is just between a 1h commute and large back yard and forest/beach within walking distance, versus the city with short commutes and shops/services within walking distance. You could live in a small flat in suburbia and save a ton, but it doesn't appear to be a popular choice.
- Johnny555 10y agoIf your company is ok with you working for an hour or two on the way in to the office, then why not just work at home for an extra 90 minutes until after peak commute hours and zip into the office when traffic is light? Or better, just stay home entirely. Many companies still don't embrace full-time telecommuting (including tech companies like Apple and Google that have unlimited technology resources to make it work), so it's going to take a big paradigm shift for those companies to accept that workers driving in are actually "working" before they get to the office. My company doesn't offer shuttle buses, but of the people I do know that ride tech shuttles, while they do tend to work on the shuttle, it's usually just catching up on emails before they get to the office to do the "real work", and 2 hours on the bus is not equivalent to 2 hours in the office.
- CM30 10y agoI think it's more likely to increase when remote work (and maybe virtual reality) increases in popularity. When managers finally realise that you don't need everyone in the same office for a 9-5 shift (and the few advantages of such are replaced by something like VR), then I suspect urban sprawl will continue. Why care about commuting times if commuting isn't as necessary in the first place? Self driving cars may make travelling easier, but even then you've got to get somewhere. Even then the inside of a car is a less useful working environment than an office, so short commutes would be preferred.
- Johnny555 10y agoI think you overestimate the ability of self driving cars to make a long commute tolerable, since driving in a car for an hour (or more) each way is no fun even if someone else is driving. Getting quality work done is tough if you're at all prone to motion sickness while working on a computer in a moving vehicle, and it's hard to get in quality sleep even in a fully reclining seat. My wife and I commuted together (45 - 60 minutes) for almost a year and while I could get some work done while she drove, it was not nearly the same as when I'm working from home. Likewise, sleep was not an option, the timing wasn't right (it's hard to wake up, get ready for work, then catch a short on the way to work). While parking may be less of an issue if your car can go park itself, traffic will become a much bigger issue because all of those cars driving around looking for parking (or another passenger) after dropping off their passengers are going to double downtown congestion (i.e. instead of you driving to your parking garage and leaving your car there, your car is going to stay on the roads until it finds a place to park, perhaps outside of the city)
- mattnewton 10y agoI have it pretty close to a self driving car now, with a company bus that picks me up. It has wifi and bathrooms, so I really don't mind the 1hr commute into the valley every day. It's a good time to get some email done or quietly reflect. I think that I gladly pay this price to shave 1k a month off living expenses, and probably would for even as low as a few hundred, since it's not really a big cost. The real downside is in being further away from things that are not work, if you are commuting in for pleasure on the weekends. But based on my experience, I agree with the grandparent and think once more people have drivers, sprawl will increase.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoNot true, when I uber into work (my commute is over 1 hr), it's like a dream come true. I can work, I can relax, I can get my life-admin tasks done with, etc. Right now it's completely wasted. When you commute with other people, it's also annoying because you need to socialize when most times I would rather do the above. If I could get a self-driving car that worked competently, it would certainly make my commute so much more tolerable.
- mc32 10y agoSprawl will continue as countries become urbanized. Africa, South Asia, etc. Sprawl will ebb once pop stabilizes in those countries. As the US pop has stabilized (except addition by immigrants) we don't expect more sprawl.
- mjevans 10y agoI support ending sprawl, but there are factors that drive people to it. (Perceived or real) * Quality of education for their children. * Privacy (space/sound insulation) * Nature (if you move far enough out, then wonder why wildlife 'invades') * Investment (housing shouldn't be, but it is; also rent is too high)
- alkonaut 10y agoThe "let's move where schools are good" is just a self sustaining effect of some sprawling cities. In most countries "inner city kids" or "inner city schools" means the best schools with the richest kids. If the inner city is attractive then schools will be too. Not sure if you referred to nature as a net positive or negative? I have a forest an beach nearby (with the commute to suit my very reasonable price point). I think most wildlife is a positive.
- vostok 10y agoI mean, that's true in the US too if you look at schools like Stuyvesant or Trinity.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoSprawl is a reaction to land rents ( ala Ricardo ). It's really only bad in that it facilitates and encourages commuting. It could be at least partially addressed through the tax system - carbon taxes and land rents taxes combined would probably be enough.
- eru 10y agoLand rent taxes by themselves won't lower land rents that tenants have to pay. (They are exactly neutral, can't be passed on one way or another.) But they do allow to lower other taxes, and shift incentives away from NIMBYism that is currently blocking denser developments.
- golergka 10y ago> * Quality of education for their children. It's an american thing, without any objective reason. As a teenager, I had to commute for an hour (one way) from a distant neighbourhood to a good high school in the city center.
