4 ms·
My only concern is around the lack of ability for businesses to respond or request any level of verification that a person actually did business with them. The
by brightball 10y ago
My only concern is around the lack of ability for businesses to respond or request any level of verification that a person actually did business with them. The BBB at least contacts the business and oversees a process for resolution (documenting the entire thing).
I personally know multiple business owners who've dealt with threats from customers who will go and write a bad review if they don't simply bow to demands. Medical offices are another issue entirely because many medical professional don't even know if they are allowed to respond to complaints due to HIPAA.
I know one who even had a bad review from a phone call from a woman that simply called and yelled at them for not getting free service. It was their first and only review in years. Never even set foot in the building.
People are basically given permission to hang a sign on your front door that you're not allowed to take down.
I'm all for reviews and feedback but at least Amazon shows "Amazon Verified Purchase". Balance it somehow with either cross reference to the BBB or document how many years the business has existed. There are far too many businesses who've been open 10+ years with thousands of customers that have never felt the necessity to leave a review.
Without verification that the person has actually a customer, it's basically just libel.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> There are far too many businesses who've been open 10+ years with thousands of customers that have never felt the necessity to leave a review. I wonder what could be a good way to incentivise this. If I like a restaurant, I'll go back multiple times. At most, I may leave a good review once. If I go to a bad place, I'm more likely to leave a bad review. Maybe businesses could integrate a "did business here $x amount of times" button, similar to a like button or a check-in that would increment next to a review. If it was your first time, it could lead straight to leaving your first review.
- retox 10y agoMy immediate thought is to have a 'universal review code' on your invoice, which somehow encodes the monetary amount of business as well as the date. Reviewers could use this code when leaving a review on a 3rd party site to prove they were a genuine customer. There's an opportunity for stalking or harassment if the business was able to correlate the code to an individual though, so the money and time might have to be bucketed. If a customer got a refund the same system could be updated to show the fact.
- franciscop 10y agoWe were thinking about giving cards with the Tripadvisor name/link to restaurants to give then only to those customers that seems specially happy; however the local restaurants where I live are really technophobic so they just saw it as overhead with no benefit.
- talmand 10y agoTechnophobic? The industry that keeps insisting on just uploading PDFs of their menus instead of maintaining a proper website? No way.
- lijason 10y agoA company that sells a POS system (like Square) could do this. They'd have a record of verified purchases, and if you input your email, similar to with Amazon purchases, they can follow up with you to ask if you want to leave a review.
- oggedintocom 10y agoOff-topic, but would Amazon have anything to lose if they completely purged all reviews by users without verified purchases? It would certainly combat the spam reviews problem.
- hayksaakian 10y agoprobably those products which are only sold 'used' and only have 0-3 reviews total. on anything with over 100 reviews, non-verified ones are just noise.
- hueving 10y ago>but would Amazon have anything to lose Potentially sales. Unfortunately they are in a spot right now where lots of normal people not aware of the fraud see a product with 2000 reviews and 4.5 stars and take that as a strong signal that it's a good buy. They are conditioned to think that 'lots of reviews == well vetted'. If suddenly the review counts plunge by 90% people might be more wary of making a purchase. They almost need to figure out a way to keep both. Maybe keep the review count for everyone but make the star rating just based on verified purchases...
- Keverw 10y agoIt'd be cool if they added a checkbox to see only verified reviews in your searches and product pages.
- mhaymo 10y agoAmazon is already weighting reviews based on whether they are verified purchases, among other features: http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/amazon-updates-customer-reviews-with-new-machine-learning-platform/ http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/amazon-updates-customer-reviews-...
- TheCowboy 10y agoCompanies are gaming verified purchases now. There are several sites that provide a service of connecting reviewers with companies who provide their products for a hefty discount with the expectation of getting a perfect review. Companies are allowed to vet your previous reviews to determine how likely you are to give a good review before giving you a discount code. If reviewers don't deliver, they stop getting discounted products, or even get banned from these sites.
- rtpg 10y agoA powerful aspect of foursquare is even if you don't check in, they've likely marked you as having been in a restaurant. Feel like Yelp could at least use this for popularity measurements
- Chrisatorain 10y agoExtremely hard to reveal these helpful page or site. I have numerous gadgets and accomplishing legitimate photo of these worked admirably and vitality keeps on being seeing about this web blog. http://www.clazwork.com/index.php http://www.clazwork.com/index.php
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mcherm 10y agoIf a person has posted a completely bogus bad review, I, as the maligned merchant, have three choices. I can ignore it. I can post a response. I can sue the person. I think it is quite reasonable for Yelp to note when merchants use the third option. As a consumer reading reviews, I learn slightly different things when I see: A: Three good reviews and one bad review; the merchant responded to the bad review and their response sounds well-reasoned. B. Three good reviews (one deleted review, but I can't see that) and one note from Yelp stating that the merchant has used the legal system to suppress reviews. I do think it is important that since Yelp (not a customer) is making the statement that the legal threat was used, that Yelp take reasonable steps to ensure the legal threat actually occurred. Otherwise, a malicious user could falsely report receiving legal threats from a business as a way to harm their reputation.