9 ms·
> The big factor, Harvard sociology professor Alexandra Killewald found, is the husband's employment status. For the past four decades, she discovered, husbands
by koolba 10y ago
> The big factor, Harvard sociology professor Alexandra Killewald found, is the husband's employment status. For the past four decades, she discovered, husbands who aren’t employed full time have a 3.3 percent chance of getting divorced in any given year, compared with 2.5 percent for husbands employed full time. In other words, their marriages are one-third more likely to break up.
Interesting. I'd be curious to see how the hours spent at work impact that number.
Specifically, do longer hours away at the office lead to a more stable marriage? Will having a second (or third!) job increase my chances of maintaining a nuclear family?
- niftich 10y agoPresumably, the full-time job's contribution to financial security is the driver of this indicator, rather than its contribution to lack of facetime between spouses. But as these are confounding variables -- they correlate inversely -- it makes testing it difficult.
- ethanbond 10y agoI imagine there are a lot factors. Time spent together skyrocketing, financial instability causing stress, and the fact that a lot of men tie their identity to their employment so strongly. Becoming unemployed is immensely turbulent in pretty much every way.
- LA_Banker 10y ago>and the fact that a lot of men tie their identity to their employment so strongly. That's a really interesting point, especially in light of the study pointing out that it's moreso job status that's a risk factor than money problems. One would normally think the two would go hand-in-hand in terms of a divorce autopsy. But as you (and the study) point out, there's very much distinct.
- Thedis 10y agoI am making $340 to $350 per hour by online working on facebook. i was jobless a year ago , but now i am getting my own salary by doing this online job. This salary is enough for me to meet my expences. I am really thankful to God. If you want to make this salary like my , you can check my details.⤵ CLICK THIS LINKHERE HERE===>>>>>>> www.WageNeT9.ℂom
- acangiano 10y ago> a lot of men tie their identity to their employment so strongly I wonder if the other side of the coin isn't that wives tend to respect their husbands less when these earn less than they do. It could be because it violates a social norm caused by society's gender role expectations. Research found that even employed men who earn a bit less than their wives are affected by higher divorce rate. So we can cast these men as insecure and emasculated, or it could be a mix of both men and women's reaction to the situation, along with many other variables that you've hinted at.
- anonbiocoward 10y ago> it violates a social norm This story hit me pretty hard. While I was in medical school, my wife's family, especially her mother, routinely encouraged her to divorce me. We had two small kids, and I had gone on job interviews and seen the offers I was getting without a graduate degree, despite a BS in physics and 7 years of experience. It was obvious to everyone that medical school was the right course of action in the long term but it would be hard. I didn't realize it would get harder when her family started jumping on any opportunity to point out my "temporary financial embarrassment". On a day-to-day basis, she was working 40 hours a week and while med school was paid for, and I had a small stipend, her paycheck was better. And cognitively, she understood that. But her brothers and mother, and eventually her father told her to "get rid of him". We stuck it out. They wonder why we don't fly across country to visit them much...
- vonklaus 10y agoInteresting. Clearly there were hardships involved and getting an MD is a non-trivial financial and time commitment. However, at least in popular culture, an MD is a highly respected career path and often the joked about target for 'gold diggers'. Sure, it isn't marry a student, but it is a pretty well regarded track socially, financially and educationally.
- reitanqild 10y agoImpressed that you and your wife stuck together! Bet your kids will be too. My father used to quote someone that "the best a man can do for his kids are to love their mother." And: I feel sorry that this can actually happen to people.
- thrway2670 10y agoHaving your wife discover she's a lesbian after 15 years is another way. Ask how I know. Never again.
- DominikR 10y ago> and the fact that a lot of men tie their identity to their employment so strongly At least this part is nothing new. Men have always (up until now and I'd argue that this is still true today) tied their identity, masculinity and even self-worth as a human being to their profession as society expected men contribute the necessary resources to their families in order to support wife & children. If a man couldn't provide the resources anymore he usually lost his value and function to his family and society.
- DefaultUserHN 10y agoWill your kids still love you even though you can't provide for them? Will they look down on you because they're starving and you are not competent enough to feed them? When they look around, they see other dads being able to feed their own kids, and they ask themselves, "Why is it that my dad can not feed them?" Will your kids look down on you because of this? Is the patriarchy forcing men to tie their identity to their ability to provide for their own kids? Or do men understands naturally that if they can't provide for their kids, then they must be pretty incompetent, and then they feels bad about it, naturally, because they love their kids. And then their kids look down on them, because "all the other dads can feed their children, when can't my dad feed me?"
