2 ms·
Yes, this is what civil engineers do, but it's a highly suboptimal alternative to real data, which is impossible to collect due to cost and the laws of physics.
by potatolicious 17y ago
Yes, this is what civil engineers do, but it's a highly suboptimal alternative to real data, which is impossible to collect due to cost and the laws of physics.
If for $200 civil engineers could test a new bridge design against real, live traffic, with no risk of injury or loss of life... you bet your ass they'd be doing it. But that's not going to happen, because we can't will multiple bridges into existence for almost no money, nor can they occupy the same space :)
This is also why transit planning is often such a clusterfuck - the mathematical models behind urban growth, commute patterns, etc, are often poor predictors of what will actually happen. We've got road layout down to a pretty precise science, but that's about the limit of it. The impact of said roads and thoroughfares on the communities surrounding it, for example, are still poorly understood.
Roundabout way of saying it: I just don't think civil engineering and software engineering will ever truly be comparable. The amount of consequence-free testing, combined with the ability to iterate for extremely cheaply, will never be matched by a field that must build expensive physical objects.