5 ms·
DON'T USE GPS ALONE FOR SELF DRIVING CARS. Not even DGPS. Really. Don't. A ton of metal moving under its own volition really needs to be looking at the things
by taneq 10y ago
DON'T USE GPS ALONE FOR SELF DRIVING CARS.
Not even DGPS. Really. Don't. A ton of metal moving under its own volition really needs to be looking at the things around it, directly, using some kind of vison. Cameras are good.
- pmiller2 10y agoI don't think any sensible self driving car system would use GPS alone. Collision avoidance is pretty important, and GPS only stops you from crashing into buildings and mountains. :P
- posterboy 10y agoNot to mention reports of tracking in the mountains, where position was off several hundred meters, because of signal echoes.
- MiguelHudnandez 10y agoIt would be criminally negligent to use GPS for any control decisions in a self-driving vehicle. Aside from wishy-washy long term tasks like what route to take, or which street has traffic, GPS simply cannot be used. GPS can fail, be jammed, or lose accuracy. I can't imagine there is any risk of any production vehicles using GPS alone. Certainly GPS matching physical reality will be helpful, but no car is going to drive on a sidewalk and plow through fire hydrants because GPS was off by 1.5 meters. Before a car can enter a physical space, it should verify with at least two local, independent, physical sensors that the intended space is unoccupied and that no detectable objects are on a trajectory to occupy that space. Our brains do these calculations very easily and with minimal conscious thought. However, our brains' attentiveness and accuracy leave much to be desired.
- notahacker 10y agoI think the potential issue with GPS being a couple of metres out issue is less cars driving through fire hydrants and more the car driving down what GPS thinks is the correct route and looks like a nice open stretch of road to the computer vision, but is in fact the wrong lane...
- maxerickson 10y agoI hope nothing on the road is that naive with lane finding. I can't imagine it would be.
- bbradley406 10y agoA common problem I've had with standalone GPS units is that they get confused when two roads are very close to one another. Highway overpasses, on-ramps and off-ramps, routes right next to highways, etc. You wouldn't want your self driving car to think it's on a freeway and should do 65 when you're really on the dirt farm road right next to it.
- mikeash 10y agoFortunately, using GPS alone will work so poorly that you'll never get anywhere with such a project, so it'll never get to the stage where it can cause some huge disaster.