5 ms·
IMO an appeal to authority is a perfectly reasonable response to an assumption of incompetence. It's tiresome to always see comments assuming that such-and-suc
by mikeash 10y ago
IMO an appeal to authority is a perfectly reasonable response to an assumption of incompetence.
It's tiresome to always see comments assuming that such-and-such science is flawed because a mainstream news article doesn't spell out every single detail.
If it were phrased more neutrally, like "I'm amazed that this stuff can be contained without any contamination for hundreds of millions of years, how do they know that it works that way?" I wouldn't have a problem with it. Start assuming that you've missed something, not the scientist who does this for a living. Maybe the scientist has missed something, they're certainly not perfect, but to me it's ridiculous and counterproductive to be "worried" about the results of years of professional work based on one popular article and five minutes of thought (if that).
- jdmichal 10y agoIf your complaint is not the message, but rather the phrasing, then I'd say that you're not being very charitable.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's both. The phrasing contains a message of "these scientists didn't consider this obvious problem."
- jdmichal 10y agoThat's fair. To the point, this person [0] doesn't seem to be having any issues with downvotes, even though the comment raises the same basic issue -- the reliability of the crystalline entrapment. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12186872 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12186872
- dpark 10y agoIn fairness, that comment was phrased as "I don't understand this, I'd like to know more" rather than "These guys are clearly making a mistake". Relevant part from the comment you linked: "My question is if the salt completely stopped all diffusion over the last billion years. Maybe somebody here can answer." If you don't understand something and say so, you sound far less arrogant and condescending.
- IanDrake 10y agoNo Mike, it doesn't contain that message. My message is that you, the reader, should consider that this "obvious problem" is a substantial one and that the entire premise of this measurement is based on a particular understanding of the ageing process of air in a salt crystal over time.
- mikeash 10y agoWhen you say that this understanding "seems to assume" this, you're pretty strongly implying that there aren't any good reasons to think it's true. Maybe you just meant to say that it's based on that idea, rather than assuming it?
- talmand 10y agoI reserve the right to question the competency of anyone at any time concerning any topic, whether they are considered an expert or not. I'd rather that have that attitude than having "he knows what he's doing so he must be right" way of thinking.
- mikeash 10y agoAnd I'd rather have "I know way less about this stuff than they do, so until I see evidence otherwise I'll assume problems I see are due to my lack of understanding, not theirs" than either of those. I don't have a problem with skepticism or questioning competency. I do have a problem with the attitude that a few minutes of thought and an obvious objection is sufficient to start questioning competency.
- talmand 10y agoAt what point would you start asking questions then? Because questioning anyone about their work is us asking for them to show us how they are right. That is questioning their competency on the topic at hand instead of just accepting what they say at face value. I won't apologize for requesting someone to show me how they are right about a topic I know little or nothing about because the simple fact that I know little or nothing of the topic doesn't let me understand they know what they are talking about. Lots of experts get things wrong all the time. If we just accept the results of experts without questioning then how do we know they are wrong? Wait for another expert to take notice and bother to care to check?
- nzjrs 10y agoGive us an example of something you are an expert in, and we can submit our most shallow tedious questions. It should be fun!
- talmand 10y agoI get them every day already. I, for one, am not offended by it. EDIT: actually, I'm exaggerating here. I don't get them every day literally, but I encounter them quite a bit.
- engi_nerd 10y agoI read what mikeash is saying as a sort of extension of one of the guiding principles behind the moderation of HN: default to assuming that others have good intentions. The extension being, let's not immediately assume that these researchers have made a basic error, especially on the basis of a brief article. You can have a healthy skepticism while still showing professional respect.
- mikeash 10y agoYes, exactly. I'm not saying they're right, I just find it crazy to come up with an obvious objection and present it as "this is wrong" rather than "how did they overcome this?"
- baddox 10y agoThe reason that an appeal to authority is a fallacy is that the deliverer of an argument is irrelevant to the validity of that argument. If an expert makes an argument that is invalid (i.e. doesn't logically demonstrate the conclusion), we may still hold some faith in the argument, because perhaps the expert made some omissions or mistakes in presenting the argument. But we still ought to recognize that the conclusion has not actually been demonstrated as the logical implication of the premises. Obviously the language I'm using in the previous paragraphs applies to formal logic. As with all formal fallacies, they are not so easy to discuss with precision when we're talking about informal arguments (like scientific papers and studies).