3 ms·
The OP makes the false assumption that the goal of the teaching is to generate other experts. That may be true of some courses at some schools, but I would say
by sandworm101 10y ago
The OP makes the false assumption that the goal of the teaching is to generate other experts. That may be true of some courses at some schools, but I would say that most teaching does not involve trying to turn a student into an expert.
For instance, I am a lawyer. I am an expert in certain areas of law. I teach/sell a lecture on intellectual property law, mostly to startups full of young people who don't know IP from IP addresses. I have no intention of turning them into IP experts let alone lawyers. That's not why they hire me. My job is to give them a taste of some basic rules, to give them enough knowledge so they can spot some red flags. And I'm there to answer specific questions, to address those red flags. That;s most teaching. You want the expert to relate a tiny piece of their knowledge, the focused bit you actually need, so that you don't have to spend years at law school. Half of the task is relating knowledge, the other half the selection of which knowledge to relate. The expert then goes away to continue learning in their field, returning as needed to keep you abreast of changes. The relationship remains asymmetrical.