3 ms·
Ideally you should re-implement the algorithm based on the description in the paper to verify that the description of the algorithm is correct. You should also
by dagw 10y ago
Ideally you should re-implement the algorithm based on the description in the paper to verify that the description of the algorithm is correct. You should also test with your own data to make sure that the algorithm works on all reasonable data and not only on some provided cherry picked data. If you can't get the expected results with your own implementation and your own data then the results aren't reproduced.
- studentrob 10y agoGreat points, thanks!
- eru 10y agoYes. So being able to rerun with the same code and same inputs to get the same outputs is a lower bar. Many papers don't meet even that bar. (Mostly because they don't publish code nor data; and academic code is often a horrible mess, and the code was mucked around with between different stages of running.)