4 ms·
I think we should have both private and government financed pharma research. The approval process should be the same for both. If private pharma discovers a dru
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
I think we should have both private and government financed pharma research. The approval process should be the same for both. If private pharma discovers a drug that is approved - then they should be able to sell it in such a way as to maximize their profits. If government pharma discovers a drug that is approved - then they should be able to provide it at cost.
This way we don't have to worry about new drug discovery drying up because of lack of profits, while at the same time we have a way to allow government funding for actual drugs that could be provided at low cost.
I think this private-public competition will provide both innovation and low prices in the long term.
- belorn 10y agoWe already have private and government financed pharma research. US alone spends around $26.4 billion each year, which do not include university founded research (that goes under education) and the other smaller incentive systems for pharma research by organizations such as FDA (which is a third recipient of government founds). Regardless, no drugs is provided at cost. Government founded research is also the primary ground work for which private pharma use, and private pharma would unlikely survive today without that core research being done for free. But maybe government could be more return-on-investment friendly for the citizens who pay taxes and re-route some of that research founds into actually developing the end user drugs. At the same time they could create legal barriers for private pharma from using any tax funded pharma research. That would create some loud screams from the pharma lobby, and we would finally be able to say how valuable the patent supported pharma industry really is. I doubt however we will ever see such day, and patent supported pharma will continue to claim the glory while tax payers silently pays double for medicine. First through taxes and then a second time through the expensive drug prices in the pharmacy.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoMy thought was for government financed end user drug development. Think something like Pharma now but financed by taxes. This entity would compete on a level playing field with big Pharma. The basic science research would stay the same. Then both government end user drug research and private Pharma would compete on turning basic science into actual approved drugs.
- drivingmenuts 10y ago> private pharma would unlikely survive today without that core research being done for free I tend to view private pharma, as it exists today, as a leech on society, at best. Perhaps destroying it and making it pay it's own way entirely would be for the best. Yes, in the past, private companies did real work and it was beneficial. But, mostly, they seem to invent cures for problems that get blown way out of proportion thru marketing directly to the public (restless leg syndrome? really?). At a minimum, let doctors become the filter thru which medicine is prescribed, and put a very heavy penalty in place for pay-to-subscribe.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoDoes private pharma get to build on public research and then patent small changes? That's hardly fair.
- curried_haskell 10y agoThis is where I always run into problems with the conservative line of thinking. Private pharma depends on public research, the same way most commerce depends on some kind of public infrastructure or groundwork. We help lay the groundwork for their private profits, we are entitled to our share and our say. Nothing happens in a magical free-market vacuum.