10 ms·
My interest lies in why is the baseline so high in the first place? 2.5%/y sounds like an unacceptable risk , considering how devastating divorce is for men by
by antisthenes 10y ago
My interest lies in why is the baseline so high in the first place?
2.5%/y sounds like an unacceptable risk , considering how devastating divorce is for men by design (in the USA, at least)
- sokoloff 10y agoAn unacceptable risk, compared to what? Never marrying? Living comes with a 100% chance of dying.
- tamana 10y agoYes, compared to never marrying, maybe paying child support but not alimony, or compared to getting sterilized.
- sokoloff 10y agoI don't think that 2.5% is evenly distributed (as in, every year each couple pulls a ball from a lotto machine with 39 green and 1 red ball in it). I know my own chance isn't 0%, but I'm confident that it's lower than average. I choose to be married to my wife and to raise our kids in that framework. It's not easy every day, but it's absolutely an acceptable risk, IMO.
- autokad 10y agoi heard there's a lot of truth in the '7 year itch' milestone, but I havent seen the #s
- enave 10y agoYes but there's no alternative to living, so it's not a factor to consider.
- rhino369 10y agoThat the average for all marriages, but certain groups account for a disproportionate amount of divorces. The rate is a lot lower if you take out groups like that: under 20 when married, shotgun weddings, the already divorced, poorly educated, etc. IIRC, latinos who marry under the age 18 have an 80% 5-year divorce rate. I'd heard people say a 20% lifetime chance of divorce if you are a middle class, educated, non-divorcee, and over 25. But I can't vouch.
- drumdance 10y agoI've seen similar numbers. I'd be curious to see how becoming an entrepreneur affects this. Practically every entrepreneur I know over the age of 40 has divorced.
- faddat 10y agoEntrepeneurship killed a significant relationship of mine. It was entirely about money, she felt that I should continue to pursue my former profession, which provided meager, but stable income. I was thinking about her and my future, which would require more than meager, stable income could provide. Society hates entrepreneurship and that is why it is not a popular track: you need really thick skin to pursue it.
- themaninthedark 10y agoIt's not about the money or lack of but the risk vs reward. Most males are risk takers where as most females are risk adverse(the why is many fold and not just limited to humans or even mammals). My wife would hate it if I wanted to start a company, if she couldn't see a solid plan. If she could see the opportunity but more importantly the roadmap she would be on board.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoBut it's not just the uneducated that have high divorce rates. When I worked on Wall Street people there referred to their first wife as "my first wife" ... when they were still married to her! The expectation that everyone at the firm would eventually burn through 2 or 3 spouses was bizarre to me.
- JamesBarney 10y agoIt doesn't seem that bizarre. If I called my current wife my first wife I doubt I'd still be on wife one.
- CobrastanJorji 10y agoWell, wait, you have to measure that against not marrying in the first place, which I presume also comes with pros and cons. The question is whether ExpectedValue(staying single) > ExpectedValue(Getting married given the risk with risk of divorce). I assume the answer is different for different people.
- foxylad 10y agoGood question, but I'm not sure why you included the gender distinction. Do you think divorce is less devastating for women, or that risk of divorce is more of a factor for men?
- blawson 10y agoI think they mean how resources are split after a divorce, where courts are viewed as being more favourable to women. For example I think women are more likely to keep children, whereas the men will pay alimony to support them. If there are no kids the resource split might be more equitable. [edit] Also see further down: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12184148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12184148
- kaitai 10y agoCourts are more favorable to women in some ways, but the economic consequences are generally worse for women. "Worse" and "better" all depends on what endpoint you're looking at, just like all those studies on cholesterol (do you want to lower cholesterol or not die from heart problems?) -- do you want the alimony now or the overall financial health?
- zaroth 10y agoAccording to the 2010 Census only 3% of Americans receiving spousal benefits were men. This is after splitting the estate "equitably". So I really don't understand what you mean by economic consequences are generally worse for women? 97% of the time it's the man's wages being garnished.
- moseandre 10y agoYou are simplifying to wage garnishing. Probably the parent comment is intimating things like loss of socioeconomic position due to the divorce. If marriages are financially unequal in many cases, fundamentally, then divorce shows that too. But the consequences are like, how well you fare after versus before... the schoolteacher and the banker divorce, and which can maintain the social connections?