I read what mikeash is saying as a sort of extension of one of the guiding principles behind the moderation of HN: default to assuming that others have good int

I read what mikeash is saying as a sort of extension of one of the guiding principles behind the moderation of HN: default to assuming that others have good intentions. The extension being, let's not immediately assume that these researchers have made a basic error, especially on the basis of a brief article. You can have a healthy skepticism while still showing professional respect.