4 ms·
> Carriers are vulnerable and probably cannot be protected enough to survive an all out war Carriers don't travel by themselves, and are heavily defended by an
by Alupis 10y ago
> Carriers are vulnerable and probably cannot be protected enough to survive an all out war
Carriers don't travel by themselves, and are heavily defended by anti-missile/plane/sub/etc installations and supporting vessels.
They may not last an entire war, but they will probably last as long as needed to tip the scale. It's more likely the carrier's aircraft will be lost before the carrier.
- arohner 10y ago"In a 1982 congressional hearing, legislators asked [US Admiral Hyman Rickover] how long American carriers would survive in an actual war." his response? “Forty-eight hours”. https://warisboring.com/the-u-s-navy-s-big-mistake-building-tons-of-supercarriers-79cb42029b8#.ir5t0zedu https://warisboring.com/the-u-s-navy-s-big-mistake-building-...
- labrador 10y agoAdm Rickover was known mostly for two things besides putting an atomic reactor in a submarine in the 1950's: Being consistently right and being blunt about it.
- DrJokepu 10y agoI mean, Rickover was a through and through submarine guy though. This statement might be true, but he was hardly objective and without agenda when it came to surface naval warfare.
- Alupis 10y agoI'd wager the first 48 hours of a modern all-out war with another major nation will be the deciding factor, or heavily tip the scales. A modern war with another major nation likely won't last months or years like traditional wars. There's too much destructive firepower available to major nations for that to be realistic. It's more likely that it will be destructive, brutal, and very swift. Not to mention Rickover said that nearly 40 years ago - our modern carrier groups have a lot more firepower and technology at their disposal - including new generation stealthy ships.
- Benjammer 10y agoStill seems like such a huge attack surface compared to a dude sitting at a terminal in an NSA office or a drone pilot in Nevada or a cruise missile platform tucked away in a mountain somewhere. Aren't we past the point where giant war machines have much effectiveness when it comes to actual global war between 1st world nation-states?
- Alupis 10y agoCarrier groups aren't just about giant war machines. They carry many troops and their transportation (smaller war machines, like helicopters and boats).