- MollyR 10y agoI was wondering why men tie their identity to employment so much. Is it because society expects them to be providers, and ridicules men who don't ?
- ethanbond 10y agoI'd assume so. As much as HN likes to ridicule the notion of "the patriarchy," this is a component of it that's awfully harmful to men.
- karmajunkie 10y agoYes absolutely. Sexism harms everyone.
- oldmanjay 10y agoThere is a vast difference between ridiculing something and not accepting it on faith solely because very passionate people make assertions about it.
- ethanbond 10y agoSure, but that's my point. I think a lot of men on here have probably felt this effect. If it's not from "the patriarchy," or something similar by a different name, then what is it from? You don't have to think that, say, women's fashion changes faster than men's fashion because "the patriarchy!", but it takes some serious aloofness not to see that male dominance in society trickles down to some very strange places indeed. As an example: that a man's employment status is the largest factor in his marital success.
- klipt 10y agoI think plenty of people agree that Traditional Gender Roles cause problems for men and women who don't conform to them. But not everyone agrees that Traditional Genders Roles should be called "the patriarchy", because that has connotations that men (even the men being hurt by Traditional Gender Roles) are in control, which feels like blaming the victim.
- tamana 10y agoHow does the math go when you compound those rates over 30years?
- codemanneil 10y agoBased only on intuition, my guess is no. It seems more likely that husbands not working full time are more likely to have financial instability, which would be a cause of stress on the relationship.
- tlrobinson 10y agoFrom the second paragraph: "A Harvard University study suggests that neither financial strains [...] is typically the main reason for a split."
- LA_Banker 10y agoThe headline of the story itself literally reads "Don’t Blame Divorce on Money."
- rogerdpack 10y agoThis is a tricky one. Once again it could just be correlation, and "people who can't hold down a job" are more likely to get divorced, not necessarily "some person who gets fired" is more likely to get divorced, non causal as it were...
- antisthenes 10y agoMy interest lies in why is the baseline so high in the first place? 2.5%/y sounds like an unacceptable risk , considering how devastating divorce is for men by design (in the USA, at least)
- sokoloff 10y agoAn unacceptable risk, compared to what? Never marrying? Living comes with a 100% chance of dying.
- tamana 10y agoYes, compared to never marrying, maybe paying child support but not alimony, or compared to getting sterilized.
- sokoloff 10y agoI don't think that 2.5% is evenly distributed (as in, every year each couple pulls a ball from a lotto machine with 39 green and 1 red ball in it). I know my own chance isn't 0%, but I'm confident that it's lower than average. I choose to be married to my wife and to raise our kids in that framework. It's not easy every day, but it's absolutely an acceptable risk, IMO.
- autokad 10y agoi heard there's a lot of truth in the '7 year itch' milestone, but I havent seen the #s
- enave 10y agoYes but there's no alternative to living, so it's not a factor to consider.
- rhino369 10y agoThat the average for all marriages, but certain groups account for a disproportionate amount of divorces. The rate is a lot lower if you take out groups like that: under 20 when married, shotgun weddings, the already divorced, poorly educated, etc. IIRC, latinos who marry under the age 18 have an 80% 5-year divorce rate. I'd heard people say a 20% lifetime chance of divorce if you are a middle class, educated, non-divorcee, and over 25. But I can't vouch.
- caf 10y agoWell, there's been at least one study purporting to show that longer commute times correlate with a higher chance of relationship breakdown, so that would tend to push the other way. http://www.scienceofrelationships.com/home/2014/1/2/longer-commutes-linked-to-higher-likelihood-of-divorce.html http://www.scienceofrelationships.com/home/2014/1/2/longer-c...
- finid 10y agoStatistically, especially for a study of this sort, a difference of 0.8% is not that significant.
- geezerjay 10y ago> Interesting. I'd be curious to see how the hours spent at work impact that number. I'de more interested in comparing these percent changes with the sample's margin of error. Extrapolating conclusions based on a deviation of 0.8% sounds an awful lot like grasping at straws.
- camelNotation 10y ago3.3 percent is still very, very small. That's encouraging.
- DefaultUserHN 10y ago>Specifically, do longer hours away at the office lead to a more stable marriage? Will having a second (or third!) job increase my chances of maintaining a nuclear family? Well, obviously, if you work 24/7, you'll have the perfect marriage. LOL.