5 ms·
Yeah, just watching the news, it's becoming more and more apparent that people are so far removed from the horrors of WWI and WWII that they don't understand wh
by empath75 10y ago
Yeah, just watching the news, it's becoming more and more apparent that people are so far removed from the horrors of WWI and WWII that they don't understand why we created the international institutions we did.
The UN, WTO, EU, etc, are ineffective, bureaucratic messes, but no matter how bad they are, they're a better way of solving international disputes than the historical alternatives.
Western nationalists like to talk about how the cultures of the middle east are inherently violent, but seem to forget that the history of europe was a centuries-long bloodbath that eventually engulfed the entire world in horror and put us nearly on the brink of the extinction of all human life.
It's those alliances and international organizations that allowed us to step backwards from it. Solving our problems in courtrooms and at negotiating tables rather than on the battlefield.
- valkea 10y agoThe UN and WTO are not political unions though.
- bluejekyll 10y agoThe WTO wields a lot of power as a trade broker, though.
- mikeash 10y agoNow that you mention it, some of the rhetoric about the Middle East really is weird. The last time Europeans tried to go out and kill everybody with the wrong religion is still in living memory. And they were a lot more effective at it, too!
- lostlogin 10y agoDon't be forgetting Bosnia (I assume you were referencing WW2). And while the war crimes were nowhere near the same scale, Bush did make a few uncomfortable remarks about evil, crusades and the Middle East.
- mikeash 10y agoGood point, I'm afraid I did forget, and your assumption is correct.
- im4w1l 10y agoISIS is committing genocide against Christian minorities right now.
- nixos 10y agoBut did the UN ever stop a World War from breaking out? Practically, even had the UN been built instead of the League, World War 2 probably would have still happened (Italy was on the Detente side in World War 1 and would have vetoed any anti-Germany resolution). I think it's just that: 1. A weakened Europe has nothing left to fight over, and any war between two European countries would have resulted in the Soviet Union sweeping through, swallowing them all up 2. Even the "winning" side would be devastated due to Nuclear weapons. 3. Land has much less importance in a service/technology economy. Look at Singapore, for example.
- jcranmer 10y agoThe Marshall Plan, the ECC (predecessor to the EU), NATO, and the Warsaw Pact were designed in large part to bind the European countries into alliances to make war between them unthinkable. This did result in the Cold War, where both NATO and the Warsaw Pact lived in fear that the other side was ready to invade across the Iron Curtain any second, but MAD probably played a big part in restraining tensions between the two sides in war. The other thing that happened after WWII, which probably has a bigger impact on the lack of war, was that, rather than deciding which countries gets which land by plebiscites, the people who lived on the wrong side of the borders were simply deported en masse. Deportation of the Poles from Lwów, the Germans from Stettin, or the Finns from Karelia did a lot to dampen irredentist claims to those lands.
- yk 10y agoWhat about the Cuban missile crises, Kennedy did emphasize the UN security council framework as means to verify withdraw of Soviet missiles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis#Crisis_ends https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis#Crisis_en...
- Grishnakh 10y agoWhat they really need is a way of reforming these things (namely the EU), instead of it being a "love it or leave it" type of affair. This is one of the big problems with human-created bureaucracies: there's no easy and effective way to reform them, so people end up either abandoning them (e.g. Brexit, various independence movements or revolutions) or they become usurped by some better competitor (e.g. IBM being pushed out of the PC business, American automakers losing to foreign competition) or they end up collapsing (e.g. DEC being split up and sold in chunks, or the Roman Empire falling apart). It seems to be a constant that larger human organizations are simply impossible to reform effectively, so we're stuck with chaos. I don't think there's a solution for this, short of genetically-engineering humans to work better together, or else we would have found it over the past couple of millennia.
- sabarn01 10y agoThe roman empire Lasted 600+ years so I have trouble using it as a comparison.
- swasheck 10y agothey just don't make these things like they used to, do they?
- specialist 10y agoIn name only. The Roman Empire constantly reinvented itself.
- yuhong 10y agoSometimes they are flawed even beforehand. Notice how fast US manufacturing declined after Japan beat them. I think part of the problem in this case is arrogance.
- specialist 10y agoI anticipate that Brexit will be used to initiate overdue, broadly agreed upon reforms. Then everyone can save face and kiss and make up. Introspection driven change is hard for every organization. Sometimes you just need a tantrum or external stimulus.
- EliRivers 10y agoIs the EU that ineffective? Some of its greatest triumphs are invisible because they don't exist. I know someone who used to handle transporting goods around Europe and experienced the reduction of paperwork and inspection and costs and delays and so on, until he ended up with basically none. He says all the troubles he used to have that no longer exist utterly dwarf anything new. I don't have much actual evidence, though.
- 7952 10y agoThe current hostility to standardisation and regulation seems a little strange to me as a programmer. Everything we do is dependant on having a reliable standard of how things are supposed to work. Obviously compulsion is bad, but without the EU we would still have compulsion. Instead of one required standard we would have hundreds which would need to be checked at borders.
- googletazer 10y agoThese international institutions are not visibly working for the vast majority of the electorate though. The British working class finally voted for their interests and of course they've been vilified from the top for it. All these institutions have allowed for is centralization of power under one ruler/representative instead of dozen smaller ones.
- tormeh 10y agoYou don't understand how the EU works. There is a parliament and a central bureaucracy, yes, but 80% of it is just leaders of national governments sitting in a surveillance-proof room hashing out deals. There are legitimate complaints against how the EU is structured, but this is not one of them.
- notJim 10y ago> These international institutions are not visibly working for the vast majority of the electorate though. This is cleary true, but it doesn't follow that the right solution is to quit the union rather than reforming it. There are more options than rabid nationalism vs total financialization.
- __jal 10y ago> British working class finally voted for their interests That's a funny way of defining 'interests'.
- 7952 10y agoThe raison d'etre for these kind of institutions is precisely to centralise power. So that matters of wider community importance can be agreed upon collectively and standardised. And we absolutely do have issues that need to be solved at a continental level. The problem is that sometimes those institutions overreach into areas that should be handled at a lower level. Arguably the British Parliament is more guilty of this than the EU and has control of things that are much more important to everyday life.
- krylon 10y ago> Yeah, just watching the news, it's becoming more and more apparent that people are so far removed from the horrors of WWI and WWII that they don't understand why we created the international institutions we did. It is sad it only takes such a short time for people to forget. I have met a couple of people who have experienced World War II, although most of them were only children at the time. I listened to stories of being woken in the middle of the night by sirens, and then spending the rest of the night in a bunker, unable to sleep, constantly being shaken by explosions. I cannot imagine what that must be like, but I know that I would not wish that on anyone. Somebody once said that the only thing we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history. So far, it looks like whoever said it was right.