10 ms·

Pokemon Go dev argues sponsored locations are more game-friendly than IAP

26 points by Red_Tarsius 10y ago

cableshaft 10y ago
Depends on how it's done, but maybe. If it's an added Pokestop with the companies name and picture, and maybe on certain days they can promote (outside of the game) that certain in-game items will be guaranteed to be given at their Pokestop, or certain Pokemon might show up that day (based on an agreement with Niantic), then I don't see any issues with that. Like for example I remember when Gamestop offered download codes when people visited their shops to get a specific Pokemon in Pokemon X and Y, for example. That seems fine to me. But if it gets to the point (as it often does), that company Pokestops are advertised from other Pokestops, or the screen gets completely taken over (think a website where the entire border of the site is an ad for one company) and there's autoplaying videos and they tell you to go to their place for REAL WORLD items (like Burger King says "Try our new Bacon Double Taco Whopper!"), then that will suck and I'll stop playing the game. I'm already sick of dealing with it on websites, I don't want to deal with that while playing games too.
- kbuck 10y ago
  In Ingress, they had similar partnerships with a few companies. Notably, the sponsored "portals" (the Ingress version of Poke Stops) were only additional locations to get items. They didn't award special items or do anything else differently (ZipCar and Jamba Juice had this agreement with Ingress). Ingress also had in-game items named after companies, but these items could drop from anywhere and were likely to be added to the game anyway. A couple examples of these are the SoftBank Ultra Link and the "MUFG" (Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group) capsule. I think the only time they had a commercial partnership that gave someone in particular an edge was when they introduced Ultra Strike items, which could initially only be obtained on some Motorola-branded Android devices. These can now be obtained on any device, though. Given that it's the same team working on Pokemon Go, I think it's unlikely that they'll make things annoyingly intrusive or force you to go to specific Pokestops to get certain items.

26 points by Red_Tarsius 10y ago

Depends on how it's done, but maybe. If it's an added Pokestop with the companies name and picture, and maybe on certain days they can promote (outside of the game) that certain in-game items will be guaranteed to be given at their Pokestop, or certain Pokemon might show up that day (based on an agreement with Niantic), then I don't see any issues with that. Like for example I remember when Gamestop offered download codes when people visited their shops to get a specific Pokemon in Pokemon X and Y, for example. That seems fine to me. But if it gets to the point (as it often does), that company Pokestops are advertised from other Pokestops, or the screen gets completely taken over (think a website where the entire border of the site is an ad for one company) and there's autoplaying videos and they tell you to go to their place for REAL WORLD items (like Burger King says "Try our new Bacon Double Taco Whopper!"), then that will suck and I'll stop playing the game. I'm already sick of dealing with it on websites, I don't want to deal with that while playing games too.

kbuck 10y ago
In Ingress, they had similar partnerships with a few companies. Notably, the sponsored "portals" (the Ingress version of Poke Stops) were only additional locations to get items. They didn't award special items or do anything else differently (ZipCar and Jamba Juice had this agreement with Ingress). Ingress also had in-game items named after companies, but these items could drop from anywhere and were likely to be added to the game anyway. A couple examples of these are the SoftBank Ultra Link and the "MUFG" (Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group) capsule. I think the only time they had a commercial partnership that gave someone in particular an edge was when they introduced Ultra Strike items, which could initially only be obtained on some Motorola-branded Android devices. These can now be obtained on any device, though. Given that it's the same team working on Pokemon Go, I think it's unlikely that they'll make things annoyingly intrusive or force you to go to specific Pokestops to get certain items.