- greggman 10y agoI'm curious how certain things fit into city living. Examples: Rockband the Game. You can't play that game in an apartment in the city without being a total dick to your neighbors. You can play it in a house in suburbia. Arguably the same is true for the home version of Dance Dance Revolution Another is room scale VR which pretty seems to demand owning a large enough place to have your VR room. Maybe some people can move stuff to the side one in a while but if you have to spend a bunch of time prepping the room every time I can imagine room scale VR to ever get that popular. Yes I know the world doesn't revolve around video games but they seem like an example of activities that are designed around sprawl. There's plenty of others, many non-game activities as well that, for lack of a better way to describe it, would compel me to still prefer a suburbian house over a city apartment. I guess what I'm wondering is how much cultural inertia there is for one or the other
- atom-morgan 10y agoTo provide a better example, I used to play drums. As much as I'd like to continue practicing, I can't in an apartment complex even if I were to buy an electric kit. The tapping on the pedal would be too much for the people who live below me. This problem, combined with the insane amount of people moving to Atlanta, has me thinking about moving.
- Symbiote 10y agoI suspect it's not common in the US, but my apartment is directly above a shop. I can stamp on the floor as much as I like in the evenings and on Sundays, since the shop is empty. You could try raising the drum kit off the floor: http://www.alesisdrummer.com/index.php?topic=4068.0 http://www.alesisdrummer.com/index.php?topic=4068.0
- atom-morgan 10y agoI didn't even know this was an option. Thank you for sharing.
- Johnny555 10y ago
- intrasight 10y agoI don't think that technology will have any significant impact on sprawl. But demographic trends certainly will.
- p4wnc6 10y agoThe main thing I am looking for is privacy. I find that if I have access to private property big enough to take a short walk in nature, maybe a 10-20 minute walk, then my physical and cognitive health improves by huge amounts. When I lived in urban Boston, and I would go for long runs on the street and through parks, or I would use a rental car to go out to the Middlesex Fells for geocaching, it was like a poor bastardization of what I needed. There were always people around. I could not get into a meditative mood and access any of the cognitively rejuvenating effects that the activities were for. It saddens me very much that human culture is moving to agglomerative cities, because I believe I am personally extremely maladapted to be able to handle that, so I constantly feel like I'm being squeezed and stressed, even just by my ambient environment, even on a pleasant sunny day when I just take a walk to relax. It's a very maddening way to live, but I have not found any solution that would let me live with a better compromise that allows me to have private access to nature on my own property and still successfully interface with the industries I work in.
- eru 10y agoWouldn't it be great for you if everyone else moved to dense cities, so there'd be more nature left for you?
- p4wnc6 10y agoAh, but then you can't have a job that lets you live near nature. Even most remote jobs (which have lots of other downsides, like stalling out career progress) require decent proximity to a major city or airport, and high-speed internet.
- eru 10y agoThe denser the city, the closer we could have real nature close to the economic centre of the city. Think of taking all the Bay Area, putting all the economic activity and people who want city living into a small area with 40 story towers, and the rest will be much more pleasant---with relatively easy commuting into the small core for the voluntary country bumpkins.
- matt_morgan 10y agoWhere does the idea that you should spend 30% of your money on rent come from? I see it everywhere. Not that I'm questioning it in general, but does it ever change?
- tomkinstinch 10y agoThe notion one "should" spend some fraction must come the real estate industry. The rule should be "spend as little as you can on housing to achieve the quality you want (or can tolerate), but never exceed 30% (or other arbitrary percentage) of net income, lest you risk being unable to save for large future expenses and emergencies."
- cableshaft 10y agoI see 25% a little more often than I see 30%, but it's not that much different of a percentage.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoTen to fifteen percent is vastly better. It's doable but it's not that easy. You need a middling-good job in flyover country. That's the part that's not that easy - it's harder to justify a gig in flyover country by sheer ability. Companies on the downward slide towards Schumpeterian irrelevance just don't care and so don't bother them with the facts... IMO, this was what my ( Silent Generation ) parents used as a heuristic. But people saw rising home prices and began the "stretch", and then "stretching" became the standard. Because of this, I've become somewhat of the Geotaxer fan - if the rent is too damn high, then tax land rents, not income per se. Geotaxes have the aspect that they cannot be passed on to the renter by the rentier.
- auxym 10y agoFWIW, my (half of) rent (split with SO) in Montreal is less than 15% of my net income. And I'm not even in software. People see the low engineer salaries around here and are generally reluctant to come, but I find the quality of life to be high and rent to be low. Of course, there are other aspects to cost-of-living than rent, and quality of life is somewhat subjective. EDIT: For anyone curious, here is a nifty heat map of rents in the city: http://ici.radio-canada.ca/special/cartes/15-06_annonces-logements-kijiji.html http://ici.radio-canada.ca/special/cartes/15-06_annonces-log...
- gumby 10y ago"Walkable" is on the increase because of demographics: there's a slight bulge in under 30s who are more likely to like urban living; once they start having kids the suburbs start to look more enticing. Self-driving vehicles are likely to increase sprawl by reducing the travel burden :-(